Nikiski senior Ian Johnson (8) sheds Monroe Catholic defensive back Parker Glaves in the third quarter of Saturday’s Division III game at Nikiski High School. (Photo by Joey Klecka/Peninsula Clarion)

Nikiski senior Ian Johnson (8) sheds Monroe Catholic defensive back Parker Glaves in the third quarter of Saturday’s Division III game at Nikiski High School. (Photo by Joey Klecka/Peninsula Clarion)

Missed chances cost Nikiski in loss to Monroe

After a miscommunication on a two-point scoring attempt led to a failed chance to take the lead midway through the fourth quarter of Saturday’s game with Monroe, the Nikiski Bulldogs knew the game wasn’t over yet, not with eight minutes left to play.

However, missed chances and opportunities held Nikiski back and the Monroe Rams sweated through several late scares to escape with a 7-6 nonconference victory in Nikiski.

Nikiski drops to 0-2 overall while Monroe moves to 1-1.

The biggest moves of the day were made by Nikiski senior Ian Johnson, who knew he was in for a rough day before the first snap. Johnson woke up Saturday morning with chest congestion, coughing, a feverish feeling, but like any star athlete, he was prepared to roll with the punches.

“I couldn’t even sleep last night,” Johnson said. “I had to get over it, and play my hardest today.”

He did more than that as he put the Bulldogs on his back, rushing for 156 yards on 32 carries and scoring Nikiski’s only points of the day.

“We have only three guys that have played all four years, so I’ve got to play my hardest no matter what,” Johnson said.

After a scoreless first half that saw both teams trade turnovers and missed fourth downs, Monroe Catholic struck first in the third quarter on a 57-yard pass by quarterback Trae Puryear, who took advantage on a missed tackle by Nikiski to find Isaac Minnema streaking downfield.

Nikiski then mounted a massive 95-yard, 14-play drive that included 12 carries alone by Johnson, which ended with a 4-yard push into the end zone by Johnson.

The Bulldogs opted to go for two to take a lead, but the botched play saw Johnson inundated with Monroe defenders, and the Rams took over with their lead still intact.

From there, the Rams did all they could to hold off Johnson.

Puryear finished 19 for 31 for 177 passing yards and a touchdown, while throwing two picks as well.

In a defensive lockdown, Nikiski made the most headway with 263 total yards of offense — including 194 ground yards on 48 carries — while Monroe scratched out 207 of their own yards.

First-year Monroe coach Marcus Cogley said the victory was important in getting the Rams’ season going after the opening week loss.

“This is huge,” Cogley said. “I saw a lot of improvement, lots of change … it means the world to come down here and beat Nikiski.”

The biggest break of the game occurred with just over a minute left with Monroe backed up to its own 5-yard line thanks to a pair of penalties. Puryear surveyed from the pocket for a brief moment, then tried running the ball out, but was faced with several Nikiski defenders, who pushed Puryear back to the goal line for a sack.

While the Bulldogs began calling for a safety, the referees instead called the play dead on a forward momentum decision, putting the ball at the 1-yard line.

“So close,” said Nikiski head coach Paul Nelson. “That was an intense moment for sure.”

From there, Monroe used a screen play to gain 6 yards, moving them out of immediate threat of a safety, then punted to put Nikiski on the Monroe 40-yard line.

Nikiski got one last shot at a game-winning drive, starting with a miraculous 42-yard catch from Eiter to Cody Handley that put the Bulldogs 18 yards from the end zone, but in his haste, Eiter promptly was picked off by Higbee on last time.

“It just seemed like the clock was getting away from us, so we tried picking the pace up a bit,” Nelson said. “There was a lot of pressure.”

Monroe received two huge breaks earlier in the fourth quarter when Nikiski got the ball back with five minutes to play and a one-point game. The Bulldogs got to midfield but were facing third down when Bulldogs senior Tyler Olson took the ball on a pitch and was immediately swarmed by Monroe defenders.

Olson stayed down after the play with an injury and had to be carted off the field on a stretcher to a waiting ambulance, and the lengthy break in the action all but subdued Nikiski’s charge. Cogley said the injury to Olson helped to quell the momentum that Nikiski had built up to that point.

“You never want to see a player get hurt, but were able to come together and keep them out of the end zone,” Cogley said.

The Rams also got two crucial interceptions in the final 80 seconds of the game, when Nikiski had two drives end in the hands of defensive back Jordan Higbee.

“He’s a stud corner,” Cogley said about Higbee. “He’s just a sophomore, but he’s excellent at tracking the football.”

The Ram were fresh off handing Redington its first ever varsity win in program history with a 54-40 loss, so Nelson was pleased that his Bulldogs only gave up a single scoring play in 48 minutes.

“Our defense played lights out,” Nelson said. “Definitely hats off to the defense.”

The Bulldogs committed 10 penalties that backed them up 62 yards throughout the day,

In his first varsity game at quarterback, sophomore Michael Eiter finished 4 for 10 with 69 passing yards and four interceptions.

“It’s the first time (Eiter) has started a game, so you’ve got to expect stuff like that to go down,” Nelson said. “We’ll clean it up, but yeah, a little bit of a heartbreaker.”

Nikiski will travel to play non-division opponent Ketchikan next Friday night.

Rams 7, Bulldogs 6

Monroe 0 0 7 0 —7

Nikiski 0 0 0 6 —6

Third Quarter

Mon — Minnema 57 pass from Puryear (Higbee kick), 10:14

Fourth Quarter

Nik — Johnson 4 run (run failed), 8:18

Nik Mon

First downs 17 6

Rushing 48-194 18-30

Pass yds 69 177

Total yds 263 207

Comp-att-int 4-10-4 19-31-2

Return yds 23 58

Punts 2 4

Fumbles-lost 2-2 0-0

Penalties-yds 10-62 11-90

INDIVIDUAL STATISTICS

Rushing — Nikiski: Johnson 32-156, Olson 10-22, Eiter 6-(-12), Handley 4-28. Monroe: Gray 7-34, Nicholson 5-(-1), #3 2-2, Garcia 2-1, Puryear 2-(-6).

Passing — Nikiski: Eiter 4-10-4—69. Monroe: Puryear 19-31-2—177.

Receiving — Nikiski: Handley 1-42, Olson 2-17, Johnson 1-10. Monroe: Minnema 4-87, Garcia 5-26, Ortiz 1-6, #3 2-9, Higbee 5-23, Gray 2-26.

Nikiski senior Tyler Olson (14) tackles Monroe Catholic running back Isaac Garcia in the first half Saturday at Nikiski High School. (Photo by Joey Klecka/Peninsula Clarion)

Nikiski senior Tyler Olson (14) tackles Monroe Catholic running back Isaac Garcia in the first half Saturday at Nikiski High School. (Photo by Joey Klecka/Peninsula Clarion)

Nikiski sophomore quarterback Michael Eiter wards off a Monroe Catholic lineman Saturday at Nikiski High School. (Photo by Joey Klecka/Peninsula Clarion) Nikiski sophomore quarterback Michael Eiter wards off a Monroe Catholic lineman Saturday at Nikiski High School. (Photo by Joey Klecka/Peninsula Clarion)

Nikiski sophomore quarterback Michael Eiter wards off a Monroe Catholic lineman Saturday at Nikiski High School. (Photo by Joey Klecka/Peninsula Clarion) Nikiski sophomore quarterback Michael Eiter wards off a Monroe Catholic lineman Saturday at Nikiski High School. (Photo by Joey Klecka/Peninsula Clarion)

Nikiski junior Cody Handley escapes the grasp of a Monroe Catholic tackler Saturday at Nikiski High School. (Photo by Joey Klecka/Peninsula Clarion)

Nikiski junior Cody Handley escapes the grasp of a Monroe Catholic tackler Saturday at Nikiski High School. (Photo by Joey Klecka/Peninsula Clarion)

More in Sports

tease
Chugiak softball wins Bash on the Bay

The Chugiak softball team defeated Dimond 6-2 on Saturday to win the… Continue reading

tease
SoHi, Kenai, Homer baseball collect wins

The Soldotna baseball team defeated host Redington 12-8 on Saturday to move… Continue reading

The Kenai Central boys soccer teams mobs Joe Hamilton (center) after Hamilton scored the game-winning penalty kick in the Peninsula Conference championship game Saturday, May 21, 2022, at Nikiski High School in Nikiski, Alaska. (Photo by Jeff Helminiak/Peninsula Clarion)
Kenai soccer sweeps Peninsula Conference titles

The Kenai Central girls and boys soccer teams swept the Peninsula Conference… Continue reading

Seward's Tommy Cronin competes in the triple jump at the Region 3/Division II meet Friday, May 20, 2022, at Ed Hollier Field at Kenai Central High School in Kenai, Alaska. (Photo by Jeff Helminiak/Peninsula Clarion)
Area track athletes punch early tickets to state

A few area athletes wrapped up automatic berths to the state track… Continue reading

tease
Kenai baseball rolls past Grace Christian

The visiting Kenai Central baseball team defeated Grace Christian on Friday 18-4… Continue reading

Soldotna's Hamilton Hunt rises above the crowd for a header Friday, May 20, 2022, at the Peninsula Conference soccer tournament at Nikiski High School in Nikiski, Alaska. (Photo by Jeff Helminiak/Peninsula Clarion)
Kenai girls, boys; SoHi boys; Homer girls soccer earn state berths

The Kenai Central girls and boys, Soldotna boys and Homer girls earned… Continue reading

tease
Homer goes 2-1 in Bash on the Bay

The Homer softball team went 2-1 on the opening day of the… Continue reading

tease
Colony softball nips Homer

The host Homer softball team lost a nonconference contest 4-3 in four… Continue reading

tease
SoHi baseball topples Houston

The visiting Soldotna baseball team cruised past Houston 19-0 in eight innings… Continue reading

Most Read