Two Black-capped Chickadees visit a feeder in Soldotna on Wednesday. (Photo by Jeff Helminiak/Peninsula Clarion)

Two Black-capped Chickadees visit a feeder in Soldotna on Wednesday. (Photo by Jeff Helminiak/Peninsula Clarion)

Refuge Notebook: To feed or not to feed the birds


As the snow continues to pile up, I have had some unwanted guests at my bird feeder. A cow moose and her stubborn little calf have been visiting in the cloak of darkness and eating all my bird seed.

My intent was to feed birds, not moose, so for now I have suspended my feeding operation until I get a better system they cannot reach. Times can get tough, but moose are better off foraging on their own than supplementing with sunflower seeds. However, there can be unintended consequences when we dabble with things like supplemental feeding.

My break from watching the birds gave me a chance to dig into the research and address some of those nagging questions that always come up about feeding birds. Does it help them? Will they become dependent on my feeder? Will it shortstop birds and keep them from migrating?

I found more substantive research on the issue since the last time I did this exercise, but you be the judge and jury as to its appropriateness for your yard. There are several very nice papers describing methods to measure if fed birds become dependent on the artificial food source. It basically comes down to how you measure success in a wild bird.

In my mind, birds have two main goals to evaluate success. They must survive from year to year. This is pretty obvious — if you die, you failed at your mission.

Second, they must rear young to replace themselves when they do die and they must raise more than two in their lifetime if they are to grow their population or account for a percentage of their offspring not making it to rear their own young.

A paper by Egan and Brittingham in 1994 measured monthly survival rates of fed and unfed Black-capped Chickadees in Pennsylvania and found that feeding had significantly increased the short-term survival of these birds.

Brittingham and Temple had previously looked at dependency on feeders by taking feeders away from fed populations of chickadees and found that there was no difference in survival rates between fed birds that were cut off and unfed birds.

Many other researchers have documented problems associated with feeding including increased predation by both wild and domestic species, disease and parasite transmission, nontarget species congregating at supplemental feeding sites (my moose problem) and increased window strikes.

The ongoing deformed bill problem seen in chickadees in Southcentral Alaska appears to be the result of a virus and was first identified at feeders. Questions still remain as to how it is transmitted as it is also prevalent in wild populations, far from any contact with feeders (

On the pro side, many relevant papers describe the economic value of feeding, which is a multibillion dollar industry in the United States. About 40 percent of American households routinely provide food for birds.

In addition to the economic value, there are social implications to the value people derive from feeding birds because an appreciation is gained that is only possible from watching birds at close range outside their windows.

We will likely never know what goes on inside bird brains, so a definitive answer as to whether birds “decide” not to migrate because of supplemental feeding is nebulous. We do know that migrant birds like hummingbirds and sparrows that visit feeders continue to migrate and return.

Banded birds have returned to feeders up to eight years, only during migration. So we have to presume that this is not an issue.

It is obvious there are many pros and cons to this activity. I think the best way to go about this business is to make sure you are doing everything you can to protect the safety and well-being of the birds you feed.

Some people may decide against feeding, alternatively landscaping their backyard environment to support more birds “naturally.” Some do’s and don’ts to supplemental bird feeding are provided below.

1. Do not feed birds if you have a domestic cat that you allow to go outside unaccompanied.

2. Remove feeders at appropriate times in the spring to avoid unwanted visitors like bears.

3. Clean your feeders regularly to reduce disease and parasite transmission.

4. If you see sick birds or predators hanging around, pull feeders so you are not contributing to unnaturally concentrating birds.

5. In addition to the feeders, provide shrub cover or brush piles nearby, giving birds hiding spots from avian predators.

If you would like more info on best practices for feeding birds during inclement weather, this article is a good read; .

If supplemental feeding is just too much work or not your thing, but you want to create a bird friendly yard and the following link has some great info on things to consider; .

Todd Eskelin is a Wildlife Biologist at Kenai National Wildlife Refuge. Find more Refuge Notebook articles (1999-present) at or other info at

More in Sports

Refuge Notebook: Aleutian Islands oddities can win bets

Want to win a beer bet? Ask someone the location of the… Continue reading

A wheelchair accessible path leads to the Russian River Falls on Sunday, May 24, 2020 in Cooper Landing, Alaska. (Photo by Megan Pacer/Homer News)
Out of the Office: Trails that wind, hearts that find

As with a lot of things, Alaska has been lucky to be… Continue reading

Nikiski’s America Jeffreys celebrates a point with her team Friday, Sept. 27, 2019, against ACS at Nikiski High School. (Photo by Joey Klecka/Peninsula Clarion)
Nikiski’s Jeffreys to play basketball at Bushnell

Staff report America Jeffreys, a 2020 graduate of Nikiski High School, signed… Continue reading

Jode Sparks runs to victory in the 10-mile men’s run at the Mouth to Mouth Wild Run and Ride on Monday, May 28, 2018, at the Kenai beach. (Photo by Jeff Helminiak/Peninsula Clarion)
Races adjust to new coronavirus

Organizers have had to decide how to change their events to match the times.

The women’s field takes to the course Tuesday, July 4, 2017, at the Mount Marathon Race in Seward, Alaska. Eventual winner Allie Ostrander is to the right of Christy Marvin (1). (Photo by Jeff Helminiak/Peninsula Clarion)
Mount Marathon Race canceled for 2020

The 93rd running of the race up and down the 3,022-foot mountain is rescheduled for July 4, 2021.

Chugiak’s Tyler Huffer stiff-arms Soldotna’s Hudson Metcalf during a scrimmage Saturday, Aug. 10, 2019, at Justin Maile Field in Soldotna, Alaska. (Photo by Jeff Helminiak/Peninsula Clarion)
4 SoHi players to join college programs

A 2020 Soldotna High graduate class that was a key part of… Continue reading

(Photo provided)
Tangled Up in Blue: Blunt cuts

I cut my own hair last night. After months of new coronavirus… Continue reading

Refuge Notebook: The roles of morels

While people have been taking advantage of the abundance of morels following… Continue reading

The Kenai River can be seen from the Funny River Campground on Sunday, June 23, 2019, in Funny River, Alaska. (Photo by Erin Thompson/Peninsula Clarion)
Area fishing guides hit hard by pandemic

“If the quarantine doesn’t come off pretty soon, I think we’ll just be out of luck this year.”

Most Read