Attorney Jon Choate, left, representing the Alaska Democratic Party, and state attorney Laura Fox, discuss the ins and outs of the case after the oral arguments on Thursday as part of the Supreme Court Live event moderated by Marilyn May, center, at Kenai Central High School. (Photo by Kat Sorensen/Peninsula Clarion)

Attorney Jon Choate, left, representing the Alaska Democratic Party, and state attorney Laura Fox, discuss the ins and outs of the case after the oral arguments on Thursday as part of the Supreme Court Live event moderated by Marilyn May, center, at Kenai Central High School. (Photo by Kat Sorensen/Peninsula Clarion)

Oral arguments heard in primary ballot lawsuit

Assistant Attorney General Laura Fox and Alaska Democratic Party attorney Jon Choate were tasked with answering a simple question in front of the Alaska Supreme Court on Thursday afternoon in Kenai: “What does it matter?”

When it comes to primary election ballots, though, the question becomes more complex, and the answer could impact this year’s election cycle.

At Kenai Central High School, Chief Justice Craig Stowers, Justices Daniel Winfree, Peter Maassen, Joel Bolger and Susan Carney and an auditorium full of high school students participating in Supreme Court Live heard the almost an hour’s worth of oral arguments in a case that will determine if the Alaska Democratic Party can include independents, or non-affiliated, candidates on its primary election ballot.

The Alaska Democratic Party wants to allow people who are unaffiliated with a political party to run on the Democratic ballot, but Alaska state law requires candidates who want to run in a primary election for a political party’s nomination be registered to vote as a member of that political party, or as Chief Justice Stowers put it on Thursday, “sign on the dotted line.”

The state says it matters because a candidate who refuses to register with the party is prioritzing their desire to distance themselves from the party, rather than associating with it.

The Alaska Democratic Party argues that by choosing to run on the ballot, even if they aren’t a declared member of the party, associates the candidate with the party on the ballot.

“It’s reasonable for the state to draw a distinction between people who are willing to identify with the party publicly and people who aren’t,” Fox, representing the state, said. “Certainly, someone can register with the party and say that they don’t really believe in the party’s principles but it’s reasonable to distinguish.”

Choate argued that the state is filtering who may participate as a candidate based upon what they believe, based on their views.

“Underpinning the state’s argument is that the label by the candidate’s name, or signing the dotted line, is a proxy for idealogy,” Choate said. “It is a proxy for what the candidate believes.”

The state also argued that there may be confusion for the voters if a nonpartisan nominee is on a partisan ballot, particularly if the ballot signifies that the candidate is independent or non-affiliated.

“There are a range of different voters who have a range of different information, but it’s confusing and deceptive to call someone non-partisan if they are a partisan nominee,” Fox said.

The Alaska Supreme Court will take the arguments under advisement, but is expected to render a quick decision. The deadline for a candidate to file for this year’s primary is June 1. If the Supreme Court decides to uphold the Juneau Superior Court verdict, in which Judge Philip Pallenburg concluded that the state’s actions were a violation of the First Amendment, it would have to do it before June 1 for it to be effective in this election cycle.

Reach Kat Sorensen at ksorensen@peninsulaclarion.com

Alaska Supreme Court Justice Craig Stowers introduces the case and attorneys Jon Choate, left, and Laura Fox to an auditorium full of students before the Supreme Court Live event at Kenai Central High School in Kenai on Thursday. (Photo by Kat Sorensen/Peninsula Clarion)

Alaska Supreme Court Justice Craig Stowers introduces the case and attorneys Jon Choate, left, and Laura Fox to an auditorium full of students before the Supreme Court Live event at Kenai Central High School in Kenai on Thursday. (Photo by Kat Sorensen/Peninsula Clarion)

Attorney Jon Choate, left, representing the Alaska Democratic Party, and state attorney Laura Fox, discuss the ins and outs of the case after the oral arguments on Thursday as part of the Supreme Court Live event moderated by Marilyn May, center, at Kenai Central High School. (Photo by Kat Sorensen/Peninsula Clarion)

Attorney Jon Choate, left, representing the Alaska Democratic Party, and state attorney Laura Fox, discuss the ins and outs of the case after the oral arguments on Thursday as part of the Supreme Court Live event moderated by Marilyn May, center, at Kenai Central High School. (Photo by Kat Sorensen/Peninsula Clarion)

More in News

Kenai Fire Marshal Jeremy Hamilton is seen by one of Kenai Fire Department’s Tower trucks on Friday, Sept. 30, 2022 at Kenai Fire Department in Kenai, Alaska. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
‘Get up, get out and get safe’

Kids taught about fire safety as part of prevention effort

Bob Bird, left, chairman of the Alaskan Independence Party, and former Lt. Gov. Loren Leman make the case in favor of a state constitutional convention during a debate in Anchorage broadcast Thursday by Alaska Public Media. (Screenshot from Alaska Public Media’s YouTube channel)
Constitutional convention debate gets heated

Abortion, PFD factor into forum.

Carol Freas (right) helps a voter fill out absentee election materials in Kenai City Hall ahead of the Oct. 4 municipal election on Thursday, Sept. 29, 2022 in Kenai, Alaska. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
Absentee voting already underway

Absentee in-person voting has been made available across the borough

Graphic by Ashlyn O’Hara
Graphic by Ashlyn O’Hara
What’s on the ballot: Reapportionment, new field house, school bond

Voters will decide on ballot measures that address schools, public safety and legislative bodies

Cars line up ahead of dismissal at Mountain View Elementary School on Thursday, September 29, 2022, in Kenai, Alaska. A bond package up for consideration by Kenai Peninsula Borough voters on Oct. 4 would fund improvements to the school’s traffic flow. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
‘Critical needs’: Parking lot problems

Lack of space for pickup and drop-offs creates traffic jam at elementary school

Soldotna Elementary School Principal Dr. Austin Stevenson points out elements of the school building on Friday, Sept. 30, 2022, in Soldotna, Alaska. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
‘Critical needs’: Aging school on the brink

Renovations are cost prohibitive at Soldotna Elementary

Rep. Mary Peltola, an Alaska Democrat, delivers a speech on the U.S. House floor before Thursday’s vote approving her first bill, establishing an Office of Food Security in the Department of Veterans Affairs. It passed the House by a 376-49 vote, although its fate in the Senate is undetermined. (Screenshot from official U.S. House video)
Poll: Peltola’s a popular pol

Food for vets bill passes House, pollster says she is “the most popular figure in Alaska right now.”

A parking sign awaits the new executive director of the Alaska Permanent Fund at its Juneau headquarters, Three finalists will be interviewed for the job during a public meeting Monday by the fund’s board of trustees, who are expected to deliberate and announce the new director immediately afterward. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
Interviews, selection of new Permanent Fund CEO set for Monday

Three finalists seeking to manage $73.7B fund to appear before trustees at public meeting in Juneau

Principal Sarge Truesdell looks at cracked siding outside of Soldotna High School on Tuesday, Sept. 27, 2022, in Soldotna, Alaska. The siding is one of several projects in a bond package Kenai Peninsula voters will consider during the Oct. 4 municipal election. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
‘Critical needs’: Split siding at SoHi

The damage has been given patchwork treatment over the years

Most Read