Gravel pit group looks at reclamation, bonding

The Kenai Peninsula Borough’s working group on material sites is getting at the heart of the reason it was formed — to help resolve some of the conflicts between operators and neighbors.

Nearly every time a gravel pit operator comes before the Kenai Peninsula Borough Planning Commission for a conditional use permit approval, nearby residents show up en masse to protest. Chief among their complaints is concern that the presence of a gravel pit will reduce their property values.

“Most of the time, when we walk into the room, when we get our packet and there are gravel pits on the agenda, we know it’s going to be a long night,” said Robert Ruffner, the chairman of the material site working group and a member of the Planning Commission. “There’s typically 30 or 40 people for seven out of the 10 gravel pits that we hear.”

The Planning Commission generally has to grant the conditional use permit as long as the operator has met all the borough’s requirements, whether or not residents object. Outside city limits, the borough has no formal zoning, and so residential areas have few protections against industrial activity. The borough does have an opt-in program, called Local Option Zoning, but that requires a petition process, public meetings and assembly approval, which can take time.

The conflict between property owners and gravel pit operators is nothing new nor unique to the Kenai Peninsula. Nearly everywhere in the country, neighbors have complained to local governing bodies about incoming gravel pit operations reducing their property values. In northern Colorado, fights between neighbors and gravel pit operators have been cropping up along the Front Range as residential areas spread and more development requires more gravel, according to the Coloradoan. A county board of commissioners in Greenfield, Indiana denied a proposal for a gravel pit in December 2017 after nearly 100 people complained about the neighborhood impact, according to Indiana newspaper the Greenfield Reporter.

On Wednesday, the material site working group discussed reclamation, bonding requirements, unregulated gravel pits and impacts on property values, all related to the impacts on surrounding residents. The group has not made any recommendations yet but plans to do so by the end of May.

Gravel pit operators are not currently required to restore the environments of the pits until the material is “exhausted.” The borough’s Planning Department has suggested changing that language to “disturbed” and setting a limit of five acres of disturbed land at a time, rather than an operator being able to leave a pit unrestored for years and say they have not exhausted the material yet.

The group members debated about what standard the borough should set for reclamation and agreed to visit a pit that has been reclaimed adequately as an example. The planning department also wasn’t sure whether to set the limit at five acres per season or five acres per permit renewal, said Borough Planning Director Max Best at the meeting.

The issue of reclamation is also tied up into bonding. Most mining operations are required to post a bond to begin operations, which allows the governing body to restore an area if the operator abandons it, such as the state plugging an oil or gas well if the company fails to do it. The Planning Department suggested requiring $2,000 in bond per acre of gravel pit, which would still not cover the entire cost of reclamation, Best said. The number was just a suggestion and could be based on an engineer’s estimate instead or what the group decides on, he said.

Group member Larry Smith made the point that gravel pits are necessary, as much as they may be disliked by neighbors.

“Those same people who are complaining about the pit are living in a house that’s on a gravel pad with a gravel driveway,” he said. “So they got their gravel from somewhere. It’s just that they don’t want the gravel pit being in close proximity to them.”

The reclamation requirements would be partially intended to alleviate concerns about the long-term impacts on property values for surrounding residents. Les Crane from the borough’s assessing department explained at the meeting that the borough doesn’t take adjacent gravel pit operations into account during property assessments — in part because the borough doesn’t have the sales data from those transactions before and after the presence of a gravel pit to build a model on. Sales prices are not required to be disclosed in the state of Alaska, though the borough does get some sales prices voluntarily from buyers and sellers. In the few sales he looked at, the properties were selling for more than the assessed value. There were some reductions in property value for properties near BlueCrest Energy’s drilling pad in Anchor Point after some sale values were reported, he said.

The operations also have an impact on quality of life for neighbors, said working group member Stacy Crouse.

“These are real, the dust issues are real, the noise issues are real,” she said. “They are affecting quality of life issues for property owners. Dust from haul roads covers their property and they can’t go out and use their properties. There’s no restriction on noise levels right now other than crushers, and it’s not enjoyable to be on your own property when the gravel pits are operating.”

The Material Site Working Group is planning a public listening session on Thursday at the borough assembly chambers in Soldotna at 6 p.m. for people to voice their concerns about the material site codes. A second meeting is planned for Chapman School in Anchor Point on April 7 at 1 p.m.

Reach Elizabeth Earl at eearl@peninsulaclarion.com.

More in News

Erosion of the Kenai bluff near the Kenai Senior Center. (Photo by Aidan Curtin courtesy Scott Curtin)
Ribbon-cutting for bluff stabilization project set for June 10

The bluff has been eroding at a rate of around 3 feet per year

A bag of freshly dug razor clams is held aloft at the Ninilchik Beach in Ninilchik, Alaska, on Saturday, July 1, 2023. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
No clamming in Ninilchik or Clam Gulch this year

Adult abundance “well below” fishery thresholds on both beaches

Poppies are affixed to wreaths during a Memorial Day ceremony at Leif Hanson Memorial Park in Kenai on Monday. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
Remembering the sacrifices of the fallen

Speakers ask community to be inspired through sacrifice of service members

A fallen tree reaches onto Kalifornsky Beach Road in Soldotna, Alaska, as cars drive by on Friday, Sept. 1, 2023. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
Grants, borough to support HEA effort to mitigate dangerous trees

HEA will have permission to enter borough land and the borough’s right of way

Assembly President Brent Johnson asks questions of representatives of the Kenai Peninsula Borough School District during a joint work session of the School Board and Kenai Peninsula Borough Assembly in Soldotna, Alaska, on Tuesday, April 2, 2024. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
Borough to enter contract for asbestos flooring abatement in 3 central peninsula schools

The work will be done at Kenai Central High, Kenai Alternative High and Sterling Elementary schools

Kenai Central High School stands under clear skies in Kenai, Alaska, on Thursday, May 23, 2024. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
Borough approves contract for KCHS parking lot rehabilitation

Soldotna-based Foster Construction will be awarded the bid of $648,997 to complete the project

Central Peninsula Hospital is seen in Soldotna on Wednesday, Oct. 13, 2021. (Camille Botello/Peninsula Clarion)
Central Peninsula Hospital to host Cancer Survivor’s Day event

The event will take place Sunday, June 2 from 1 p.m. to 3 p.m.

Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion
Rep. Ben Carpenter, R-Nikiski, speaks to the joint Soldotna and Kenai chambers of commerce at the Soldotna Regional Sports Complex on Wednesday.
Carpenter gives wrap up on session as he nears end of House term

Carpenter is seeking election to state Senate District D

(from left to right) Jachin Sanchez, Carter Lemons, Rowan Mahoney, Adelyn McCorison and Taylor Rickard graduated from Ninilchik School on Monday, May 13, 2024 in Ninilchik, Alaska. Photo provided by Mattea Peters-Williamson
Ninilchik graduates 5 in 2024 commencement

The school held the ceremony Monday, May 13

Most Read