An Outdoor View: McPhee on catch-and-release

Author’s note: This column first appeared in the Clarion on Nov. 29, 2002. I’ve edited it slightly for brevity.

“The Founding Fish” is fascinating book about shad by noted non-fiction author John McPhee, who enjoys fishing for shad. In the last chapter, he takes the reader on a soul-searching quest for what’s right and what’s wrong about catch-and-release fishing.

McPhee starts the chapter by questioning why we fish. Searching the literature for answers, he quotes dozens of noted writers. He writes: “Thomas McGuane has called fishing ‘an act of racial memory,’ evoking the atavistic mission of the hunter-gather. Howell Raines has written that the ethos of the hunter-gatherer does not always travel well, especially if it is flying to Jackson Hole with a three-hundred-dollar rod.”

Cutting through all the rationale-seeking rhetoric, McPhee tells what does it for him: “If you like fresh fish, you might like to catch them yourself. That and the fact that fishing has the driving force of a treasure hunt is enough to put you in the stream.”

He observes: “Mainly, people seem to fish for the fight — shad fishermen manifestly included. In videos and in print, they mention primarily ‘the fighting ability of the American shad,’ carried out in ‘drag-defying escape attempts highlighted by aerial displays.’”

From there, he ventures into the subject of why fish “fight.” He notes the anti-fishing billboard of People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals, the one featuring a dog with a hook in its lip. The sign says: “IF YOU WOULDN’T DO THIS TO A DOG, WHY DO IT TO A FISH? FishingHurts.com.”

From “Orion” magazine, McPhee quotes Ted Kerasote: “We angle because we like the fight … The hook allows us to control and exert power over fish, over one of the most beautiful and seductive forms of nature, and then, because we’re nice to the fish, releasing them ‘unharmed,’ we can receive both psychic dispensation and blessing. Needless to say, if you think about this relationship carefully, it’s not a comforting one, for it is a game of dominance followed by cathartic pardons, which, as a non-fishing friend remarked, ‘is one of the hallmarks of an abusive relationship.’”

McPhee’s wife tells him catch-and-release fishing is like “humane” bullfighting, where the bull isn’t killed. Meat fishing is more like traditional bullfighting, she says. Then, going for the jugular, she says, “Fishing is crueler than hunting, in that your goal is to have the fish fight for its life. That’s the ‘fun.’ Hunting, you’re trying to kill a creature outright; fishing, you want to ‘play’ with it.”

“That is not a fair description of your husband,” he says.

“If you could just pull fish out of the water — boom — you wouldn’t be a fisherman. Don’t give me that, John,” she says, apparently knowing him better than he knows himself.

Some advocates of catch-and-release have become undeservedly sanctimonious about it, McPhee notes, but “… catch and release fishing may be cruelty masquerading as political correctness.” At its best, it’s the thrill of holding a beautiful animal in your hands for a moment, then watching it swim away. “At its worst it is dire — an unintended failure,” he says, knowing that there is no such thing as “no kill” fishing.

In a waking dream, McPhee thinks dark thoughts. “Never say playing,” he tells himself. “You are at best torturing and at worst killing a creature you may or may not eat. Playing at one end, dying at the other — if playing is what it is, it is sadism.” He berates himself to look for a different word, one that denigrates neither fish nor fisher.

He makes no bones about being a meat fisherman, but confesses to releasing male shad, which are smaller than females.

He thinks ill of anglers who release everything they catch, and those who are obsessed by numbers — the highest catch-per-day, the greatest catch-per-season.

He discovers that, in Germany, catch-and-release is not only universally unpopular, but also illegal. Quoting Herr Uwe Schuller, managing director of the Association of German Sport Fishermen: “You are never, ever to throw a fish back. We have none of this American style catch-and-release. That is verboten. That is a violation of the animal protection law and can be severely punished.”

According to the animal protection law, it’s an offense to injure fish for no good reason, and sport fishing in itself is no good reason.

McPhee made me think about things I never would’ve considered on my own.

Les Palmer can be contacted at les.palmer@rocketmail.com.

More in Life

Will Morrow (courtesy)
Older and wiser, or not

Turning 50 has been a more laid-back experience

Sara DeVolld performs as part of the Waltz of the Flowers Corps de Ballet in “The Nutcracker” with Eugene Ballet at the Alaska Center for the Performing Arts in Anchorage, Alaska. (Photo courtesy Shona DeVolld)
Becoming part of a ‘magical holiday tradition’

Local ballet dancer Sara DeVolld performs in Anchorage for ‘The Nutcracker’

A copy of Sherry Simpson’s “The Way Winter Comes” is held in the Peninsula Clarion offices on Tuesday, Nov. 28, 2023 in Kenai, Alaska. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
Off the Shelf: Inhabited by winter

Juneau writer spins haunting tales of Alaska’s darkest season in 1998 short story collection

Charles Riddiford, far right in the back row, posed for this Spokane Post Office staff photo in 1898 when he was just a clerk. The photo appeared in a 1922 edition of the Spokesman Review, along with a discussion of the post office’s tremendous growth.
Riddiford: Story of a Name Change — Part 1

So who was this Riddiford, and why did this name hold such sway at the site of Joseph Cooper’s boat landing for more than a decade?

These festive gingerbread cookies are topped with royal icing and sprinkles. (Photo by Tressa Dale/Peninsula Clarion)
Rolling out the gingerbread

With Christmas around the corner, it’s time for the holiday classic

Paper chains made of gratitude strips adorn a Christmas tree at Christ Lutheran Church in Soldotna. (Photo courtesy Meredith Harber)
Minister’s Message: Grateful and kind

What if, instead of gathering around tables and talking about what has already happened TO us, we challenge ourselves to return kindness to the world around us

Roasted broccoli Caesar salad provides some much-needed greens and fiber to balance out the rolls and gravy. (Photo by Tressa Dale/Peninsula Clarion)
A toasty, warm salad for a cozy Thanksgiving

This warm side dish provides some much-needed greens and fiber to balance out the rolls and gravy

Nick Varney
Unhinged Alaska: Some things never change. Nor should they

In the dawdling days prior to Thanksgiving, things are usually as serene as a gentle snowfall within our modest piece of nirvana

This photo from the early 1960s shows Jackson Ball enjoying the Christmas holidays with his eldest three daughters. His fourth and youngest daughter was born less than a year and a half before Ball’s death in 1968. (Photo from Ball Family memorial slideshow, 2022)
Human Complexity: The Story of Jackson Ball — Part 3

Misfortune was written across the recent history of the Arlon Elwood “Jackson” Ball family

File
Minister’s Message: Reflect upon our daily joys and blessings this Thanksgiving

There is nothing like missing something like your health to make you grateful for having good health.

Forever Dance performs “Snow” during “Forever Christmas 2022.” (Photo courtesy Forever Dance)
Forever Dance ushers in Christmas season with annual variety show

“Forever Christmas” will bring the sounds and movements of the season to the Kenai Central High School auditorium

Marvel Studios
On the Screen: ‘Marvels’ messy but very fun

Where the film shines is in the stellar performances of its three leads