An Outdoor View: Fish board

I was disappointed Sunday when state legislators voted against confirming Soldotna resident Robert Ruffner’s appointment to the Alaska Board of Fisheries. It would’ve been so good, so right, having just one board member who is there to do what’s best for the fish, not there to do the bidding of fishing guides, commercial fishermen and the others who are in it mainly for the money.

The 29-30 vote was close, but close doesn’t count in this game. To win takes a simple majority.

Having a majority is what Ruffner’s appointment was about. What doomed his confirmation was that sport and personal-use advocates realized he would upset the delicate balance that the 7-member board has enjoyed in recent years. While it’s true that such balance is more hope than reality, for some years the board has had a semblance of balance with three “sport” members, three “commercial” members and one subsistence member. The seat to which Ruffner aspired was previously held by Karl Johnstone, a sport-fishing advocate. Giving one seat to a “neutral” would’ve given the commercial side a slight advantage.

During the run up to the confirmation hearings, when I saw commercial-fishing interests starting to support Ruffner’s confirmation, I figured it would be a close thing. But when dip-netters started opposing him, even after he told them he was an avid dip-netter, I knew his chances of being on the fish board were between slim and none.

I doubt that Ruffner reckoned on the political clout of the Alaska Outdoor Council and the Chitina Dipnetters Association, or that of Anchorage and Matanuska/Susitna legislators. These relatively new players have become game changers.

Looking back, I realize that I’ve played no small part in what are commonly referred to as the “fish wars.” In the 1970s and 1980s, I attended fish-board meetings when the scale was heavily weighted toward the commercial side. Being one who fished mainly for food and fun, I felt weak and helpless at those meetings. Often there were only two or three of my kind in a room full of commercial fishermen. I’d sit there, wondering why the people who swarmed to the Kenai Peninsula to fish every summer weren’t at that meeting to protect their interests.

For years, I tried to stimulate other sport fishermen to take more interest in the process that determines who gets to fish for what, and the how, when and where of it all. I was an early member of the Kenai River Sportfishing Association, back when Bob Penney, Bix Bonney and a few others would meet at an Anchorage motel over lunch. For a brief time, I was that group’s membership chairman. Over the years, I helped convince the Alaska Outdoor Council to become more active in the fishing regulatory process.

Slowly, over the years, the worm has turned. In recent years, the increasing number of dip-netters in the personal-use fisheries at the mouths of the Kenai and Kasilof rivers have added weight to the non-commercial side of things. So-called sport fishing, previously a minor player in the game, has become a force to be reckoned with.

Don’t get me wrong. I’m not proud of the way things have turned out. I’m especially disappointed that the Kenai River Sportfishing Association, an organization I once thought was The Answer, has climbed into bed with fishing guides, lodge owners and others who seem determined to wring every buck they can out of our rivers. Both the KRSA and the Kenai Professional Guides Association strongly opposed Robert Ruffner’s run for a fish-board seat.

Trouble is, there seems to be no place for “neutral” members on the Board of Fisheries. Ruffner, although he would in many ways be an ideal board member, is apparently too neutral.

He never had a chance. It’s too bad. Maybe the fish board should have designated seats, with one or two specifically for members with no skin in the game. In a perfect world, the board would have seven Robert Ruffners.

Les Palmer can be reached at les.palmer@rocketmail.com.

More in Life

People gather in Ninilchik, Alaska, on Friday, Aug. 5, 2022, for Salmonfest, an annual event that raises awareness about salmon-related causes. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
Unhinged Alaska: Bones

Just as we approached Ninilchik, we remembered that the Salmonfest would be in high gear

File
Minister’s Message: What a Friend we have in Jesus

Can Jesus really be your friend? Jesus said so Himself.

The procedure for this quick kimchi is much less labor-intensive than the traditional whole head method, and takes less time to ferment, making it ideal for first time kimchi-makers. (Photo by Tressa Dale/Peninsula Clarion)
Garden fail — but kitchen win nonetheless

This quick kimchi technique is less labor-intensive than the traditional method

Kate Lochridge stands by one of her paintings for a pop-up show of her work on Friday, Aug. 5, 2022, at the Homer Council on the Arts in Homer, Alaska. (Photo by MIchael Armstrong/Homer News)
Pop-up exhibit shows culmination of art-science residency

The exhibit by Kate Lochridge came about after her internship this summer as a National Ocean and Atmospheric Administration Ernest S. Hollings Scholar and Artist in Residence

File
Minister’s Message: The power of small beginnings

Tiny accomplishments lead to mighty successes in all areas of life

A copy of “Once Upon the Kenai: Stories from the People” rests against a desk inside the Peninsula Clarion’s offices on Wednesday, Aug. 3, 2022, in Kenai, Alaska. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
Off the Shelf: Hidden history

‘Once Upon the Kenai’ tells the story behind the peninsula’s landmarks and people

Artwork by Graham Dale hangs at the Kenai Art Center in Kenai, Alaska, on Tuesday, Aug. 2, 2022. These pieces are part of the “Sites Unseen” exhibition. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
Apart and together

‘Sites Unseen’ combines the work of husband and wife pair Graham Dane and Linda Infante Lyons

Homemade garlic naan is served with a meal of palak tofu, butter chicken, basmati rice and cucumber salad. (Photo by Tressa Dale/Peninsula Clarion)
On the strawberry patch: Naan for a crowd

When it comes to feeding a group, planning is key

P.F. “Frenchy” Vian poses with a cigar and some reading material, probably circa 1920, in an unspecified location. (Photo courtesy of the Viani Family Collection)
Unraveling the story of Frenchy, Part 6

The many vital chapters in the story of Frenchy fell into place

File
Jesus, God of miracles, provides

When you are fishing or eating them, remember how Jesus of Nazareth used fish in some of his miracles

Sugar cookies are decorated with flowers of royal icing. (Photo by Tressa Dale/Peninsula Clarion)
Blooming sugar cookies

These sugar cookies are perfectly soft and delicious, easy to make, and the dough can be made long in advance