Kirsten Dunst portrays photojournalist Lee Smith in “Civil War.” (Promotional photo courtesy A24)

Kirsten Dunst portrays photojournalist Lee Smith in “Civil War.” (Promotional photo courtesy A24)

Review: An unexpected battle for empathy in ‘Civil War’

Garland’s new film comments on political and personal divisions through a unique lens of conflict on American soil

If I named my favorite filmmakers, I would probably come quickly to Alex Garland.

That’s odd, because before seeing his latest, “Civil War,” I had only seen two of his films, and only really liked one of them. “Ex Machina” is a film I fell in love with when I dragged my high school friends to the Orca Theater to watch a “cool, new sci-fi movie” in 2014 — I think I was alone in my enjoyment. Garland’s most recent, “Men,” is a haunting, fascinating film with a revolting conclusion that never quite landed with me.

Good or otherwise, something about the dense ideas Garland’s shown a proclivity to grapple with and the gripping pace with which he ratchets tension make for some wild movies, if nothing else.

“Civil War” is every bit the dense and intense thriller Garland is known for. It’s a film that I’m not sure I have a firm grasp on, despite it roiling around in my head now for the better part of a day.

Kirsten Dunst stars as Lee Smith, a hardened photojournalist traveling through a version of the United States twisted by civil war. She’s on a mission to shoot the president — his photo, that is. Joining her are an eclectic crew of media: reporting partner Joel played by Wagner Moura; a veteran reporter from another publication, Sammy, played by Stephen McKinley Henderson; and aspiring photographer Jessie tagging along played by Cailee Spaeny.

The relationships of the core team, road tripping down the coast, are charming, against a backdrop that’s anything but. The crew move in their press van from New York City to Washington, D.C., along their way encountering and documenting violence and conflict as their nation comes apart.

The details or politics of the war are never made clear. The film depicts atrocities with a bleak, uncompromising eye — but it never explains them. In sequences where the reporters follow soldiers as they assault a building, the objective is never revealed.

“Civil War” is a film about humanity. Its most affecting sequences are when the reporters move up with their cameras and capture images of grief, pain or triumph. These images regularly intercut the action — lingering just for a moment on the human toll of the conflict.

War is so secondary as to be not worth detailing, what matters are the ways people are hurt by division — it what appears to me a call for empathy.

Dunst drives the film with a stunning performance as Smith, shown in an early sequence to be grappling with the realities of photographing hurt, but resolute in her belief that telling those stories is valuable. She maintains an icy distance from her subjects. It’s through her relationship with Jessie and the experiences they share on the journey that she interrogates that distance.

“Civil War” isn’t a weird controversy-courting action film, like trailers might make it seem. It’s a heavy, violent film that comments on political and personal divisions through a unique lens of conflict on American soil.

It’s weird and affecting in a way that very well may fail to connect with people, the kind of film that left me in stunned silence as the credits began to roll. It’s a film I’m going to revisit as I continue to grapple with everything it’s trying to say.

“Civil War” is playing at the Kenai Cinema and the Orca Theater this weekend. Check showtimes at or

Reach reporter Jake Dye at

Kirsten Dunst, Wagner Moura, Stephen McKinley Henderson and Cailee Spaeny appear in “Civil War.” (Promotional photo courtesy A24)

Kirsten Dunst, Wagner Moura, Stephen McKinley Henderson and Cailee Spaeny appear in “Civil War.” (Promotional photo courtesy A24)

More in Life

Virginia Walters (Courtesy photo)
Life in the Pedestrian Lane: This and that

Organizations are running out of people to keep them going

This Al Hershberger photo of his good friend Hedley Parsons was taken in Germany in 1945, after World War II had ended. Parsons and Hershberger came to Alaska together a few years later, and in 2010, when Parsons was interviewed for this story, he may have been the last person living who had actually attended George Dudley’s messy funeral
This parting was not sweet sorrow — Part 2

The funeral was scheduled for 2 p.m. on May 5, and spring break-up was in full, sloppy bloom at the Kenai Cemetery

Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion
A copy of “People, Paths, and Places: The Frontier History of Moose Pass, Alaska” stands in sunlight in Soldotna on Friday.
Off the Shelf: Community history project a colorful portrait of hometown

The book features the work of students at Moose Pass School and integrates further stories pulled from a community newspaper

The Anchorage Bowl Chamber Orchestra performs. (Photo courtesy Anchorage Bowl Chamber Orchestra)
Anchorage orchestra group to visit Kenai Peninsula for 10th annual tour

Anchorage Bowl Chamber Orchestra will play four shows from May 30 to June 2

Minister’s Message: Boasting only in Christ and the Cross

The Reverend Billy Graham advised every president since Truman during his lifetime

Corn cheese is served alongside grilled beef, kimchi and lettuce. (Photo by Tressa Dale/Peninsula Clarion)
Planning barbecue with all the bells and whistles

Expect kimchi, lots of side dishes, piles of rice, marinated meat for the flame and cold fruit for dessert

Noa (voiced by Owen Teague) in 20th Century Studios’ “Kingdom of the Planet of the Apes.” (Photo courtesy of 20th Century Studios)
On the Screen: New ‘Planet of the Apes’ expands, brings new ideas to franchise universe

“Kingdom of the Planet of the Apes” tells a story that feels more rooted in fantasy than the post-apocalypse vibe of its predecessors

A mural depicting imagery and iconography of Kenai brightens the entryway of the Walmart in Kenai, Alaska, on Wednesday, May 15, 2024. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
‘Visible art raises people’s spirits’

Local artist’s mural introduced as part of Walmart renovations

Former North Kenai resident George Coe Dudley, seen here during the winter of 1950-51, was a hard-drinking man. His messy funeral in 1967 in Kenai echoed his lifestyle. (Photo courtesy of Al Hershberger)
This parting was not sweet sorrow — Part 1

“Dudley was an easy-going, laid-back sort of guy, always laughing and joking, as well as hard drinking.”

Most Read