What others say: Protests need to have a purpose

  • Wednesday, May 30, 2018 9:31am
  • Opinion

The original message Colin Kaepernick was trying to send in September 2016, when he first knelt during the national anthem, has gotten lost.

So, maybe those who support the former 49ers quarterback and his protest against police brutality and racial inequality should consider how to get that message back on track. Try a new tactic with a real call-to-action.

What began as a player’s silent dissent has morphed into a loud debate, pitting the NFL and team owners against players and their supporters. Even President Trump, who likes a good “kerfuffle,” has weighed in, making it about patriotism, saying to players who take a knee, “Maybe you shouldn’t be in the country.”

The new NFL owners’ rule has only escalated the divide by threatening to penalize players and teams if they don’t stand during the national anthem, or stay in the locker room while it’s playing.

Yes, this is about free speech, and our country’s time-honored right to protest. That, too, is patriotism.

But it’s also about who’s in charge — team owners who employ the players and don’t want political protests to disrupt profits. Or the players — employees — who want to use their celebrity and what they believe to be their First Amendment rights to speak out about injustice.

We hate censorship. But the question of who is legally right about the new rule is murky.

Erwin Chemerinsky, the dean of Berkeley Law and a constitutional law expert told the Washington Post, First Amendment rights don’t apply to private institutions. “Private employers can fire employees for their speech without having to worry about the First Amendment,” he said.

In an article written for Vox, Benjamin Sachs, a labor professor at Harvard Law School, said it comes down to the players’ collective bargaining agreement with the NFL and whether the union should have been consulted.

“If, as the NFL Players Association says, the employer implemented this change on its own, the policy is flatly illegal for that reason and should be rescinded by the league,” Sachs writes.

The Players Association has said it will study the new policy to determine whether it violates its collective bargaining agreement with the NFL.

In the midst of the legal quandary, players who want to combat racial injustice by kneeling on the field are losing the PR battle. Members of the media may be in their corner, but their employers and a lot of fans no longer hear their message, if they ever did.

Protesters will get more traction for their movement if it becomes one. If it expands to include the public and other high-profile supporters. And if it has a tangible goal like changing a specific law or law enforcement practice. Where exactly do the NFL protesters want to go with this?

Think the #MeToo movement and its effort to identify and punish harassers. Or the Parkland students who’ve ignited a call across the country for greater gun control.

It’s time for this protest to evolve if it’s going to be effective. Tell us what you want. Take it beyond the field; get the fans in the stands and our communities involved; get policy makers’ attention.

If this is about ending racial injustice, make it a movement, or watch it fizzle.

— Fort Worth Star-Telegram. May 28

More in Opinion

The Alaska Capitol on Monday, Jan. 16, 2023, in Juneau, Alaska. (AP Photo/Becky Bohrer)
Alaska Voices: Legislature deserves credit

A special session shouldn’t have been necessary, but at least it was only one day instead of 30 days.

Alaska State Troopers logo.
Alaska Voices: Please be safe, courteous, and legal as you fish in Alaska this summer

As you head out to hit the water this year, here are a few tips to help you have a safe and citation free season

An observer makes an entry in the Fish Map App on Prince of Wales Island. (Photo by Lee House/courtesy Salmon State)
Alaska Voices: Document Alaska rivers with new fish map app

The app provides a way for everyday Alaskans to document rivers home to wild salmon, whitefish, eulachon and other ocean-going fish — and earn money doing it

(Peter Segall / Juneau Empire File)
Opinion: Sustainability report is a greenwashing effort

Report leaves out “the not-so-pretty.”

Pictured is an adult Chinook salmon swimming in Ship Creek, Anchorage. (Photo: U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service)
Voices of the Peninsula: Proactive measures key to king salmon recovery

I have been sport fishing king salmon along the eastern shores of Cook Inlet and in the Kenai River since 1977

U.S. Sen. Lisa Murkowski (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
Honoring the fallen on Memorial Day

As we honor the men and women who fell in service to our nation, we must keep their memories alive through their stories

Shana Loshbaugh (Courtesy photo)
History conference seeking input from peninsula people

The Alaska Historical Society will hold its annual conference on the central peninsula this fall

Coach Dan Gensel (left) prepares to get his ear pierced to celebrate Soldotna High School’s first team-sport state championship on Friday, Febr. 12, 1993 in Soldotna, Alaska. Gensel, who led the Soldotna High School girls basketball team to victory, had promised his team earlier in the season that he would get his ear pierced if they won the state title. (Rusty Swan/Peninsula Clarion)
Remembering my friend, Dan Gensel

It’s a friendship that’s both fixed in time and eternal

(Clarise Larson / Juneau Empire File)
Opinion: The false gods in America’s gun culture

HB 61 is a solution in search of a problem.

Most Read