What others say: Meet the Legislature’s new restriction on freedom of speech

  • Sunday, October 18, 2015 8:04pm
  • Opinion

It’s a rare day when someone wakes up in the morning with the intent to make a mistake.

Most mistakes are made when our actions fail to perfectly match our intentions.

This week, the Alaska Legislature created a new rule addressing how the media may cover the Alaska Legislature. In the event of a medical emergency — if someone suffers a heart attack, a fall down the stairs or a paper cut, then needs an ambulance — no photography is allowed. Any journalist who attempts to take a photograph on the capitol grounds during that emergency will have his or her press pass revoked.

In our opinion, this is a solution in search of a problem, and if misused, this rule could have grave consequences for free speech and free access in Alaska.

Last year, Rep. Ben Nageak, D-Barrow, suffered a medical emergency — he collapsed due to a “low blood count,” a spokesman said at the time — on the floor of the House of Representatives. At the time, House rules forbade the photography of any medical emergency on the floors of the House or Senate.

The cameras of Gavel Alaska — which broadcasts Legislative hearings — obediently panned away from the prostrate Nageak, and Empire reporter Katie Moritz kept her cellphone camera off.

When Nageak was taken off the floor and into an adjacent office, Gavel Alaska’s Jeremy Hsieh (a former Empire employee) and Skip Gray attempted to get a picture of the scene from the hallway. When they realized the situation, they went outside and got a picture of an ambulance pulling up to the Capitol to take Nageak to Bartlett Regional Hospital.

Rep. Craig Johnson, R-Anchorage and chairman of the House Rules Committee, says Hsieh and Gray were impeding Nageak’s medical care by refusing to get out of the nearby hallway.

Hsieh and Gray briefly had their credentials revoked, but those credentials were restored when it was realized that the pair had broken no rules.

Hsieh says the pair were not obstructing first responders. “You don’t walk between the firefighter and the fire,” he told Nathaniel Herz of the Alaska Dispatch News.

The event the two were documenting was clearly newsworthy, and if Gavel Alaska operates as this newspaper does, publishing a photo or an account of a vulnerable person is a decision made only after careful thought and consideration.

The prototypical motto of a journalist says that good journalism should comfort the weak and afflict the powerful. In any case, any photographs of an injured Nageak have never been published.

The grounds of the Capitol are supposed to be a public space just as much as the road or sidewalk are. The general public — not just the press — has a right to be there.

The profusion of cellphone cameras has granted the world easy, immediate access to events. Restrictions on the media are a foolhardy attempt to control the narrative. When professionals are restricted, amateurs will fill the gap. Alaska’s capitol journalists, though few in number, are among the most professional in the state.

Restricting them has no effect but to make the public believe there is something to hide, and it is futile to hide when there are cameras in the pockets of every person in the Capitol.

We suspect this rule is also illegal under Article 1, Section 5 of the Alaska Constitution: “Every person may freely speak, write and publish on all subjects, being responsible for the abuse of that right.”

The House’s new rule appears to at best be a solution in search of a problem. At worst, it’s a tool that could be manipulated to quash public discourse and protect the powerful.

It’s also futile. In the event of an emergency like the 2014 shooting in the Canadian Parliament, any journalist worth his or her salt will gather news first, rule or no rule.

Gavel Alaska cannot speak for itself. It is paid on contract to broadcast the hearings of the Alaska Legislature, and rocking the boat could swamp that contract.

We feel an obligation to speak on its behalf and say what it cannot: The Alaska Legislature may have good intentions with this rule, but those intentions do not excuse a serious error.

— Juneau Empire,

Oct. 16

More in Opinion

Jodi Taylor is the board chair for Alaska Policy Forum. (Courtesy photo)
Private school, state reimbursement: family choice

By Jodi Taylor Alaskan parents have a legitimate right to choose the… Continue reading

Opinion: It’s time for bold action to protect our fisheries

Our fisheries feed the world and sustain our unique cultures and communities.

The logo for the Kenai Peninsula Borough School District is displayed inside the George A. Navarre Borough Admin Building on Thursday, July 22, 2021 in Soldotna, Alaska. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
Voices of the Peninsula: Hard to fill positions?

Paying poverty wages to support staff, secretaries and custodians is unacceptable yet routine behavior by our district

A copy of the State of Alaska Official Ballot for the June 11, 2022, Special Primary Election is photographed on May 2, 2022. (Peninsula Clarion staff)
Choosing a candidate – Who will best represent us in D.C.?

Voters are encouraged to do homework before casting a vote

Tourists watch as one of two cubs belonging to an 18-year-old sow black bear crosses the path between groups of tourists visiting the Mendenhall Glacier Visitor Center on Wednesday, July 18, 2018. (Michael Penn / Juneau Empire File)
Opinion: Tourists have pushed us to critical mass in parts of Juneau

I don’t go to the glacier in the summer now to hike or watch bears.

Sens. Shelley Hughes, R-Palmer, left, and Robert Myers, R-North Pole, read through one of 41 amendments submitted to the state’s omnibus budget bill being debate on the floor of the Alaska State Senate on Monday, May 9, 2022. (Peter Segall / Juneau Empire)
Opinion: The Alaska Senate’s foolish gamble

“All these conservative people just spent all our money”

Mobilizing for Action through Planning and Partnerships. (logo provided)
Point of View: A few ideas for Mental Health Awareness Month

What are some things you can practice this month and subsequently apply to your life?

Alex Koplin is a founding member of Kenai Peninsula Votes. (courtesy photo)
Voices of the Peninsula: 1 candidate dined, 47 to go

By Alex Koplin Last month, I wrote a satirical piece for the… Continue reading

Most Read