Point of View: Bay Club purchase could be city community center

Instead of building new center on HERC site, why not purchase the Bay Club?

William Marley

William Marley

Congratulations to the City of Homer in their effort to create a community/recreation center just as most other communities in Alaska have already long done. The proposed facility would be placed where the present day HERC building is. It is my belief that this facility should meet the following expectations:

• A community center meeting some of the social and small meeting needs of Homer and vicinity.

• A recreation facility meeting needs of exercise and physical, mental fitness.

• Not to be excluded, storage space for the Public Works and Recreation departments.

• A cost effective facility meeting the typical tax payer’s needs of our conservative peers.

• A facility that would indeed be a showcase that would meet the unmet needs of a convention/conference center providing opportunity for an off-season economy in our community.

• A facility that would be a physical and structural compliment to our geologically serene beauty pronouncing how we appreciate where we live. The facility should not just have a view but should be highly viewable to the 95% plus of the traffic entering our community via the Sterling Highway.

Regrettably, the proposed designs by Stantec Inc. fail to meet these community needs. The designs largely seem to provide a gymnasium with what seems to be little else at great projected expense, and that expense does not also include the cost of the demolition of the HERC building, as it is, nor the value of the land.

A far better opportunity to meet many of the above community needs is to purchase the existing Bay Club right here in Homer at a mere fraction of the cost of the Stantec Inc. proposals. It is my understanding that the Bay Club currently is a purchasable facility. The Bay Club has a significant variety of exercise devices, an exercise swim pool, a yoga exercise area and racquetball courts. Its 5 acres of land also allows for facility expansion.

BUT: The only difficult thing is that the cost of utilization exceeds many family and individual budgets. If anything can be learned from this immediate past COVID-19 winter, it is that we all should appreciate, immensely, the value of social interaction as well as physical exercise relative to our mental and physical well-being. Public purchase of the Bay Club with private individual participation reducing considerably the cost of utilization is an opportunity for us all to have a true “healthier” life and community.

Financing should not rely on just the City of Homer, but should be area wide and institution wide such as the Seldovia Village Tribe (SVT) and the South Peninsula Hospital (SPH) service area. The City of Homer has the administrative plus organizational structure and should take the leadership to facilitate this most worthy project.

More in Opinion

Larry Persily. (Juneau Empire file photo)
Opinion: Low oil prices a ‘bah humbug’ for state treasury

It’s the season of warm wishes, goodwill, families and friends. It’s a… Continue reading

Seismologist Carl Tape stands at the site of Dome City in summer 2025. Dome City ghosted out many years ago, but not before miners unearthed many fossils, some of which they donated to the University of Alaska. Photo courtesy Ned Rozell
A whale of a mammoth tale

Matthew Wooller couldn’t believe his ears after a California researcher rang his… Continue reading

A vintage Underwood typewriter sits on a table on Tuesday, Feb. 22, 2022, at the Homer News in Homer, Alaska. (Photo by Michael Armstrong/Homer News)
Letters to the editor

Soldotna needs better funding for all student sports An issue that has… Continue reading

Larry Persily. (Juneau Empire file photo)
Opinion: Governor misses the point of fiscal leadership

Gov. Mike Dunleavy, now in his final year in office, has spent… Continue reading

Voting booths are filled at the Kenai No. 2 precinct, the Challenger Learning Center of Alaska in Kenai, Alaska, on Tuesday, Nov. 5, 2024. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
Point of View: Alaskans, don’t be duped by the Citizens Voter initiative

A signature drive is underway for a ballot measure officially titled the… Continue reading

A 1958 earthquake on the Fairweather Fault that passes through Lituya Bay shook a mountaintop into the water and produced a wave that reached 1,740 feet on the hillside in the background, shearing off rainforest spruce trees. Photo courtesy Ned Rozell
A wrinkle beneath the icy face of Alaska

A few days ago, the forces beneath Alaska rattled people within a… Continue reading

A vintage Underwood typewriter sits on a table on Tuesday, Feb. 22, 2022, at the Homer News in Homer, Alaska. (Photo by Michael Armstrong/Homer News)
Letters to the editor

Brine makes life less affordable About a year after the 2024 presidential… Continue reading

Larry Persily. (Juneau Empire file photo)
Opinion: Maybe the 5-day-old leftovers are to blame

I don’t ever throw away leftovers. I figure anything wrapped in petrochemical-based… Continue reading

This figure shows the approximately 2,700 earthquakes that occurred in Southcentral Alaska between Sept. 10 and Nov. 12, 2025. Also shown are the locations of the two research sites in Homer and Kodiak. Figure by Cade Quigley
The people behind earthquake early warning

Alders, alders, everywhere. When you follow scientists in the Alaska wilderness, you’ll… Continue reading

Patricia Ann Davis drew this illustration of dancing wires affected by air movement. From the book “Alaska Science Nuggets” by Neil Davis
The mystery of the dancing wires

In this quiet, peaceful time of year, with all the noisy birds… Continue reading

Photo courtesy Kaila Pfister
A parent and teen use conversation cards created by the Alaska Children’s Trust.
Opinion: Staying connected starts with showing up

When our daughter was 11 and the COVID lockdown was in full… Continue reading

Juneau Empire file photo
Larry Persily.
Opinion: The country’s economy is brewing caf and decaf

Most people have seen news reports, social media posts and business charts… Continue reading