State Rep. Ben Carpenter, R-Nikiski, inquires about election legislation during a committee hearing Tuesday at the Alaska State Capitol. Carpenter, chair of the House Ways and Means Committee, is sponsoring bills to decrease business taxes and implement a 2% statewide sales tax that were heard. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire File)

State Rep. Ben Carpenter, R-Nikiski, inquires about election legislation during a committee hearing Tuesday at the Alaska State Capitol. Carpenter, chair of the House Ways and Means Committee, is sponsoring bills to decrease business taxes and implement a 2% statewide sales tax that were heard. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire File)

Opinion: Proposal is a fiscal plan, but not a good one

The numbers don’t add up.

  • By Larry Persily
  • Wednesday, April 5, 2023 11:07pm
  • Opinion

Three-term Nikiski Rep. Ben Carpenter is right, the state needs a sustainable, long-term fiscal plan. Give him credit for raising the issue. Talk of a balanced fiscal plan has lingered since 1990 — before several of today’s legislators were even born.

The accompanying discussion about diversifying Alaska’s economy has lasted even longer, ever since the first barrels started flowing from Prudhoe Bay in 1977 and we tried using the riches to expand the state’s economy and job opportunities beyond oil.

But unless new business activity produces oil, any new industry or commercial enterprise does little to nothing to add revenue to the state, which pays for education, roads, the courts and so much more. Without a broad-based tax, such as a state sales or income tax, more jobs and more people needing more public services are a loser for the Alaska treasury, which pays much of the cost of those services.

It’s called the “Alaska Disconnect” — economic activity that costs more than it produces.

It’s not anti-development, it’s just a failing fiscal structure that spends more on services with nothing coming in to pay the higher bills.

Carpenter understands the disconnect, which he addressed in his legislative proposals. And he is absolutely right, everyone should contribute to the solution.

But where his plan misses the mark is in the details and its unfairness. He proposes a state sales tax, piled on top of local taxes in more than 100 cities and boroughs, along with a significant reduction in the state tax on corporate profits. That sounds about as equal as heads I win, tails you lose.

His corporate tax reduction could cost the treasury an estimated $330 million a year, while his sales tax could raise twice that much. His plan would merely shift a lot of the tax burden from corporations to people.

While slashing the tax on corporate profits, Carpenter proposes imposing sales taxes on food, medicines and many other essential goods and services often exempted from tax. Yes, he is right, every member of the state’s fiscal house should help pay to close the gap between revenues and expenses, but that pie should be sliced fairly — and this isn’t even close.

At last month’s hearing in the House Ways and Means Committee, chaired by Carpenter, Anchorage Democratic Rep. Andrew Gray noted that without a sales tax exemption on food, residents in rural Alaska would pay a disproportionate share of the tax on their expensive groceries.

“If people in rural Alaska are paying twice as much for their groceries, they will be paying twice as much of that tax,” he said.

Carpenter’s answer was that the Legislature could investigate ways to reduce the cost of a gallon of milk in rural Alaska, such as improving transportation.

Unless he wants to subsidize barge service and air freight flights, that is a useless answer.

The Kenai Peninsula Republican says his sales tax would be just one piece of a long-term fiscal plan, along with a spending cap on the state budget and cementing the Permanent Fund dividend into the Alaska Constitution. Not just guaranteeing a PFD in the constitution, but hard wiring the formula at such a high amount that it would add several hundred million dollars a year to the state budget deficit.

Let’s see if I understand the math: Spend more on the dividend than the budget can afford, cut corporate taxes in hopes of attracting new businesses that will need more state services, and help pay for everything with a sales tax?

The numbers don’t add up. It’s a plan, but not a good one.

• Larry Persily is a longtime Alaska journalist, with breaks for federal, state and municipal service in oil and gas, taxes and fiscal policy work. Columns, My Turns and Letters to the Editor represent the view of the author, not the view of the Juneau Empire. Have something to say? Here’s how to submit a My Turn or letter.

More in Opinion

Sen. Jesse Bjorkman, a Nikiski Republican, speaks during floor debate of a joint session of the Alaska State Legislature on Monday, March 18, 2024. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
Sen. Jesse Bjorkman: Protecting workers, honoring the fallen

Capitol Corner: Legislators report back from Juneau

Rep. Justin Ruffridge, a Soldotna Republican who co-chairs the House Education Committee, speaks during floor debate of a joint session of the Alaska State Legislature on Monday, March 18, 2024. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
Rep. Justin Ruffridge: Supporting correspondence programs

Capitol Corner: Legislators report back from Juneau

The Alaska State Capitol on March 1. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
Opinion: We support all students

In the last month of session, we are committed to working together with our colleagues to pass comprehensive education reform

Rep. Ben Carpenter, a Nikiski Republican, speaks during floor debate of a joint session of the Alaska State Legislature on Monday, March 18, 2024. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
Rep. Ben Carpenter: Securing Alaska’s economic future through tax reform

Capitol Corner: Legislators report back from Juneau

(Juneau Empire file photo)
Opinion: Alaska House makes the right decision on constitutionally guaranteed PFD

The proposed amendment would have elevated the PFD to a higher status than any other need in the state

Rep. Justin Ruffridge, a Soldotna Republican who co-chairs the House Education Committee, speaks during floor debate of a joint session of the Alaska State Legislature on Monday, March 18, 2024. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
Rep. Justin Ruffridge: Creating a road map to our shared future

Capitol Corner: Legislators report back from Juneau

An array of solar panels stand in the sunlight at Whistle Hill in Soldotna, Alaska, on Sunday, April 7, 2024. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
Renewable Energy Fund: Key to Alaska’s clean economy transition

AEA will continue to strive to deliver affordable, reliable, and sustainable energy to provide a brighter future for all Alaskans.

Mount Redoubt can be seen acoss Cook Inlet from North Kenai Beach on Thursday, July 2, 2022. (Photo by Erin Thompson/Peninsula Clarion)
Opinion: An open letter to the HEA board of directors

Renewable energy is a viable option for Alaska

Sen. Jesse Bjorkman, R-Nikiski, speaks in opposition to an executive order that would abolish the Board of Certified Direct-Entry Midwives during a joint legislative session on Tuesday, March 12, 2024 in Juneau, Alaska. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
Sen. Jesse Bjorkman: Making progress, passing bills

Capitol Corner: Legislators report back from Juneau

Heidi Hedberg. (Photo courtesy of the Alaska Department of Health)
Opinion: Alaska’s public assistance division is on course to serve Alaskans in need more efficiently than ever

We are now able to provide in-person service at our offices in Bethel, Juneau, Kodiak, Kenai, Homer and Wasilla

Priya Helweg is the deputy regional director and executive officer for the Office of the Regional Director (ORD), Office of Intergovernmental and External Affairs, Department of Health and Human Services, Region 10. (Image via hhs.gov)
Opinion: Taking action on the maternal health crisis

The United States has the highest maternal mortality rate among high-income countries