Is giving an invocation an individual right?

  • Saturday, December 17, 2016 5:36pm
  • Opinion

In the Town of Greece, New York v. Galloway, the U.S. Supreme Court found the tradition of legislative bodies inviting local clergy to open meeting with an invocation to be constitutional, provided that minority faiths are not excluded.

The Kenai Peninsula Borough Assembly now faces a related legal debate: while the assembly has the authority to invite religious leaders to offer a prayer, do individuals have a constitutional right to give an invocation?

That’s the crux of the lawsuit filed last week by the American Civil Liberties Union of Alaska on behalf of two borough residents. The suit claims that the assembly’s recently adopted policy regarding invocations at its meetings is discriminatory because it limits those who may be invited to give an invocation to those who come from “religious associations with an established presence in the Kenai Peninsula Borough that regularly meet for the primary purpose of sharing a religious perspective, or chaplains who may serve one of more of the fire departments, law enforcement agencies, hospitals, or other similar organizations in the borough.”

The assembly’s policy — which has been adopted, repealed and adopted again — very closely follows the guidelines set out in the Greece v. Galloway ruling, with measures ensuring that any faith group that so chooses may be invited to offer an invocation. The policy expressly prohibits assembly members or borough staff from excluding any religious group, and outside of asking “that no invocation should proselytize or advance any faith, or disparage the religious faith or non-religious views of others,” the assembly is prohibited from dictating the content of invocations, or requesting to review an invocation ahead of time.

But as we noted, the challenge to the policy doesn’t involve whether an opening prayer is constitutional, but whether the invitation to give an invocation must be extended to individuals outside of established congregations — the tradition upheld by the Supreme Court.

In other words, it is not so much a matter of the freedom of speech and freedom of religion, but more a question of equal protection.

It is an interesting question, and one we would like to see answered by the court.

We do think the assembly needs a written policy on invocations if the practice is to remain a part of the assembly agenda. Frankly, the former policy of no formal policy leaves open the possibility of exclusion based on religious beliefs — clearly an issue based on recent comments from some assembly members.

And though it would seem to imply members of the local clergy, without a clear definition, the meaning of “religious association with an established presence” or what constitutes a “regular meeting” is open to interpretation. It is worth noting that IRS criteria for defining a religious association — the guidelines to be used in the event a religious association’s legitimacy is questioned — are deliberately vague for constitutional reasons. We would hope that, given the stated intent of the assembly policy, they are interpreted in the broadest sense possible — that, when in doubt, the clerk and assembly president look for reasons to include those wishing to give an invocation, rather than reasons to exclude.

Should the borough assembly opt to amend the portion of the policy over which the suit has been filed, we hope it will be done so without throwing out the rest of the policy.

But should the assembly go forward with defending the policy, we look forward to hearing the legal arguments on both sides of the issue. Some have argued that the cost of defending the policy is not worth it, but just as the ACLU has become involved, there are likely organizations that would assist the borough in its defense. As much as the policy is an attempt to remove politics from the assembly’s invocation, it has certainly stirred the political pot.

More in Opinion

(Juneau Empire file photo)
Opinion: Alaska House makes the right decision on constitutionally guaranteed PFD

The proposed amendment would have elevated the PFD to a higher status than any other need in the state

Rep. Justin Ruffridge, a Soldotna Republican who co-chairs the House Education Committee, speaks during floor debate of a joint session of the Alaska State Legislature on Monday, March 18, 2024. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
Rep. Justin Ruffridge: Creating a road map to our shared future

Capitol Corner: Legislators report back from Juneau

An array of solar panels stand in the sunlight at Whistle Hill in Soldotna, Alaska, on Sunday, April 7, 2024. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
Renewable Energy Fund: Key to Alaska’s clean economy transition

AEA will continue to strive to deliver affordable, reliable, and sustainable energy to provide a brighter future for all Alaskans.

Mount Redoubt can be seen acoss Cook Inlet from North Kenai Beach on Thursday, July 2, 2022. (Photo by Erin Thompson/Peninsula Clarion)
Opinion: An open letter to the HEA board of directors

Renewable energy is a viable option for Alaska

Sen. Jesse Bjorkman, R-Nikiski, speaks in opposition to an executive order that would abolish the Board of Certified Direct-Entry Midwives during a joint legislative session on Tuesday, March 12, 2024 in Juneau, Alaska. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
Sen. Jesse Bjorkman: Making progress, passing bills

Capitol Corner: Legislators report back from Juneau

Priya Helweg is the deputy regional director and executive officer for the Office of the Regional Director (ORD), Office of Intergovernmental and External Affairs, Department of Health and Human Services, Region 10. (Image via hhs.gov)
Opinion: Taking action on the maternal health crisis

The United States has the highest maternal mortality rate among high-income countries

Heidi Hedberg. (Photo courtesy of the Alaska Department of Health)
Opinion: Alaska’s public assistance division is on course to serve Alaskans in need more efficiently than ever

We are now able to provide in-person service at our offices in Bethel, Juneau, Kodiak, Kenai, Homer and Wasilla

Sara Hondel (Courtesy photo)
Opinion: Alaskan advocate shines light on Alzheimer’s crisis

In the heart of the nation’s capital next week, volunteers will champion the urgent need for legislative action to support those affected by Alzheimer’s

Most Read