In this Feb. 13, 2019 photo, Office of Management and Budget Director Donna Arduin explains the budget as Gov. Mike Dunleavy listens during a press conference. (Michael Penn | Juneau Empire File)

In this Feb. 13, 2019 photo, Office of Management and Budget Director Donna Arduin explains the budget as Gov. Mike Dunleavy listens during a press conference. (Michael Penn | Juneau Empire File)

Alaska Voices: Dunleavy’s budget: Malfeasance or misfeasance?

Governor fails to submit a revenue plan, refuses to contemplate one.

  • Thursday, April 4, 2019 2:34pm
  • Opinion

We often hear politicians saying that we need to “run government like a business.” This is particularly true of conservative politicians. This is what Gov. Mike Dunleavy and many of his well-heeled supporters said during the campaign.

I spent 30 years as a development professional assessing and analyzing business cases. I thought it might be interesting to take a look at the governor’s budget from a business analysis perspective.

But before we can analyze a business we have to know something about the business itself.

It appears to me that the authors of the Alaska Constitution envisioned our state to be established as a “beneficial trust.” No other state in the union is so organized.

[Opinion: Alaska’s illusion of election mandates]

In the natural resources article of the Constitution, Article VIII at Sections 1, 2 and 3, the founders declare the collective ownership of state resources, which shall be developed “in the public interest” and for the maximum benefit of the people. Section 3, “Common Use”, is far-reaching. In his “Citizen’s Guide to the Alaska Constitution,” Gordon Harrison notes:

“This section enshrines in the Alaska Constitution the common law doctrine that natural resources must be managed by the state as a public trust for the benefit of the people as a whole rather than for the benefit of the government, corporations or private persons.”

This is a vastly different vision of the state than that which exists elsewhere in the Lower 48. Building Alaska’s public equity is the job of the state. The vision was that these pools of public equity would produce robust income and they would, in turn, permanently fund the various “benefits” declared in the Constitution; these funds are apart from the Permanent Fund itself, which came years later.

Analysis

The first thing I notice is all of the “public equity funds,” those trusts and endowments, established over the years to become a renewable source of benefits, are being targeted for liquidation by the chief executive officer.

What competent CEO of a beneficial trust would propose to “sweep” long-term assets enjoying a 7-8% return on investment into a liquidity pool generating less than 1%? Especially if the consequence of that liquidation is to terminate the recurring benefits called for in the charter and by-laws of the business?

And then there is an operating deficit.

[Opinion: Alaska’s budget must be brought in line with our ability to pay for it]

When a business — any business — projects a negative cash flow in its operations, it will get a clue about what is going on by looking at its profit and loss. Here we see our company gets about $1.4 billion in royalties and $524 million in production taxes after allowing the companies to deduct $1.25 billion in tax credits. That results in a 15% return rate on a commodity from which our company is supposed to be getting a 35% return — the nominal rate provided in Senate Bill 21.

Analytically, this flags a problem with our “business.”

David Teal, chief financial analyst for the Legislature, testified that while our expenditures are roughly at Fiscal Year 1980 levels, our revenues are significantly diminished. Teal put it simply, “Alaska does not have an expenditure problem, it has a revenue problem.”

Yet Alaska’s CEO submitted a budget to the board of directors that calls for cutting expenditures, liquidating our beneficial trust funds while he completely ignores the revenue side of the ledger.

Dunleavy seems confused about his constitutional role overseeing a beneficial trust, but the Constitution is clear: He is the governor of the public sector — not the private sector. Article IX, Section 6 makes clear the financing and taxation of the state is to be used for public, not private purposes. And Section 12 directs the governor to submit a budget that includes “a bill or bills covering recommendations in the budget for new and additional funds.”

Dunleavy’s failure to submit a revenue plan and his refusal to contemplate one, together with his proposed liquidation of the trust, constitute either malfeasance or misfeasance. In either case, it is up to our board of directors, and ultimately, the people to set him straight.

Elstun W. Lauesen lives in Anchorage.


• Elstun W. Lauesen lives in Anchorage. My Turns and Letters to the Editor represent the view of the author, not the view of the Juneau Empire.


More in Opinion

Dr. Tamika Ledbetter, commissioner of the Alaska Department of Labor and Workforce Development, participates in a press conference in Anchorage, Alaska, on March 31, 2020. (Courtesy photo)
Alaska Voices: State working to address Alaskans’ unemployment needs

As of the week ending March 21, the department processed 13,774 new claims.

The Alaska State Capitol. (Michael Penn | Juneau Empire File)
Alaska Voices: It’s time for a spending cap that works

It is essential to minimize uncertainty and prioritize stability.

The Capitol is seen as House lawmakers prepare to debate emergency coronavirus response legislation on Capitol Hill, Friday, March 27, 2020, in Washington. (AP Photo/Andrew Harnik)
Voices of the Peninsula: Cash payments give Americans crucial economic support

Cash payments put Americans in the driver’s seat because they are empowered to decide how to spend it

Gov. Mike Dunleavy (courtesy photo)
Opinion: Standing behind our state workers

Whatever hardship Alaskans face, the business of the state must go on.

A sign outside of RD’s Barber Shop indicating that they are closed can be seen here in Kenai, Alaska on March 25, 2020. (Photo by Brian Mazurek/Peninsula Clarion)
Alaska Voices: Support your local business!

The actions we take now can help sustain these enterprises over the next few weeks.

Adam Crum
Alaska Voices: Alaskans are experts at social distancing and helping others

Most of us have never heard of anything like this, much less been asked to do it.

Alaska Voices: We will get through this together

We understand what a challenging and unprecedented time this is for Alaskans.… Continue reading

A moose feeds on a rose bush near the Homer News by Beluga Lake on Friday afternoon, March 6, 2020, in Homer, Alaska. (Photo by Michael Armstrong/Homer News)
Voices of the Peninsula: Thank you for keeping Alaska wild

The successes on the Kenai Peninsula are due to a handful of dedicated professionals.

Salmonberries hang fat from a bush on a recent summer. (Photo by Mary Catharine Martin)
Alaska Voices: Alaskan solace

We Alaskans, Americans and the rest of the world face uncharted waters in the months ahead.

Most Read