This April 2017 photo shows the Alaska Railroad Corporation’s bridge across the Snow River near Seward, Alaska. (Photo by Elizabeth Earl/Peninsula Clarion)

This April 2017 photo shows the Alaska Railroad Corporation’s bridge across the Snow River near Seward, Alaska. (Photo by Elizabeth Earl/Peninsula Clarion)

Resolution puts Legislature into railroad property dispute

A resolution before the Legislature attempts to put a stake in an ongoing disagreement between the Alaska Railroad Corporation and landowners next to its tracks.

The railroad, which maintains track over more than 400 miles from Resurrection Bay in Seward to Fairbanks, runs through the heart of Alaska’s most populated areas. In some places, the railroad runs through neighborhoods or parallel to popular trails. Completed by the federal government in 1923 and conveyed to the state to be run by the independent state-owned corporation the Alaska Railroad Corporation in 1982, the railroad transports thousands of people and tons of freight every year.

However, in recent years, the railroad’s work to keep people and objects out of its right of way up to about 80 feet from the tracks has caused conflict with neighbors. Neighbors have said the railroad corporation has put up fences, asked property owners to clear land within the right of way easement and clouded ownership titles over land disputes. Railroad administrators say they have an exclusive use easement and need to exert exclusive authority to keep pedestrians and operations safe.

Rep. Chuck Kopp (R-Anchorage) is asking the Legislature to step in with House Joint Resolution 38 this session.

“Hundreds of landowners along the Alaska Railroad Corporation’s right-of-way have had property rights confiscated and a cloud put on their title through an unlawful exclusive use easement claim the Alaska Railroad makes to the entire right-of-way,” he said during an April 6 hearing before the House Judiciary Committee.

HJR 38 would state that the Legislature views any exclusive-use easement transferred by the federal government in 1982 on private property to be illegal, would have to be disclosed and urges Alaska’s congressional delegation to correct the situation. Kopp said there are more than 200 people affected by the land conflict.

Property owners have said the U.S. Department of the Interior amended their original homestead patents, issued before the railroad was transferred to the state under the Alaska Railroad Transfer Act, without their knowledge in 2005 and 2006. Fred Rosenberg of Anchorage, who owns the Dimond Capital Company and Red Robin Alaska, wrote in a letter to the Legislature that the railroad charged him to store snow in the easement, which is technically on his property.

“I want to assure you and the Alaska Railroad that we will continue to work with the Alaska Railroad in a positive way to ensure the safety and transportation opportunities as they occur,” he wrote. “However, I believe that the Alaska Railroad has abridged my private property rights and that those rights should be restored.”

Railroad representatives maintain that the exclusive-use easement is legal in part because the federal government owned most of the railroad’s right-of-way in a fee simple title and had at least an exclusive-use easement in all of it was transferred, according to a document the corporation submitted to the legislature. The language in the railroad transfer act was clear that Congress intended to transfer exclusive use anyway, the document states.

Bill O’Leary, the president and CEO of the railroad corporation, said during the April 6 hearing that the Legislature isn’t the right place for the dispute to be resolved anyway — the court is.

“When it comes to a situation where reasonable people disagree about the nuances of a law, a court of law is where the decision on that point of law should be made,” he said.

People already trespass on the tracks, endangering themselves and railroad operations, O’Leary said. Without exclusive rights to the right-of-way, the railroad may have to slow some speeds because the operators may not know what’s coming down the track, he said.

“If the right of way is turned into a checkerboard of control from Seward to Fairbanks, we can’t make that assumption (of a clear right-of-way),” he said. “We may be forced to reduce our speeds … making it impossible to meet our commitments.”

It would also likely impact the railroad economically, O’Leary said. Petro Star Refinery CEO and President Doug Chapados wrote in a letter to the Legislature opposing the resolution that restricting the exclusive-use easement could impede expansion into the Interior. The General Teamsters Local 959 wrote in a letter opposing the resolution that it would reduce revenue to the railroad, which has already lost revenue in the past several years amid the ongoing state recession.

Recreational users are concerned, too. The Anchorage Snowmobile Club wrote in a letter of support that the Alaska Railroad Corporation has limited access to crossing its tracks before. Boaters on the eastern Kenai Peninsula were frustrated in summer 2016 after the Alaska Railroad Corporation welded a gate shut, blocking off an access point that boaters had frequently used to reach the water. Railroad representatives cited safety concerns about people trespassing in the right-of-way, which runs alongside the lake.

Rep. Lora Reinbold (R-Eagle River) said in the hearing that she wanted the railroad to consider traditional uses that occur in its right of way, including recreational.

“I think as a state we need to set an example and be good neighbors,” she said.

The House voted to support the resolution on April 20 and sent it to the Senate, where it is currently before the Senate Transportation Committee.

Reach Elizabeth Earl at eearl@peninsulaclarion.com.

More in News

Gary Porter, owner of Bald Mountain Air Service, stands in front of his Twin Otter airplane Friday, Oct. 22. (Photo by Sarah Knapp/Homer News)
City Council passes aircraft flat tax rate

The Homer City Council held a public hearing for Ordinance 21-62 concerning a flat tax on aircrafts.

Amelie Bignell, of Soldotna, drops a treat in the bucket of Hayden Jones, of Soldotna, on Saturday, Oct. 31, 2020, at a “trunk-or-treat” event at Orca Theatre on Kalifornsky Beach Road in Alaska. Jones was dressed as Vampirina. (Photo by Jeff Helminiak/Peninsula Clarion)
All Halloween all weekend

A sinister performance, pumpkin carving contest, food drive, pet microchip event and multiple trick-or-treats are on the docket.

Bill Elam (center) nominates Brent Hibbert to be president of the Kenai Peninsula Borough Assembly on Tuesday, Oct. 26, 2021 in Soldotna, Alaska. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
Johnson elected assembly president; Hibbert to be vice president

Prior to Tuesday, Johnson, who represents Kasilof, served as the assembly’s vice president.

Homer Senior Citizen Center residents participated in a worldwide Televeda bingo event to set a Guinness world record on Friday, Oct. 22. (Photo by Sarah Knapp/Homer News)
Homer senior citizens help break world record

The game was held to fight against social isolation in senior communities caused by the COVID-19 pandemic.

This illustration provided by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention in January 2020 shows the 2019 Novel Coronavirus. (CDC)
State hospitalizations still on the rise

Despite a decrease in cases, the state is still seeing hospitalization surge.

The Seward welcome sign is photographed in July 2021. (Photo by Jeff Helminiak/Peninsula Clarion)
Seward vice mayor and council member resigns

The council accept the resignation of Tony Baclaan during its Monday night meeting.

Ben Mohr watches Kenai River Junior Classic participants head out to fish on the Kenai River in Soldotna, Alaska, on Wednesday, Aug. 11, 2021. (Camille Botello / Peninsula Clarion)
Mohr resigns as director of KRSA

He has been the executive director of KRSA for nearly three years.

Heather and Hunter Phillips walk through the Kenai Community Library Haunted Hunt with their mom Kumi Phillips on Tuesday, Oct. 26, 2021. (Camille Botello/Peninsula Clarion)
Scary reads

Spooky literary characters come to life at Kenai library haunted house.

Most Read