Clarion file photo In this June 23, 2013 file photo the tide, wind and waves eat at the bottom of Kenai Bluff during high tide Sunday evening below Toyon Way in Kenai.

Clarion file photo In this June 23, 2013 file photo the tide, wind and waves eat at the bottom of Kenai Bluff during high tide Sunday evening below Toyon Way in Kenai.

Kenai bluff erosion study cost almost doubles

The cost of an upcoming Army Corps of Engineers study necessary to proceed with Kenai’s bluff stabilization project has increased from a May 2015 estimate of $650,000 to a present $1.17 million. The Army Corps and the city of Kenai are splitting the study cost in half. Kenai had previously paid its $252,000 share of the initial cost, and on Wednesday the Kenai City Council unanimously agreed to pay the $333,000 increase with money from a $4 million state grant dedicated to the bluff erosion project.

The Army Corps final feasibility study is one of the last pre-construction steps in a project to shield around 5,000 feet of bluff face near Old Town Kenai from the erosion that presently consumes around 3 feet of bluff-top per year. Although the study was delayed for lack of federal funding from 2011 to 2015, Dave Martinson, the Army Corps of Engineers manager of the Kenai Bluff Stabilization Project, said it is now underway.

Martinson said the study’s estimated cost has risen “because of several factors” including the increased costs of the study’s component elements — particularly real estate and economic analysis — and a wider-than-normal scope.

Martinson said typical Army Corps studies evaluate potential projects on the sole criteria of national economic benefit using a cost-benefit analysis. The study would create a ratio of project cost to economic benefit, considered on a national scale. If the ratio equals more than one — that is, the benefits are greater than the cost — the project can be approved.

Martinson said the Kenai Bluff Stabilization project would not be approved under such an analysis. As an alternative, the upcoming study will be done under a newer administrative structure that allows other considerations to influence the decision.

“What we can do is look at three other accounts,” Martinson said. “One of them is ‘other social’ or cultural. Another one is environmental, and the last one would be regional — regional economic development, as opposed to national. So the nation might not see a benefit, but the region could… We have to do additional analysis to look at those factors.”

This type of evaluation will also allow the Corps to include benefits to private property in its cost-benefit analysis, while the traditional evaluation would only consider public property.

The solution to the bluff erosion problem proposed in previous Army Corps studies is to regrade and vegetate the bluff-top while shielding its base with large stones. In addition to analyzing this solution, the final feasibility study will examine costs and benefits of alternative projects.

Martinson said one alternative to be examined will be leaving the bluff untouched while relocating the buildings and infrastructure on top of it. Another will be moving the entire mouth of the Kenai River to the southwest.

These alternatives were discussed along with other elements of the study at a project charette — a two-day planning session held with Army Corps and Kenai officials at the Kenai City Hall on May 4 and 5, 2015. Martinson said much of the cost increase was due to new requirements brought out at the charrette. One more expensive element is the required real estate study.

“The amount required for the real estate effort definitely increased,” Martinson said, in part because of “the magnitude of the amount of homes we’d have to do that for.”

Army Corps Alaska District Public Affairs Chief Tom Findtner wrote in an email that the final feasibility study will require real estate appraisals of 63 properties, a greater number than first anticipated. Martinson said a requirement unaccounted for in previous estimates — for the appraisals to be reviewed and certified by an a Corps employee in a different district — also added to the cost.

Other elements of the study, listed in the Kenai City Council’s most recent ordinance approving the agreement, include biological assessments of Steller sea lions and beluga whales in the Kenai River, and documentation required by the National Environmental Protection Act.

The Army Corps and Kenai formally entered the cost-share agreement in May 2015, although Kenai first approved signing its part of a similar agreement in September 2011, when the City Council passed a ordinance to pay $253,844 of the study cost — estimated at that time to total $640,989.

Army Corps Alaska District Public Affairs Chief Tom Findtner wrote in an email that the completed final feasibility study is expected to be approved by the Corps in July 2017.

Reach Ben Boettger at ben.boettger@peninsulaclarion.com

More in News

tease
House District 6 race gets 3rd candidate

Alana Greear filed a letter of intent to run on April 5

Kenai City Hall is seen on Feb. 20, 2020, in Kenai, Alaska. (Photo by Victoria Petersen/Peninsula Clarion)
Kenai water treatment plant project moves forward

The city will contract with Anchorage-based HDL Engineering Consultants for design and engineering of a new water treatment plant pumphouse

Students of Soldotna High School stage a walkout in protest of the veto of Senate Bill 140 in front of their school in Soldotna, Alaska, on Wednesday, April 17, 2024. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
SoHi students walk out for school funding

The protest was in response to the veto of an education bill that would have increased school funding

The Kenai Courthouse as seen on Monday, July 3, 2023, in Kenai, Alaska. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
Clam Gulch resident convicted of 60 counts for sexual abuse of a minor

The conviction came at the end of a three-week trial at the Kenai Courthouse

The Kenai Peninsula Borough Assembly meets in Seward, Alaska, on Tuesday, April 16, 2024. (screenshot)
Borough awards contract for replacement of Seward High School track

The project is part of a bond package that funds major deferred maintenance projects at 10 borough schools

Kenai Peninsula Education Association President LaDawn Druce, left, and committee Chair Jason Tauriainen, right, participate in the first meeting of the Kenai Peninsula Borough School District’s Four Day School Week Ad Hoc Committee on Wednesday, Jan. 10, 2024, in Soldotna, Alaska. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
4-day school week committee talks purpose of potential change, possible calendar

The change could help curb costs on things like substitutes, according to district estimates

A studded tire is attached to a very cool car in the parking lot of the Peninsula Clarion in Kenai, Alaska, on Monday, April 15, 2024. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
Studded tire removal deadline extended

A 15-day extension was issued via emergency order for communities above the 60 degrees latitude line

A sign for Peninsula Community Health Services stands outside their facility in Soldotna, Alaska, on Monday, April 15, 2024. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
PCHS to pursue Nikiski expansion, moves to meet other community needs

PCHS is a private, nonprofit organization that provides access to health care to anyone in the community

Jordan Chilson votes in favor of an ordinance he sponsored seeking equitable access to baby changing tables during a meeting of the Soldotna City Council in Soldotna, Alaska, on Wednesday, April 10, 2024. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
Soldotna OKs ordinance seeking to increase access to baby changing tables

The ordinance requires all newly constructed or renovated city-owned and operated facilities to include changing tables installed in both men’s and women’s restrooms

Most Read