Evidence to be argued in sex assault case

Issues surrounding DNA evidence will be argued before the trial for a Sterling woman accused of sexually assaulting a minor can take place.

Laurel Lee, 52, was charged with first-degree sexual assault, kidnapping and second-degree sexual abuse of a minor on Oct. 1, 2014. Alaska State Troopers allege that she pulled a 14-year-old boy off his bicycle near the Sterling Highway, took him into the woods and sexually assaulted him by forcibly performing oral sex.

Lee was scheduled to go to trial Monday. At her trial call Wednesday at the Kenai Courthouse, a possible delay to the trial was discussed as a result of issues surrounding DNA testing.

Lee’s defense attorney, Dina Cale, filed Monday a 25-page motion to dismiss Lee’s indictment or “in the alternative,” suppress DNA testing results from the state. In it, she wrote that the Alaska State Crime Lab used up all the material from six swabs taken from the alleged victim during its testing, making additional testing for saliva futile.

This is important, Cale said at the Wednesday hearing, because part of her defense will be that Lee was the one who was sexually assaulted, not the other way around. Testing the swabs for saliva would have been central to the argument of whether or not Lee forcibly performed oral sex on the alleged victim, she wrote in the motion.

She included in the motion an excerpt from an email from a member of the crime lab that states “during my analysis … I utilized all of the peripheral swab material, effectively leaving no sample remaining for (the independent tester) to reasonably test any physical evidence.”

Cale wrote in the motion that this was not in line with crime lab procedures that an entire sample does not routinely get used if there are more than two swabs.

The defense wanted to independently test the DNA swabs as well as Lee’s pants starting in July 2015, according to the motion.

Cale wrote in the motion that by failing to preserve the material from the six swabs, the state violated Lee’s right to due process.

“The Lab in this case made no effort to retain any of the swabs for further testing, created no notes indicating why it was necessary to consume the entirety of all six swabs, did not clearly note the entire sample had been consumed or attempted to only use as much material as necessary to obtain a DNA profile,” she wrote.

Cale has also filed a motion asking for expedited consideration of the motion, which Assistant District Attorney Kelly Lawson is opposing.

Lawson told the court Wednesday that the motion is too lengthy and poses too big an issue to be dealt with quickly, requesting more time for a separate evidentiary hearing before trial.

Based on what she said she has read of the motion so far, she thinks it requires hearing testimony from someone at the Alaska State Crime Lab.

Lawson said while she understands everyone involved wants to get to trial, the DNA evidence is too important in this case for the motion to be dealt with quickly.

“It’s again our position that we should not rush this issue,” Lawson said.

Kenai Superior Court Judge Carl Bauman set a continued hearing for Monday to hold an evidentiary hearing to go over the issues the motion presents. He said he expects the state to have someone from the crime lab there either in person or over the phone to testify.

Bauman said the result of Monday’s hearing will decide whether everyone is ready to go to trial Tuesday.

Reach Megan Pacer at megan.pacer@peninsulaclarion.com.

More in News

Dr. Anne Zink, Alaska’s chief medical officer, addresses reporters during a Wendesday, March 25, 2020 press conference in the Atwood Building in Anchorage, Alaska. (Photo courtesy Office of the Governor)
State COVID officials brief Soldotna City Council in work session

The council was joined by Chief Medical Officer Dr. Anne Zink and State Testing Coordinator Dr. Coleman Cutchins

COVID-19. (Image courtesy CDC)
State reports more than 4,000 cases this week, 357 on peninsula

The state reported 462 new COVID-19 cases on Friday

Seward junior Lydia Jacoby swims in August 2019 at the Speedo Junior National Championships in Stanford, California. (Photo by Jack Spitser)
Improving through challenging times

Seward junior swimmer Jacoby wins national title at U.S. Open

Kenai Peninsula Borough Superintendent John O’Brien (courtesy photo)
Community input requested in superintendent search

The survey will be open until Dec. 7 at 11:59 p.m.

Photo courtesy Kenai Peninsula Food Bank
Kenai Peninsula Food Banks staff and volunteers assemble food bags for the cities of Kenai and Soldotna recently at the food bank, near Soldotna.
Food Bank keeps setting records

The food bank distributed 267,000 pounds of food in October.

photo illustration
Housing relief program deadlines approaching

The deadline for the Soldotna and borough-wide programs is Monday, Nov. 30 at 5 p.m.

COVID-19. (Image courtesy CDC)
DHSS: 75 new peninsula cases

DHSS reported 505 new cases in Alaska Thursday.

Risk levels
Risk levels: Nov. 19

34 schools are operating 100% remotely until Nov. 25

Kenai Peninsula Borough Mayor Charlie Pierce addresses constituents in a YouTube video posted on Wednesday, Nov. 18, 2020 in Alaska. (Screenshot)
Mayors Pierce and Gabriel respond to COVID-19 in separate videos

Gabriel voiced his concern regarding Central Peninsula Hospital, which reached capacity on Monday.

Most Read