Assembly member files complaint against borough

A Kenai Peninsula Borough Assembly member is challenging a clause included in a legal nonprofit’s contract to defend the borough in an ongoing lawsuit over the assembly’s controversial invocation policy.

Assembly member Willy Dunne of Homer filed a civil complaint in Superior Court in Kenai on Thursday asking for a temporary injunction against the borough administration and Borough Mayor Mike Navarre. The injunction would allow him to publish an op-ed piece he wrote in local newspapers addressing an upcoming hearing on an ordinance he sponsored to remove prayer from the beginning of the assembly meetings. The ordinance, which has several times before been struck down before introduction, narrowly passed introduction with a 5-4 vote at the Feb. 14 meeting and will get a public hearing March 21.

But Dunne was told not to publish the piece, which explained his rationale for wanting to introduce the ordinance, according to the complaint. Publishing his opinion will help contribute to a dialogue that may lead borough residents to communicate with their representatives before the vote, the complaint states.

“(Dunne) believes that he has the right, if not the obligation, to explain to the public his position on the ordinance he has introduced,” the complaint states.

Even though the opinion article begins with a disclaimer that Dunne’s views are his own, Borough Attorney Colette Thompson told him that the Alliance Defending Freedom didn’t approve of his publishing the piece, saying in an email to the borough that it violated the contract. Dunne asked for a copy of the email, which she refused, the complaint states. She also said she wasn’t sure if speaking to his ordinance during the March 21 meeting would violate the contract, according to the complaint.

The complaint alleges that blocking the publication is a violation of Dunne’s right to equal protection under the Alaska Constitution and of Dunne’s right to freedom of expression. The complaint asks for a temporary injunction that would allow Dunne to publish the piece before the meeting.

“(Dunne) will suffer irreparable injury to his right to communicate with his constituents and other Borough residents, and to otherwise carry out the responsibilities of his office, unless the Borough is retrained from prohibiting him from publishing his op-ed piece in the news media serving the Kenai Peninsula Borough,” the complaint states.

The American Civil Liberties Union of Alaska filed a lawsuit in December claiming the assembly’s policy on who can give invocations, passed in October 2016, is unconstitutional. The assembly’s policy requires anyone giving an invocation before the meetings to be a member of a religious group with an established presence on the Kenai Peninsula or a chaplain serving law enforcement agencies, fire departments, hospitals or other similar organizations.

Since the lawsuit was filed, the borough assembly members have had to go through the borough and be approved by the Alliance Defending Freedom before communicating with the media. A clause in the borough’s contract with the Scottsdale, Arizona-based group requires that the borough not make any public statements “orally, in writing, via social media, or any other form of electronic communication without first obtaining approval from ADF.”

Another clause states that the borough “agrees to fully cooperate with Alliance Defending Freedom in the publicizing of non-privileged and non-confidential information relating to this representation, including participation in recorded interviews and testimonials.”

“The borough assembly never saw or approved the contract,” Dunne said. “Another question I’m interested in is does this even apply to elected officials? I’m looking for some clear and binding decision by a judge, by the courts.”

Dunne’s attorney, John McKay of Anchorage, said the complaint is asking the court for a temporary injunction and an expedited hearing, given that the hearing on the ordinance is a week away. They’ll seek answers from the court on how far the language in the contract extends, such as whether it only applies to the borough administration or whether it also applies to elected officials on the assembly, and what kind of communication is included, he said.

“Our main focus is that (Dunne) and other assembly members have the right to speak out on issues that are of importance to their community,” he said.

The borough legal department and the Alliance Defending Freedom did not return requests for comment by press time. A hearing is scheduled for Thursday morning.

The Alliance Defending Freedom agreed to represent the borough in its lawsuit about five days after it was filed, on Dec. 21, according to the contract. The Christian-based nonprofit, which primarily litigates issues related to governmental prayer, marriage rights and abortion, represented clients in the Town of Greece v. Galloway case before the U.S. Supreme Court, a similar case in which several members of the public objected to the town council beginning its meetings with prayers, which were primarily offered by Christian pastors.

The court ruled in favor of the town, saying the ritual was open to every religious group, so it was not discriminatory. The case has been cited multiple times in reference to the legal precedent for the borough assembly’s invocation policy.

Reach Elizabeth Earl at elizabeth.earl@peninsulaclarion.com.

More in News

Sockeye salmon. (Photo via Alaska Department of Fish and Game)
Fish and Game seeks comment on 2022 sport fish stocking plan

The Sport Fish Division plans to release approximately 7 million fish into the Alaska water systems over the next five years.

A map shows which parts of the Chugach National Forest are open to motorized winter recreation use for the 2021-2022 season. (Map courtesy of the U.S. Forest Service)
Parts of Chugach National Forest open to snowmachine use

The 2021-2022 winter motorized season will run through April 30.

Kenai Police Department Chief David Ross explains the purpose of a grant to be used for new radios during a meeting of the Kenai City Council on Wednesday, Dec. 1, 2021 in Kenai, Alaska. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
Kenai Police to update radios using grant money

The department received almost $260,000 through the U.S. Department of Homeland Security.

Democratic Party candidate for governor Les Gara attends a Zoom meeting with Homer residents on Nov. 18, 2021, from his Anchorage, Alaska, home. (Screen capture)
Gara makes election pitch to Homer

Democratic Party candidate for governor Gara visits virtually.

A man missing for more than 40 years was identified by the Alaska Bureau of Investigation as a Chugiak resident who was last seen in 1979. The man’s body was discovered on an island near Anchorage in 1989. (Courtesy photo/Alaska Department of Public Safety)
Body found in 1980s ID’d through DNA analysis

The body, found in 1989, had been unidentified until now.

COVID-19. (Image courtesy CDC)
COVID continues decline; 1 new death

The state had an estimated rolling average of 253.3 cases per 100,000 people over the past seven days.

U.S. Census Bureau Director Steven Dillingham addresses state and Alaska Native leaders Friday, Jan. 17, 2020, in Anchorage, Alaska. Dillingham will travel to Toksook Bay, on an island just off Alaska’s western coast, for the first count on Tuesday, Jan. 21, 2020. (AP Photo/Mark Thiessen)
Census reports minimal state population growth

The Kenai Peninsula Borough’s population grew by about 3,400 people between the 2010 and 2020 census.

The old Homer intermediate school building, showing the Homer Boys & Girls Club and gym on the south side of the building at the corner of the Sterling Highway and Pioneer Avenue.
The old Homer intermediate school building on the corner of the Sterling Highway and Pioneer Avenue, as seen in October 2010. It’s now known as the Homer Educational and Recreational Complex, or HERC. (Homer News file photo)
Homer awards contract to study use of rec complex site

The goal is to help the city understand the maximum use of that property.

Genna Stormer gives Santa a hug during Christmas Comes to Nikiski at the Nikiski Community Recreation Center on Dec. 14, 2019. (Photo by Brian Mazurek/Peninsula Clarion)
December brings the holiday cheer

Groups across the peninsula get into the spirit of the season with public events.

Most Read