Alaskans tendency is to vote no to judge retention

Alaskans may pass a negative judgement on their judges too easily, despite Alaska’s merit-based process for selecting and retaining judges, according to retired Alaska Superior Court Judge Elaine Andrews.

Andrews and Don McClintock, an attorney with Ashburn &Mason and a board member of Justice Not Politics Alaska, presented on Alaska’s judicial selection process and the public’s involvement at last Thursday’s Soldotna Rotary Club meeting at Mykel’s in Soldotna.

Andrews detailed the public process for installing judges, which starts out in the hands of a council and the governor who decide who should fill a vacant seat. After that, every four to 10 years voters decide whether judges should be retained in office and, according to Andrews, the tendency of Alaskan voters is to say “no.”

“I think there is a general sense that people say ‘a pox on all your houses,’ or alternatively, you get to the end of the ballot and think ‘I don’t know anything about these people,’ and you just vote ‘no,’” Andrews said.

In 2016, District 30, which includes Kenai and Soldotna, voted no on two supreme court justices and five superior court judges.

“If you automatically vote ‘no’ it is your prerogative as a voter to do so, but it takes at least two to three years to really train a judge to be good,” McClintock said. “If you start voting them out and cycling through, you lose the ability to have people with great tenure.”

In Alaska, judges are selected from a pool of candidates on a merit-based system. To apply, candidates must submit an application, which opens the candidate up to what Andrews referred to as a “public report card system.”

“That means when there is a judicial vacancy, if you want to be a judge you have to apply. It’s a job application just like any other, except it’s about 30 to 40 pages long,” Andrews said. “Your name goes out to every lawyer in the state and you’re going to get rated by your peers, and it’s a public rating.”

Then a candidate goes before a judicial council, which is made up of three attorney members selected by the Board of Governors of the Alaska Bar Association and three non-attorney members chosen by the governor and approved by the Legislature. This body determines whether a candidate is qualified and sends a list of qualified candidates to the governor who then chooses who will fill the vacancy.

“So, the public participates in the judicial selection basically because you’ve selected the governor and they’re the person whose going to appoint the judge,” Andrews said. “Once a judge is appointed, the judge then stands for retention and this is where folks really have something to say about your judges.”

When a judge stands for retention, the judicial council will create a file on each judge that includes interviews with everyone that appears in the judge’s court on a regular basis, from jurors to social workers, in order to create a well-informed evaluation. This evaluation is then used to recommend either for or against the judge’s retention.

“None out of 10 times, judges are recommended for retention,” Andrews said. “… These are people who have been vetted and found to be not lacking as judges.”

Then, the public is given a “yes” or “no” choice as to whether the judge should retain their seat on the bench. Each judge must receive a majority of “yes” votes in their judicial district for retention.

“The message I find myself giving these days is that … if you have to default to not knowing which way to vote, you have citizens who have done the work for you. You will know if a judge is recommended against (for retention) because it’s a big headline,” Andrews said. “If you don’t know and, assuming you have some confidence in your fellow citizens, probably the default should be yes, rather than no, which is what most people are doing.”

Reach Kat Sorensen at

More in News

Bradley Walters leads the pack up Angle Hill on Wednesday, July 18, 2018, at the Salmon Run Series at Tsalteshi Trails. (Photo by Jeff Helminiak/Peninsula Clarion)
Summer races kick off at Tsalteshi

The annual Salmon Run Series 5K races start on July 6 and continue every Wednesday through Aug. 3

Central Emergency Services staff wait to receive doses of Pfizer’s COVID-19 vaccine on Friday, Dec. 18, 2020, in Soldotna, Alaska. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
Assembly mulls bond for new CES fire station

Replacement of the current station is estimated to cost $16.5 million

Buldozers sit outside of the former Kenai Bowling Alley on Thursday, June 23, 2022, in Kenai, Alaska. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
Old Kenai bowling alley comes down

The business closed in 2015

Landslide debris surrounds part of Lowell Point Road on Friday, June 3, 2022, in Seward, Alaska. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
Assembly looks to mitigate future Lowell Point Road dangers

Assembly members approved legislation supporting agencies working to address the “repetitive hazards”

The Alaska Department of Health And Social Services building in Juneau has no visible signs indicating the department is splitting into two agencies as of Friday. Top officials at the department said many of the changes, both physical and in services, are likely weeks and in some cases months away. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
Little sign of big change for DHSS

No commissioner at new department, other Department of Health and Social Services changes may take months

Nate Rochon cleans fish after dipnetting in the Kasilof River, on June 25, 2019, in Kasilof, Alaska. (Photo by Victoria Petersen/Peninsula Clarion)
King closures continue; Kasilof dipnet opens Saturday

The early-run Kenai River king sport fishery remains closed, and fishing for kings of any size is prohibited

An "Al Gross for Congress" sign sits near the driveway to Gross’ home in Anchorage, Alaska, on Tuesday, June 21, 2022, after he announced plans to withdraw from the U.S. House race. Gross has given little explanation in two statements for why he is ending his campaign, and a woman who answered the door at the Gross home asked a reporter to leave the property. (AP Photo/Mark Thiessen)
Alaska judge rules Sweeney won’t advance to special election

JUNEAU — A state court judge ruled Friday that Alaska elections officials… Continue reading

Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion 
Soldotna City Manager Stephanie Queen listens to a presentation from Alaska Communications during a meeting of the Soldotna City Council on Wednesday, March 9, 2022 in Soldotna, Alaska.
ACS pilots fiber program in certain peninsula neighborhoods

The fiber to the home service will make available the fastest internet home speeds on the peninsula

Most Read