Borough drops plan to access North Road gravel pit

  • Monday, January 12, 2015 10:29pm
  • News

While two groups have parallel plans to extend the North Road, a Kenai Peninsula Borough ordinance to fund a gravel pit access road to aid in the project construction was withdrawn from the Jan. 6 borough assembly agenda.

The ordinance, sponsored by Mayor Mike Navarre, was to appropriate $668,000 from the Land Trust Fund to access the Suneva material site, located on 140 acres of borough property off Mile 32 of the Kenai Spur Highway. The borough and the Apache Alaska Corporation have separate plans to extend the Spur Highway beyond Captain Cook State Park and the gravel pit is in close proximity to the proposed project area.

Before the ordinance could be introduced, Apache contacted the borough and notified them it hasn’t selected a material site for their project. If Apache proceeds with the purchase of material, it would assume responsibility for the road development to the gravel pit site.

At the assembly finance committee meeting Jan. 6, Navarre said there is no need to build the access road unless Apache buys gravel from the borough.

“In order to access the gravel pit, a different right-of-way needs to be built,” he said. “There is no need for us to build this road because we can’t do the (North Road) project this year and Apache has not yet made a determination. We may end up getting both roads built.”

The borough’s project is on hold while administration works with the Alaska Department of Transportation to obtain a categorical exclusion, which would bypass the cost of an environmental impact study. The borough has $5 million in federal funds earmarked for the project and cannot proceed until they receive a categorical exclusion.

Borough Chief of Staff Paul Ostrander said to get a categorical exclusion, the project needs to fit in a listed category depending on how environmentally sensitive the area is. He said after much deliberation from officials in Juneau, DOT determined the project didn’t meet the requirements and will now have to seek concurrence with the Federal Highway Administration.

Last September, the borough sent letters of support for the project from the Alaska Department of Fish and Game, Kenai National Wildlife Refuge, Corps of Engineers and Kenai Watershed Forum to FHA.

“Instead of it being a slam-dunk now FHA has to sign off on it,” he said. “Now it’s a more difficult threshold to meet but DOT is still optimistic they can get it primarily for the support from local agencies.”

Apache is in the design process to construct a similar 7.5-mile road for oil and gas exploration on Tyonek owned-land. The proposed road would continue from the end of the Spur Highway to Otter Creek in the Gray Cliffs subdivision.

Apache spokesperson Lisa Parker said Apache has applied for permits with the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers. Because road construction would be undertaken on wetlands, the company is working with the Corps to complete a federal Clean Water Act Section 404 wetlands permit.

The Corps public comment period for the project ends Jan. 21. Then the Corps has up to 120 days, or April 15, when it can deem Apache’s application complete, she said. After that time Parker said Apache is hopeful to receive a construction permit from the borough road service to begin to clear a path for the road this summer.

“There are no guarantees but we are confident we will get approved before the borough,” Parker said. “Should our project not proceed, the borough is using federal funds. Both are still going down parallel paths and if one doesn’t go as planned, the other can still go forward.”

Parker said Apache has talked with the borough about using the Suneva pit as a potential material site, but has not landed on a particular site.

“It’s an option but there are other material sites,” she said.

The borough planning commission granted a material site permit, which allows the borough to develop the site.

According to a memo from Marcus Mueller, Borough Land Management Officer, and Craig Chapman, Borough Finance Director, Apache has expressed interest in purchasing approximately 130,000 cubic yards of material for this project from the Suveva material site. The royalty rate for sand and gravel is $3.25 per cubic yard. Based on Apache’s request its total purchase from the borough would be $422,500.

The borough planned to make the access road bid process contingent on Apache securing funds for their project. The $668,000 figure is based on an engineer’s estimate, according to the memo.

Navarre said the timing of the ordinance was contingent on either entity moving forward in the North Road project. If Apache determines not to go forward this year, the borough will wait until a more opportune time to develop access to the material site.

“The building of the road and use of gravel could be used to make our match for federal funds to accomplish the North Road extension,” Navarre said. “If we do that and Apache doesn’t go forward then we start working on how we approach that project so we can get it underway next year.”

Reach Dan Balmer at

More in News

From left, Sen. Jesse Bjorkman, R-Nikiski, east side setnetter Ken Coleman and Konrad Jackson present information about a bill establishing a voluntary buyback program for east side setnet fishery permits during a Senate Finance Committee meeting on Monday, Feb. 19, 2024, in Juneau, Alaska. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
Senate committee hears setnet buyback bill

The East Side of Cook Inlet Set Net Fleet Reduction Act is sponsored by Nikiski Sen. Jesse Bjorkman

Rep. Cathy Tilton, R-Wasilla, presides over a mostly empty House chamber at the end of an hourslong recess over education legislation on Monday in Juneau (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
Tie vote kills early House debate on education funding

Lawmakers went into an hourslong recess that ended with adjournment until Tuesday morning

Mock-up illustration of in-development Kahtnu Area Transit Bus (Image courtesy Kenaitze Indian Tribe)
Kenaitze purchase Kenai’s former Kendall Ford building for transportation hub

Hetl Qenq’a will also serve as a hub for the upcoming Kahtnu Area Transit, a fixed route public bus service

Peninsula Clarion government and education reporter Ashlyn O’Hara stands in the hallways of the Alaska State Capitol in Juneau on Monday. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
Clarion reporter working in Juneau for legislative exchange

Reporter Ashlyn O’Hara will be covering statewide issues with a local lens

Voters fill out their ballots at the Challenger Learning Center in Kenai, Alaska on Election Day, Nov. 8, 2022. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
Bjorkman leads local campaign finance pack, reports show

The reports, due Feb. 15 for candidates running for state office in 2024, offer a glimpse at the position from which candidates will start this election year

Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion
Caitlin Babcock addresses students during Luke Herman’s government class at Soldotna High School on Feb. 8 in Soldotna.
Amid education funding shortfalls, local students advocate for support

‘This state will lose us and generations of students after’

Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion
Soldotna Mayor Paul Whitney, center, and representatives of Aspen Creek Senior Living celebrate a ribbon-cutting during a grand opening event at Aspen Creek Senior Living in Soldotna, Feb. 9.
Aspen Creek celebrates expansion, readies to widen its community

The facility is in one of the areas described in the city’s Soldotna Downtown Riverfront Redevelopment Plan

Department of Health logo. (Graphic by Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
Kenai Peninsula resident dies of Alaskapox, 1st documented fatal case

Seven total infections of Alaskapox have been reported to the State’s Section of Epidemiology

In this image provided by the Cooper Landing Emergency Services, emergency personnel respond to reports of an avalanche on Tuesday, Feb. 13, 2024, in Cooper Landing, Alaska. One backcountry skier died and two others were injured in an avalanche on Alaska’s Kenai Peninsula, as warm weather raises the risk for such events in the state. (Clay Adam/Cooper Landing Emergency Services via AP)
Anchorage man killed in Kenai Peninsula avalanche

The avalanche swept away three backcountry skiers

Most Read