Kirsten Dunst portrays photojournalist Lee Smith in “Civil War.” (Promotional photo courtesy A24)

Kirsten Dunst portrays photojournalist Lee Smith in “Civil War.” (Promotional photo courtesy A24)

Review: An unexpected battle for empathy in ‘Civil War’

Garland’s new film comments on political and personal divisions through a unique lens of conflict on American soil

If I named my favorite filmmakers, I would probably come quickly to Alex Garland.

That’s odd, because before seeing his latest, “Civil War,” I had only seen two of his films, and only really liked one of them. “Ex Machina” is a film I fell in love with when I dragged my high school friends to the Orca Theater to watch a “cool, new sci-fi movie” in 2014 — I think I was alone in my enjoyment. Garland’s most recent, “Men,” is a haunting, fascinating film with a revolting conclusion that never quite landed with me.

Good or otherwise, something about the dense ideas Garland’s shown a proclivity to grapple with and the gripping pace with which he ratchets tension make for some wild movies, if nothing else.

“Civil War” is every bit the dense and intense thriller Garland is known for. It’s a film that I’m not sure I have a firm grasp on, despite it roiling around in my head now for the better part of a day.

ADVERTISEMENT
0 seconds of 0 secondsVolume 0%
Press shift question mark to access a list of keyboard shortcuts
00:00
00:00
00:00
 

Kirsten Dunst stars as Lee Smith, a hardened photojournalist traveling through a version of the United States twisted by civil war. She’s on a mission to shoot the president — his photo, that is. Joining her are an eclectic crew of media: reporting partner Joel played by Wagner Moura; a veteran reporter from another publication, Sammy, played by Stephen McKinley Henderson; and aspiring photographer Jessie tagging along played by Cailee Spaeny.

The relationships of the core team, road tripping down the coast, are charming, against a backdrop that’s anything but. The crew move in their press van from New York City to Washington, D.C., along their way encountering and documenting violence and conflict as their nation comes apart.

The details or politics of the war are never made clear. The film depicts atrocities with a bleak, uncompromising eye — but it never explains them. In sequences where the reporters follow soldiers as they assault a building, the objective is never revealed.

“Civil War” is a film about humanity. Its most affecting sequences are when the reporters move up with their cameras and capture images of grief, pain or triumph. These images regularly intercut the action — lingering just for a moment on the human toll of the conflict.

War is so secondary as to be not worth detailing, what matters are the ways people are hurt by division — it what appears to me a call for empathy.

Dunst drives the film with a stunning performance as Smith, shown in an early sequence to be grappling with the realities of photographing hurt, but resolute in her belief that telling those stories is valuable. She maintains an icy distance from her subjects. It’s through her relationship with Jessie and the experiences they share on the journey that she interrogates that distance.

“Civil War” isn’t a weird controversy-courting action film, like trailers might make it seem. It’s a heavy, violent film that comments on political and personal divisions through a unique lens of conflict on American soil.

It’s weird and affecting in a way that very well may fail to connect with people, the kind of film that left me in stunned silence as the credits began to roll. It’s a film I’m going to revisit as I continue to grapple with everything it’s trying to say.

“Civil War” is playing at the Kenai Cinema and the Orca Theater this weekend. Check showtimes at catheaters.com or orcatheater.com.

Reach reporter Jake Dye at jacob.dye@peninsulaclarion.com.

Kirsten Dunst, Wagner Moura, Stephen McKinley Henderson and Cailee Spaeny appear in “Civil War.” (Promotional photo courtesy A24)

Kirsten Dunst, Wagner Moura, Stephen McKinley Henderson and Cailee Spaeny appear in “Civil War.” (Promotional photo courtesy A24)

More in Life

Fika co-owners Sierra Moskios-Schlieman and Tyler Moskios-Schlieman pose for a photograph with their Taste of Homer plaque at the 2025 HarborFest in June. (Photo courtesy of Fika Coffee Roasters)
Local coffee roastery to compete in ‘Great Alaska Coffee Roaster Competition’

The competition will take place on Sunday, Aug. 17 at the Alaska State Fairgrounds in Palmer.

A vintage KBBI mug, repurposed and filled with various office supplies, rests in the Homer News office window on Friday, Aug. 8, 2025. (Chloe Pleznac/Homer News)
KBBI seeks art submissions for annual membership mugs

The mugs will be released in October, as an incentive for the fall membership drive.

In September 1946, the Alaska Sportsman Magazine published “Moose Ranch,” an article by Mamie “Niska” Elwell. The story describes Steve Melchior’s moose-ranching operation from the 1920s and features two photographs of Melchior.
Steve Melchior: Treasured peninsula pioneer with a sketchy past — Part 5

In June 1913, a peninsula game warden informed the governor that Melchior was raising a moose calf on his mining property.

Liam Neeson is Lt. Frank Drebin Jr. in “The Naked Gun.” (Promotional image courtesy Paramount Pictures)
On the Screen: Profoundly dumb, deeply hilarious

‘Naked Gun’ brings back the goofball comedy.

These scones are an easy treat and feature locally-grown fruit. Photo provided by Tressa Dale
Family meals and memories

These easy scones feature fresh cherries, grown locally.

Freshly caught fish lay at the author’s feet. (Photo by Meredith Harber/courtesy)
Minister’s Message: Fishing together

We, despite our differences, are one human population, attempting to make life each day.

Team Seaweed presents their research on Monday, July 28, 2025 in Pioneer Hall at Kachemak Bay Campus. (Chloe Pleznac/Homer News)
‘Girls on the Water’ expedition presents on summer adventures and research

The program, run through UAF, helps expose young women to coastal ecosystems

A community member works with clay on a wheel in the ceramics studio at Homer Council on the Arts in Homer, Alaska. Photo provided by Homer Council on the Arts
Homer’s art scene heads into fall

Homer Council on the Arts’ activities are bursting onto the scene for all to enjoy.

Salmonfest-goers crowd in front of the Ocean Stage during Blackwater Railroad’s performance on Saturday, Aug. 2, at the Kenai Peninsula Fairgrounds in Ninilchik. (Delcenia Cosman/Homer News)
Celebrating salmon, art and culture

Salmonfest was held in Ninilchik last weekend, featuring music, community and advocacy.

Most Read