Backers of initiative to ban set-netting misleading public

These must be exciting times for the Alaska Fisheries Conservation Alliance. If their campaign is successful, they will use Alaska voters to try to end the careers and lifestyles of some of our most historic Kenai Peninsula families.

As the AFCA soldiers work frantically around the state to gather the necessary signatures needed to get this setnet ban before the voters, there is no requirement to be truthful or honest in their quest to get people to sign the petitions.

Using buzzwords like “curtains of death” and “devastation of bycatch,” it will not be hard to gather signatures from prospective voters that have little or no knowledge about Alaska fisheries issues. Petition signers and eventually voters may simply think they are doing the right thing in helping to eliminate “evil set-netting.”

At the heart of this issue is Kenai River king salmon. While king salmon stocks state wide are experiencing a down cycle, Kenai River kings have a more troubling problem. The historically large kings seem to have been eliminated and what remains are a disproportionate number of immature small males called jacks.

What’s most troubling about this whole issue is that the sponsors and supporters of this set-net ban initiative drive, AFCA, KRSA, KRPGA, which are Kenai River guide groups, made their careers catching Kenai River king salmon right where they have returned to spawn. Their main target was the “biggest” of the kings, the historically giant females that spawn in the main stem of the Kenai River — the ones that are now mostly gone.

As these trophy sized fish began to disappear, hooking and releasing was allowed, which continued to stress the ones that remained. Claiming the noble high ground of “turning fish loose and not killing them,” guides claimed their hook-and-release actions caused no harm to kings, while the evidence actually shows quite the opposite to be true.

It’s crazy that the goal of this initiative is to eliminate set-netters so the guides can get back on the river in full force and continue to target spawning kings. Most of us that live here on the Peninsula understand exactly what’s going on here. It will be much easier, however, to fool voters from other parts of the state — Anchorage, Mat-Valley, Fairbanks.

I would encourage everyone to visit the webpage of the Alaska Fisheries Conservation Alliance http://www.akfisheries.org/about-1-1/, and see who the board members are. Read their mission statement and the testimonials. These folks call themselves our neighbors, but they are certainly not our friends.

Go to Kenai River Sportfishing Association, http://www.krsa.com/, and see who the board members are. See what they are saying about our set-netter neighbors.

It’s up to us that live here on the Peninsula to “out” these guide groups for what they are and to figure a way to derail their agenda . Their vision of the future does not include most of the rest of us — the ones that feel responsible for protecting the Kenai and Kasilof Rivers and the salmon that return there.

More in Opinion

Dr. Karissa Niehoff
Opinion: Protecting the purpose: Why funding schools must include student activities

High school sports and activities are experiencing record participation. They are also… Continue reading

Sharon Jackson is the Alaska State Chair for U.S. Term Limits. Photo courtesy U.S. Term Limits
Term limits ensure fresh leadership and accountability

75 years after the 22nd amendment, let’s finish the job and term limit Congress.

Larry Persily. (Juneau Empire file photo)
Opinion: Ferry system swims or sinks with federal aid

The Alaska Marine Highway System has never fully paid its own way… Continue reading

Biologist Jordan Pruszenski measures an anesthetized bear during May 2025. Biologists take measurements and samples before attaching a satellite/video collar to the bear’s neck. Photo courtesy Alaska Department of Fish and Game
The scent of barren ground grizzly

Unlike most of us, Jordan Pruszenski has held in her arms the… Continue reading

A vintage Underwood typewriter sits on a table on Tuesday, Feb. 22, 2022, at the Homer News in Homer, Alaska. (Photo by Michael Armstrong/Homer News)
Letters to the editor

Masculinity choices Masculinity is a set of traits and behaviors leading to… Continue reading

Gov. Mike Dunleavy gestures during his State of the State address on Jan. 22, 2026. (Photo by Corinne Smith/Alaska Beacon)
Opinion: It’s time to end Alaska’s fiscal experiment

For decades, Alaska has operated under a fiscal and budgeting system unlike… Continue reading

Northern sea ice, such as this surrounding the community of Kivalina, has declined dramatically in area and thickness over the last few decades. Photo courtesy Ned Rozell
20 years of Arctic report cards

Twenty years have passed since scientists released the first version of the… Continue reading

Larry Persily. (Juneau Empire file photo)
Opinion: World doesn’t need another blast of hot air

Everyone needs a break from reality — myself included. It’s a depressing… Continue reading

Larry Persily. (Juneau Empire file photo)
Opinion: Dunleavy writing constitutional checks he can’t cover

Gov. Mike Dunleavy, in the final year of his 2,918-day, two-term career… Continue reading

A vintage Underwood typewriter sits on a table on Tuesday, Feb. 22, 2022, at the Homer News in Homer, Alaska. (Photo by Michael Armstrong/Homer News)
Opinion: Federal match funding is a promise to Alaska’s future

Alaska’s transportation system is the kind of thing most people don’t think… Continue reading

Photo courtesy of the UAF Geophysical Institute
Carl Benson pauses during one of his traverses of Greenland in 1953, when he was 25.
Carl Benson embodied the far North

Carl Benson’s last winter on Earth featured 32 consecutive days during which… Continue reading

A vintage Underwood typewriter sits on a table on Tuesday, Feb. 22, 2022, at the Homer News in Homer, Alaska. (Photo by Michael Armstrong/Homer News)
Letters to the editor

Central peninsula community generous and always there to help On behalf of… Continue reading