Nikiski senior Bethany Carstens signs her letter of intent, with father Dan Carstens looking on, to play at Division I basketball at Chicago State University in a ceremony Thursday at Nikiski High School. (Photo by Joey Klecka/Peninsula Clarion)

Nikiski senior Bethany Carstens signs her letter of intent, with father Dan Carstens looking on, to play at Division I basketball at Chicago State University in a ceremony Thursday at Nikiski High School. (Photo by Joey Klecka/Peninsula Clarion)

Nikiski’s Carstens signs to play Div. I hoops

This is a week that Nikiski’s Bethany Carstens will always remember.

Last Saturday, the Nikiski senior helped lead the Bulldogs to their first high school volleyball state championship in 18 years.

Thursday afternoon, Carstens committed to her future by signing her collegiate letter of intent to play basketball at Division I Chicago State University, making it official in a ceremony in the Nikiski High commons area.

Carstens is likely the first peninsula basketball player to sign a Div. I commitment in 25 years, since 1993 Soldotna graduate Molly Tutor took her talents to Arizona State. Rachel Thompson, a 2015 Nikiski grad, currently competes for the Div. I Washington State women’s soccer team, but originally signed to play at the community college level.

Carstens credited her parents, Dan and Debbie Carstens, along with former girls basketball coach Scott Anderson and wife Sari, club traveling coach Ryan Hales, and Soldotna assistant coach Curtis Schmidt, who coached Carstens in her youth days at the comp level.

“I makes me feel really thankful for my parents and all the time they’ve put in,” Carstens said. “All my coaches have been teaching me, and all my friends’ parents, they were a big part of this too, and my friends, because they’ve pushed me.”

Carstens said she is looking to go into the nursing program that the school offers.

Chicago State competes in the Western Athletic Conference in the NCAA. Carstens will look to build on a program that went 1-29 overall last year, but Carstens said she chose Chicago State due to the programs’ commitment to her, which includes a full ride scholarship.

“It feels like a relief,” she said. “I don’t have to worry about that anymore, I know where I’m going. It just feels like the next step.”

Carstens said she chose the Cougars basketball program over other offers from Division III and NAIA programs, as well as both the University of Alaska Anchorage and Fairbanks programs, because of how committed Chicago State was to her.

“I feel like if I went there, I could be the best basketball player I could be,” she said. “It’s a DI program, I have a full ride so I don’t have to worry about money issues. Everything’s perfect.”

Bethany’s father, Nikiski High principal Dan Carstens, said the commitment that the school gave his daughter was exceptional, explaining that the current Chicago State recruiting coordinator watched Carstens compete last summer in a camp. The recruiter at the time worked at Central Methodist University in Missouri and liked what he saw in Carstens’ game.

After making the move to Chicago State, the recruiter pushed to have Carstens on the team.

“He started talking to the head coach and said, ‘Hey I’ve got video of this two-guard that you’ve got to see,” said Dan Carstens. “And the head coach said, ‘Naw I’m not interested in a two-guard, we’re not looking for that right now’, and he told her to just watch the video.

“She watched the video, came back the next day and said, ‘I’m looking for a two-guard now’. Totally changed her mind.”

With a desire to have the 2018 Class 3A Alaska Player of the Year on their team, Dan Carstens said it was the right fit for Bethany.

“To feel wanted like that, that’s what I want for my daughter,” he said. “To be wanted in a program, not as an after thought. She is one of their top choices.”

Carstens added that his daughter’s signing represents the kind of quality student athletes Alaska is producing that often may go unnoticed.

“It means the programs we have here, if you’re willing to put in the extra time, they’re quality programs,” he said. “The high school coaches here were encouraging and recognized what she had.”

The signing also signals the pinnacle of a remarkable comeback after Carstens suffered two tears of the anterior cruciate ligament to both knees — one before her freshman year, and the second at the end of her sophomore season, when Nikiski was competing in the region tournament.

Cartens’ first ACL tear caused her to miss the entire 2015-16 campaign, while the second one forced her out of the 2017 state tournament, where the Bulldogs finished fifth.

“How many kids would want to come back and still put in the time and effort?” Dan Carstens asked. “It’s a testament to that kid and the work ethic, determination and love of the sport.”

Nikiski’s Carstens signs to play Div. I hoops
Nikiski’s Bethany Carstens (right) dodges Barrow defender Jordan Ahgeak in the second half of a quarterfinal contest March 22, 2018, at the Class 3A state tournament at the Alaska Airlines Center. (Photo by Joey Klecka/Peninsula Clarion)

Nikiski’s Bethany Carstens (right) dodges Barrow defender Jordan Ahgeak in the second half of a quarterfinal contest March 22, 2018, at the Class 3A state tournament at the Alaska Airlines Center. (Photo by Joey Klecka/Peninsula Clarion)

More in Sports

Photo courtesy Pete Dickinson
The SoHi junior varsity and varsity wrestling teams compete in the Battle for the Bird at Soldotna High School on Wednesday, Nov. 26. The Kenai Peninsula Athletics Sapphire dance team performed the halftime show.
SoHi, Nikiski wrestling teams compete for Thanksgiving dinner

The Stars and Bulldogs faced off during the Battle for the Bird duals last Wednesday.

Runners of all ages gather for a photo in the Homer High School Commons after the annual Thanksgiving Turkey Trot on Thursday, Nov. 27, 2025, in Homer, Alaska. Due to icy outdoor conditions, the official run was moved to the high school halls. Photo courtesy Matthew Smith
55 turn out for Homer Turkey Trot

Each Thanksgiving morning, the Kachemak Bay Running Club and the City of… Continue reading

The varsity wrestling team is pictured after the Robin Hervey individual tournament in Kodiak on Nov. 22, 2025. Photo courtesy of Pete Dickinson
Sports briefs: Soldotna hockey, wrestling teams secure wins at weekend tournaments

SoHi hockey won the End of the Road tournament in Homer and the wrestling team gained 20 individual wins.

The Kenai Central High School varsity volleyball team is named the 2025 3A Volleyball State Championship Tournament, held Nov. 13-15, 2025, at the Alaska Airlines Center in Anchorage, Alaska. The Kardinals defeated the Nikiski Bulldogs 3-2 in a "rematch" championship game on Saturday, Nov. 15, securing their third state title in the last four years. Photo courtesy of the Kenai Volleyball Booster Club
Kenai Central takes home 3rd volleyball state title

The Kards defeated Nikiski in a rematch championship game on Saturday during the state tournament in Anchorage.

Soldotna High School wrestlers won six individual championships during the Lancer Smith Memorial wrestling tournament in Wasilla Nov. 14-15. Photo courtesy of SoHi Stars Wrestling on Facebook
SoHi wrestling sweeps Lancer Smith tourney, eyes state title

SoHi girls and boys took first and second place as teams, respectively.

Soldotna’s Gracelyn Altobelli attacks against Nikiski’s Addison Perkins on Tuesday, Sept. 16, 2025, at Soldotna High School in Soldotna, Alaska. (Photo by Jeff Helminiak/Peninsula Clarion)
Sports briefs: Soldotna volleyball claims third Northern Lights Region III title

The SoHi Stars will compete at the state tournament this weekend.

The Homer Mariners varsity football team celebrates their victory after the Division III state championships game on Saturday, Oct. 18, 2025, in Wasilla, Alaska. Photo provided by Justin Zank
Homer, Kenai football receive Division III All-State awards

Players on the Homer High School and Kenai Central High School varsity… Continue reading

The Homer Mariners varsity football team celebrates their victory after the Division III state championships game on Saturday, Oct. 18, 2025, in Wasilla, Alaska. Photo provided by Justin Zank
Homer football brings home back-to-back state titles

The Mariners defeated Barrow 20-0 on Saturday, winning the state championships for the second year in a row.

Homer's Nik Macauly runs past Kenai Central's Carson Cramer on Saturday, Sept. 27, 2025, at Ed Hollier Field at Kenai Central High School in Kenai, Alaska. (Photo by Jeff Helminiak/Peninsula Clarion)
Homer football tops Kenai

The Homer football team defeated Kenai Central 44-6 on Saturday in Mid… Continue reading

tease
Saturday: Brown Bears top Mountain Kings, win 2 of 3 at Showcase

The Kenai River Brown Bears finished up play at the North American… Continue reading

tease
Kenai volleyball ties for 3rd in Gold Bracket at West Spiketacular

The Kenai Central volleyball team tied for third in the Gold Bracket… Continue reading

tease
Soldotna football tops Lathrop, captures 20th straight conference title

The Soldotna football team defeated Lathrop 27-14 on Friday in Railbelt Conference… Continue reading