Deep-pocketed organizations litigate borough’s prayer issue

One of the biggest complaints members of the public have had about the Kenai Peninsula Borough Assembly’s invocation policy lawsuit is the cost. As it turns out, neither the borough nor the plaintiffs are paying the full bill.

The plaintiffs are represented by the American Civil Liberties Union of Alaska, a nonprofit that regularly litigates cases around the U.S. based on civil rights. The organization got involved in the controversy over the assembly’s invocation policy, which requires anyone offering a prayer before the assembly’s regular meetings to be part of an organization that meets regularly to share a religious perspective or a chaplain, in October 2016 and formally sued the borough in December.

The ACLU sued on behalf of two residents, Lance Hunt and Iris Fontana, and Elise Boyer of Homer joined as a third plaintiff in January.

On the borough’s side, the Alliance Defending Freedom is offering legal counsel and footing at least part of the cost. The Scottsdale, Arizona-based nonprofit regularly litigates cases around the U.S. related to religious freedom, abortion and marriage rights. Notably, the organization represented the town of Greece, New York in the Town of Greece v. Galloway case, which the assembly has cited as a precedent for its invocation policy.

Brett Harvey, an attorney with the Alliance Defending Freedom, is co-representing the Kenai Peninsula Borough with Anchorage attorney Kevin Clarkson, whom the borough contracted independently. Harvey represented the town of Greece before the U.S. Supreme Court in 2014, a case that resulted in the Supreme Court upholding the right of the Greece city council to begin its meetings with a prayer, as long as it is open to people of all religions.

The borough’s policy does not draw any lines other than requiring someone to be part of a group or a chaplain. Harvey said governmental bodies can set rules on public participation, and in this case, the invocation is open to religious groups of all types.

“In this case, they have said any assembly within the community that meets regularly to discuss their religious perspective, regardless of what the perspective is … whatever that faith is, quite frankly, even if you deify Satan,” he said. “If you have an assembly that you gather together and discuss these things and further your religious perspective, you are invited to appoint someone and put them on the list.”

Federal courts have repeatedly upheld the right of legislative bodies to begin their meetings with prayer, Harvey said. The borough’s practice is very similar to the one that Greece, New York had in place, he said.

“It happens across the country at virtually every government level and has for centuries,” he said. “… those who really don’t want prayers, that disapprove that they have them at all, that’s what we’ve been litigating for the last 20 years in a variety of contexts.”

The borough’s legal department staff was doing research on attorneys that had litigated similar cases when it reached out to the Alliance Defending Freedom. Both Harvey and Clarkson have worked on similar cases. The Alliance Defending Freedom is working pro-bono on the case, which means they are covering the borough’s costs except for incidental expenses like copies, said Borough Mayor Mike Navarre. The costs are not firm at this point, though, he said. The case is still making its way through the courts, currently on its way back to state court after the plaintiffs filed to remove it from federal court in January.

“We’re trying to do it as cost-effectively as we can and still defend the code,” Navarre said.

The ACLU and the Alliance Defending Freedom have clashed before on the same issue. During the arguments on Town of Greece v. Galloway, the ACLU of New York filed an amicus brief in the Supreme Court supporting the plaintiffs. In 2015, they met again when the ACLU of North Carolina sued Rowan County, which began its county commission boards with a prayer and Harvey co-counseled on the case. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 4th Circuit upheld the county’s policy in September 2016.

Both organizations have deep pockets, funded by donations and membership dues. The Alliance Defending Freedom, a 501(c)3 nonprofit, worked with an approximately $48.3 million budget in 2014, the most recent year of tax documents available. The organization also has a supporting foundation, the ADF Foundation, reporting $4.8 million in net assets at the end of 2014, according to tax documents.

The ACLU, a 501(c)4 nonprofit, listed an approximately $50.6 million budget in 2014, according to its Form 990 tax documents. It also has a supporting foundation, the American Civil Liberties Union Foundation, that recorded approximately $327.6 million in assets in 2014, according to its tax documents. The ACLU of Alaska, registered as its own nonprofit, recorded $57,600 in net assets in 2014, and its corresponding foundation had $374,894 at the end of 2014, according to tax documents.

If the borough loses the lawsuit, though, it’ll still get stuck with the fees. Alaska law makes public entities liable for the legal fees of both parties if they lose a lawsuit, a concern Navarre voiced to the assembly multiple times during the discussion over the suit.

Reach Elizabeth Earl at elizabeth.earl@peninsulaclarion.com.

More in News

Signs direct voters at the Kenai No. 3 precinct on Tuesday, Oct. 5, 2021. (Camille Botello/Peninsula Clarion file)
Signs direct voters at the Kenai No. 3 precinct for Election Day on Tuesday, Oct. 5, 2021. (Camille Botello/Peninsula Clarion)
Local candidates report support from state PACs

Labor unions and the National Education Association are among the groups putting money into Kenai Peninsula state election races

Signs and examples on the recycling super sack at the Cook Inletkeeper Community Action Studio show which plastics are desired as part of the project in Soldotna, Alaska, on Aug. 11, 2022. Plastics from types 1, 2, 4 and 5 can be deposited.(Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
Local nonprofit accepting plastics for synthetic lumber project

The super sack receptacles can be found on either side of Soldotna

This July 28, 2022, photo shows drag queen Dela Rosa performing in a mock election at Cafecito Bonito in Anchorage, Alaska, where people ranked the performances by drag performers. Several organizations are using different methods to teach Alaskans about ranked choice voting, which will be used in the upcoming special U.S. House election. (AP Photo/Mark Thiessen)
Groups get creative to help Alaska voters with ranked voting

Organizations have gotten creative in trying to help voters understand how to cast their ballot, as the mock election featuring drag performers shows

A school bus outside of Kenai Central High School advertises driver positions on Wednesday, Aug. 10, 2022, in Kenai, Alaska. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
Staff shortage, gas prices change school bus routes

The changes do not apply to the district’s special education students

The cast of “Tarzan” rides the Triumvirate Theatre float during the Independence Day parade in downtown Kenai, Alaska on Monday, July 4, 2022. (Camille Botello/Peninsula Clarion)
The show goes on as Triumvirate seeks funding for new theater

The troupe has staged shows and events and is looking to debut a documentary as it raise funds for new playhouse

Aaron Surma, the executive director for National Alliance on Mental Illness Juneau and the Juneau Suicide Prevention Coalition, leads a safety plan workshop Tuesday night hosted by NAMI and the Juneau Suicide Prevention Coalition. The workshop was a collaborative brainstorming session with Juneau residents about how to create a safety plan that people can use to help someone who is experiencing a mental health or suicide crisis. (Clarise Larson / Juneau Empire)
Study shows a rise in anxiety and depression among children in Alaska

Increase may indicate growing openness to discussing mental health, according to experts

Alaska Lieutenant Governor Kevin Meyer addresses election information and misinformation during a press conference on Wednesday, Aug. 10, 2022. (Screenshot)
With a week to go, officials work to clear up election confusion

Officials provided updated ballot statistics, fielded questions from reporters and clarified misconceptions about the current election cycle

COVID-19. (Image courtesy CDC)
State reports 21 new COVID deaths; cases down from last week

20 of the reported deaths took place from May to July

A closeup of one of the marijuana plants at Greatland Ganja in Kasilof, Alaska, as seen on March 19, 2019. (Photo by Brian Mazurek/Peninsula Clarion)
Assembly streamlines process for marijuana establishment license applications

License applications will now go straight to the Kenai Peninsula Borough Assembly for consideration

Most Read