Court hears arguments on invocation lawsuit

Court hears arguments on invocation lawsuit

The Kenai Peninsula Borough Assembly’s policy on who can give invocations had its day in court.

The American Civil Liberties Union and the Kenai Peninsula Borough’s lawyers argued the case before Alaska Superior Court Judge Andrew Peterson in Anchorage on Wednesday. The sides didn’t disagree about any of the material facts leading up to the case but disagreed about a number of particulars, including whether the assembly’s current policy constitutes a violation of freedom of speech and freedom of association.

Following a controversy over an invocation delivered by a member of the Satanic Temple in August 2016, the assembly passed a policy requiring anyone delivering an invocation to be a member of an association with an established presence in the Kenai Peninsula Borough that meets primarily for religious purposes, or a chaplain serving a fire department, hospital, the military or other similar organizations. In December 2016, the ACLU sued, saying the policy unfairly stopped individuals who were not part of established religions from giving invocations.

Lawyers for both sides argued their points in the hearing Wednesday, with the borough holding that the invocations are government speech and thus do not violate the establishment clause, which prohibits governments from establishing a religion, and that the people giving invocations are not speaking publicly as private individuals but as designated agents of the government.

Attorney Kevin Clarkson, who represented the borough, said the policy is open to any religion as long as it’s an association with a presence in the Kenai Peninsula Borough and that the policy does not actually define what an association is.

“The borough doesn’t have to go seek anybody out, but they’ve created the opportunity by which any association can take the avenue to give the invocation,” he said.

ACLU attorney Eric Glatt, who represents three plaintiffs from the peninsula, argued that the people giving invocations do so with individual speech and that the policy effectively blocks anyone not part of an association with enough people on the Kenai Peninsula to formally establish itself. One of the plaintiffs, Elise Boyer of Homer, falls into this situation, as there are not enough people who identify as Jewish in Homer nor a rabbi or priest to establish a synagogue, and thus she cannot meet the criteria to give an invocation, Glatt said.

Altogether, the ACLU has levied claims of the violation of freedom of speech, freedom of association, a failure to provide equal protection under the law and a violation of the establishment clause.

“(The borough has) to clear all four of these hurdles for the policy to remain intact,” he said.

Peterson heard the arguments for a little more than an hour Wednesday before retiring to consider the information and make a decision.

Reach Elizabeth Earl at eearl@peninsulaclarion.com.

More in News

Salmon are preserved in a cooler by dipnetters on Saturday, July 10, 2021 in Kenai, Alaska. (Camille Botello / Peninsula Clarion)
Sockeye bag and posession limits increased

The new limits are six per day and 12 in possession.

The United States’ women’s 4x100-meter medley relay team, Regan Smith, Lydia Jacoby, Torri Huske and Abbey Weitzeil, celebrates at the podium after winning the silver medal at the 2020 Summer Olympics, Sunday, Aug. 1, 2021, in Tokyo, Japan. (AP Photo/Gregory Bull)at the 2020 Summer Olympics, Sunday, Aug. 1, 2021, in Tokyo, Japan. (AP Photo/Gregory Bull)
Jacoby honored with resolution, parade

Jacoby, 17, is a rising senior at Seward High School and won a gold medal for Team USA.

Joanne Jenkins distributes backpacks and school supplies to a line of cars at the Peninsula Community Health Services KidFest event on Wednesday, Aug. 4, 2021 in Kenai, Alaska. (Camille Botello/Peninsula Clarion)
KidFest distributes back-to-school supplies

Different colored backpacks were stocked with basic school supplies.

Interior Secretary Deb Haaland, speaks during a news conference at the offices of Denver Water Thursday, July 22, 2021, in Denver. (AP Photo/David Zalubowski)
Haaland hasn’t made decision on King Cove land exchange

King Cove residents have long sought a land connection through Izembek National Wildlife Refuge to Cold Bay.

A resident casts their vote in the regular municipal election Tuesday, Oct. 6, 2020 at the Kenai Peninsula Fairgrounds in Ninilchik, Alaska. (Photo by Megan Pacer/Homer News)
Filing period open for municipal elections

City councils, the Kenai Peninsula Borough Assembly and the Kenai Peninsula Borough School District Board of Education all have seats available.

Gov. Mike Dunleavy at an Anchorage news conference on Sept. 15, 2020. (Courtesy photo/Office of Gov. Mike Dunleavy)
Dunleavy encourages Alaskans to get vaccinated

Dunleavy emphasized that the vaccines had been developed as part of the Trump administration’s Operation Warp Speed.

Setnets are packed up on the Kasilof River on June 25, 2021, in Kasilof, Alaska. (Camille Botello / Peninsula Clarion)
East side setnetters denied fishery reopening

The Alaska Board of Fisheries held an emergency meeting Monday after eastside… Continue reading

King salmon hang on a wall on March 24, 2018 on the Spit in Homer, Alaska. (Photo by Megan Pacer/Homer News)
What’s causing the king salmon decline?

Officials aren’t exactly sure.

Peninsula Clarion file
Auctioneers Andy Kriner, left, and Rayne, Reynolds celebrate a successful sale during the 4-H Junior Market Livestock Auction at the Kenai Peninsula Fair on Aug. 17, 2019 at the fairgrounds in Ninilchik.
4-H expo to kick off in Soldotna on Friday

The expo was previously held in Ninilchik, but the Soldotna City Council voted to relocate it.

Most Read