Cook Inlet Energy unsuccessfully contests fine

The Alaska Oil and Gas Conservation Commission’s final decision to put a $446,000 penalty on Cook Inlet Energy remains final.

In an order Tuesday, the commission — Alaska’s regulator of the hydrocarbon industry — denied Cook Inlet Energy’s appeal of the fine, originally issued Feb. 14 for an incident in 2013. AOGCC began considering Cook Inlet’s arguments against the penalty March 6.

Between November 2013 and January 2014, Cook Inlet Energy’s Sword 1 oil well on the west Cook Inlet’s Kustatan Peninsula (also known as West Forelands) operated for 42 days with a non-functioning AOGCC-required safety valve system. The commission alleged that one of the two required valves was non-functional, and the other missing, during a Dec. 11, 2013 inspection; Cook Inlet Energy later denied the second valve was missing at the time.

On Feb. 16, 2014, an AOGCC inspector saw the second valve installed, but witnessed it failing a safety test, requiring the well to be shut down. The well remained active, however, until March 7, 2014, while Cook Inlet Energy sought, unsuccessfully, to waive the shut-down requirement.

In a later hearing on the penalty, Cook Inlet Energy Production Manager David Kumar told the commission the well was a low-energy design that required a hydraulic jet pump rather than natural pressure to create flow from the well, making the safety valves unnecessary. However, Cook Inlet Energy does not dispute the safety valve violations, according to Tuesday’s order.

“Instead, (Cook Inlet Energy) claims it acted in good faith, that its violations were mitigated and that the fines are inconsistent with past fines imposed by AOGCC,” the order states.

The order, signed by AOGCC chair Kathy Forester and commissioner Hollis French — lacking the signature of the third AOGCC commissioner Dan Seamount — questions the claim of good faith by noting Cook Inlet Energy’s “conscious disregard” of the safety valve requirement and “significant history of regulatory compliance issues.”

“The potential for harm was significant; that no harm occurred was simply luck,” the order states.

The commission recorded eight violations by Cook Inlet Energy between 2011 and June 2016, some of which resulted in enforcements. They include a late 2014 citation for Cook Inlet Energy’s unapproved flaring of 24.6 million cubic feet of natural gas between Nov. 26, 2013 and Feb. 2014. AOGCC proposed a $294,834 fine for the flaring, which was dropped after a review.

As for Cook Inlet Energy’s claim that the penalty is inconsistent with past penalties, Tuesday’s order states that some of the smaller past penalties Cook Inlet Energy cites were issued prior to a statutory penalty increase.

“Others are cited without any articulation as to how the decision cited is inconsistent with the AOGCC’s decision here,” the order states.

The $406,000 penalty has been a subject of dispute between Cook Inlet Energy and AOGCC since it was originally issued in Dec. 2014 as an $806,000 penalty. After Cook Inlet argued that the fee was excessive in a February 2015 appeal hearing, AOGCC dropped it to the current amount in a May 2015 order.

Two appeals since have resulted in no changes to the penalty. Cook Inlet Energy now has the option to further appeal to the Alaska Superior Court within 30 days.

More in News

Snow coats an eroding bluff near the mouth of the Kenai River on Friday, March 3, 2023, in Kenai, Alaska. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
Kenai accepting bids on bluff stabilization project

The announcement means that contractors can start submitting their proposals for how they’d complete the work and how much it would cost to do so

A stack of the Seward Journal is pictured. The town’s only daily newspaper published its last edition Nov. 27. (Photo via Seward Journal Facebook page)
‘A thing of the past’

Seward Journal calls it quits after struggle to keep newspaper afloat

Tim Navarre and Dana Cannava discuss a preliminary Soldotna route for the Kahtnu Area Transit with Planner Bryant Wright at the Challenger Learning Center of Alaska in Kenai, Alaska, on Wednesday, Nov. 29, 2023. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
Getting people where they need to go

Plans for Kenaitze Indian Tribe’s Kahtnu Area Transit move forward

A state plow truck clears snow from the Kenai Spur Highway on Wednesday, Nov. 2, 2022, in Kenai, Alaska. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
DOT identifies roads included in brine reduction plan

The department said its goal is to reduce brine use overall in the region by 40%

Soldotna High School senior Josiah Burton testifies in opposition to the proposed cut of Kenai Peninsula Borough School District theater technicians while audience members look on during a board of education meeting on Monday, March 6, 2023 in Soldotna, Alaska. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
School board finance group reviews expenditures ahead of upcoming budget cycle

As the Kenai Peninsula Borough School District prepares to grapple with another… Continue reading

Members of the Kenai/Soldotna Fish and Game Advisory Committee raise hands to vote in favor of a proposal during a meeting at Cook Inlet Aquaculture Association in Kenai, Alaska, on Monday, Nov. 20, 2023. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
Silver salmon, personal use fishing discussed by advisory committee

The group set their recommendations on a variety of proposals to the State Board of Fisheries

Hoses pump water along Patrick Drive to help mitigate flooding near Kalifornsky Beach Road on Friday, July 21, 2023, near Kenai, Alaska. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
Borough spent almost $78k responding to flood events during disaster declaration

Most of the funds were spend in the northwest area of Kalifornsky Beach Road

The National Weather Service’s map shows a winter weather advisory, in orange, effective for much of the eastern Kenai Peninsula. (Screenshot)
Heavy snow, blowing winds forecast for Turnagain Pass on Wednesday

Snow accumulations of up to 16 inches are expected

The Kenai Courthouse is seen on Monday, July 3, 2023, in Kenai, Alaska. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
Grand jury adds charges in October killing of Homer woman

The indictment was delivered on Nov. 8

Most Read