Shrubs grow outside of the Kenai Courthouse on Monday, July 3, 2023, in Kenai, Alaska. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)

Shrubs grow outside of the Kenai Courthouse on Monday, July 3, 2023, in Kenai, Alaska. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)

Opinion: Vote yes to retain Judge Zeman and all judges on your ballot

Alaska’s state judges should never be chosen or rejected based on partisan political agendas

  • By Donna Goldsmith, Tom Amodio, Bruce Botelho, Michael Geraghty, Joelle Hall, Barbara Hood, Erin Jackson-Hill, Debra Dzijuksuk O’Gara and Paul Seaton
  • Friday, November 1, 2024 1:30am
  • OpinionElectionsPoint of view

We are a diverse group of Alaskans who serve as members of the board for Alaskans for Fair Courts. We urge you to vote YES to retain every judge and justice on the ballot — including Judge Adolf Zeman.

We are two former attorneys general who were appointed by Republican governors, a retired tribal judge, a union leader, a civil rights advocate/community leader, a former Republican legislator who is also a commercial fisherman, several attorneys and a retired businesswoman.

While our political views on almost any matter span the broad political spectrum within Alaska, one very important belief unites us all: an unwavering belief that Alaska’s state judges should never be chosen or rejected based on partisan political agendas. We share a deep commitment to protecting judges who have met the highest of professional judicial standards and who have demonstrated a commitment to uphold Alaska’s Constitution and the laws of this great state. And we heartily applaud every judge whose decisions reflect their best effort to follow the laws and facts of each case — despite the popularity of any of their decisions.

Why should you care? Because Alaska’s state judges are the bulwark against attacks on the Alaska Constitution and the law. They handle 95% of all cases, affecting a wide variety of issues that affect all Alaskans, sometimes involving core constitutional rights that you value. A single judge makes dozens of decisions in a single day. This year, 15 judges/justices are on the general election ballot in the Third Judicial District, the largest judicial district in the state and home to two-thirds of the state’s population. It runs from Homer on the Kenai Peninsula, to Anchorage, including Dillingham and Kodiak and up to the Mat-Su.

Unlike many other states, Alaska’s judges do not run campaigns to become — or remain — a judge. Alaska’s Constitutional framers intentionally decided to keep money and partisan politics out of judicial selection and retention. After researching other states where judges ran political campaigns to be appointed to the court, Alaska’s framers concluded that Alaskans would be better served by judges who demonstrated integrity, knowledge of and commitment to the law, and who would be fair and impartial in conducting their courtrooms. The framers did NOT want judges to be looking over their shoulders worrying whether their decision would be unpopular. The framers wanted every Alaskan to be served by judges who represent “the best available timber.”

The framers also decided that judges should serve limited terms rather than lifetime appointments, requiring judges to “stand for retention” every few years by appearing on the ballot. Retention offers you an important role — to make the final decision about whether a judge should remain on the court based on their professional record.

We are confident that every judge and justice on the ballot this year has served Alaskans with honor, integrity, fairness, and a strong commitment to the law. Each has been rigorously evaluated by the Alaska Judicial Council, which has recommended a YES

Vote on all the judges.

This year, one judge has garnered a disproportionate share of attention — for the wrong reason. There is a campaign to remove Judge Zeman. The reason? Judge Zeman issued a ruling that public money cannot be used for purchases of private educational services because doing so violates Art. VII, Sec. 1 of Alaska’s Constitution, which prohibits the use of “public funds for the direct benefit of any religious or other private educational institution.”

The campaign wants you to remove Judge Zeman because Judge Zeman’s ruling does not coincide with the campaign groups’ ideology.

This approach is no way to run an effective judicial system. Alaska’s judges are obligated to follow the law, wherever it takes them. That is their job. Alaskans cannot afford to allow popularity to run our courts. Rather, Alaskans want, and deserve, judges who, like Judge Zeman, do their very best to understand and follow the law, and who do so with integrity, fairness and impartiality and professionalism. Alaskans can never be well-served by judges who bend their decision-making to something that might seem popular to some but which violates the Constitution under which we live.

Judge Zeman, a lifelong Alaskan appointed by Gov. Mike Dunleavy, received near-perfect ratings from attorneys, court employees, and, importantly, jurors.

Every Alaskan should be proud — and grateful — to have a judge of Judge Zeman’s caliber on the bench. He reflects the dedication and respect for the law and for those who come into his courtroom. We ask you to retain him. Join us and vote YES to retain every judge on the ballot, including Judge Zeman.

Donna Goldsmith, Tom Amodio, Bruce Botelho, Michael Geraghty, Joelle Hall, Barbara Hood, Erin Jackson-Hill, Debra Dzijuksuk O’Gara and Paul Seaton are board members for Alaskans for Fair Courts. Alaskans for Fair Courts is a nonprofit group of Alaskans from across the political and ideological spectrum who believe justice should not be for sale, judges should be selected and retained based upon their merit, and the framers of the Alaska Constitution got it right by keeping partisan and other politics out of the courtroom. Read more about their work at akfaircourts.com.

More in Opinion

A state plow truck clears snow from the Kenai Spur Highway on Wednesday, Nov. 2, 2022, in Kenai, Alaska. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
Opinion: Use of the brine shows disregard for our community

It is very frustrating that the salt brine is used on the Kenai Peninsula often when it is not needed

Therese Lewandowski. (Photo provided)
Point of View: Inflation, hmmm

Before it’s too late and our history gets taken away from us, everyone should start studying it

A cherished "jolly Santa head" ornament from the Baisden Christmas tree. (Photo provided)
Opinion: Reflections of holidays past

Our family tradition has been to put up our Christmas tree post-Thanksgiving giving a clear separation of the holidays

Screenshot. (https://dps.alaska.gov/ast/vpso/home)
Opinion: Strengthening Alaska’s public safety: Recent growth in the VPSO program

The number of VPSOs working in our remote communities has grown to 79

Soldotna City Council member Linda Farnsworth-Hutchings participates in the Peninsula Clarion and KDLL candidate forum series, Thursday, Sept. 5, 2024, at the Soldotna Public Library in Soldotna, Alaska. (Photo by Erin Thompson/Peninsula Clarion)
Opinion: I’m a Soldotna Republican and will vote No on 2

Open primaries and ranked choice voting offer a way to put power back into the hands of voters, where it belongs

Nick Begich III campaign materials sit on tables ahead of a May 16, 2022, GOP debate held in Juneau. (Peter Segall / Juneau Empire file photo)
Opinion: North to a Brighter Future

The policies championed by the Biden/Harris Administration and their allies in Congress have made it harder for us to live the Alaskan way of life

Shrubs grow outside of the Kenai Courthouse on Monday, July 3, 2023, in Kenai, Alaska. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
Opinion: Vote yes to retain Judge Zeman and all judges on your ballot

Alaska’s state judges should never be chosen or rejected based on partisan political agendas

A vintage Underwood typewriter sits on a table on Tuesday, Feb. 22, 2022, at the Homer News in Homer, Alaska. (Photo by Michael Armstrong/Homer News)
Point of View: District 6 needs to return to representation before Vance

Since Vance’s election she has closely aligned herself with the far-right representatives from Mat-Su and Gov. Mike Dunleavy

The Anchor River flows in the Anchor Point State Recreation Area on Saturday, Aug. 5, 2023, in Anchor Point, Alaska. (Delcenia Cosman/Homer News)
Opinion: Help ensure Alaskans have rights to use, enjoy and care for rivers

It is discouraging to see the Department of Natural Resources seemingly on track to erode the public’s ability to protect vital water interests.

A sign directing voters to the Alaska Division of Elections polling place is seen in Kenai, Alaska, Monday, Oct. 21, 2024. (Photo by Erin Thompson/Peninsula Clarion)
Vote no on Ballot Measure 2

A yes vote would return Alaska to party controlled closed primaries and general elections in which the candidate need not win an outright majority to be elected.

Derrick Green (Courtesy photo)
Opinion: Ballot Measure 1 will help businesses and communities thrive

It would not be good for the health and safety of my staff, my customers, or my family if workers are too worried about missing pay to stay home when they are sick.