Murkowski: House chose party over energy policy

  • Monday, December 19, 2016 10:33pm
  • News

Sen. Lisa Murkowski accused House leaders of forgoing negotiations on her overarching energy policy bill to begin holiday celebrations early.

Still steaming more than a week after it became clear her signature piece of legislation would die in the lame duck session of Congress, Murkowski said in a Dec. 16 interview that House Speaker Paul Ryan, R-Wisconsin, chose to adjourn the House Dec. 8 to attend a holiday party in New York rather than round up votes for final passage of the final House-Senate conference committee version of her Energy Policy Modernization Act.

According to Murkowski, Ryan and other House Republicans had tickets for a Dec. 8 train from Washington, D.C., to New York City that they didn’t want to miss and thus what would have been the first federal energy reform package in nearly 10 years was left for dead in the last hours of a nearly two-year journey.

“The Speaker said ‘We’ve run out of time’ because they wanted to get on the party train,” Murkowski said.

A spokesperson for Ryan could not be reached for comment.

As chair of the Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee, Murkowski began working on the energy reform bill nearly as soon as Congress convened in 2015 following the mid-term elections in which Republicans took control of the Senate.

The legislation package touched many aspects of domestic energy policy, from ensuring timely decisions on LNG export permits to federally recognizing hydropower as renewable energy and providing federal loan guarantees to states for deployment of energy efficiency and new energy systems, according to her office.

Far more than an energy bill, it also included a fish and wildlife conservation and lands access package long-sought by sportsmen’s groups; a land management package of more than 50 individual bills; and funding for fire mitigation and water management provisions for drought-riddled Western states, aspects championed by Murkowski’s partner on the legislation Washington Sen. Maria Cantwell, the ranking Energy committee Democrat.

In a last-ditch Dec. 8 speech on the Senate floor Murkowski emphasized the bill had gone through the proper committee process with input from both sides of the aisle — a rarity in Washington.

It passed the Senate 85-12 in April with priorities from 80 senators, Murkowski has noted, and the final conference report had provisions from 74 senators and 224 members of the House.

The House passed its Republican-heavy version of energy reform in late May and conference work began in July.

In using regular order, “Sen. Cantwell and I did what people said you couldn’t do,” Murkowski said in an interview.

She also accused House members on the conference committee of late changes to their demands in negotiations, saying negotiating hurdles had mostly been cleared in the days before everything fell apart.

They claimed a water settlement for the Yakima River watershed in central Washington, a key provision of Cantwell’s, would violate the House ban on earmarks, according to Murkowski.

However, Alaska’s senator contends the House turned around and approved similar California-specific provisions in the $12 billion water infrastructure bill President Barack Obama signed into law, also on Dec. 16.

A spokesman for Rep. Don Young, who served on the conference committee along with Murkowski, said the congressman would have rather seen something pass than nothing at all.

“Ultimately, the settlement point that (Young) came to was he supported some sort of energy package this year, while recognizing that moving forward we would have had to do a package that took a broader scope for energy policy in the country,” Young spokesman Matt Shuckerow said.

Shuckerow also said he had not heard of Murkowski’s claim as to why the House adjourned when it did.

Murkowski stressed that getting more Republican priorities in an energy bill next Congress won’t necessarily be any easier, despite the forthcoming change in the White House because Republicans will hold 52 seats in the Senate, not close to the 60 votes needed to squelch a Democrat filibuster.

“Those who think it’s going to be easier next year don’t understand the realities of the Senate,” she said.

When it became clear the House was done, Murkowski took to salvaging what she could from her bill. She spent Dec. 9 pulling the dozens of land conveyance and management provisions from the bill in an effort to get passage through unanimous consent in the Senate.

The land provisions included approval of a right-of-way through Denali National Park for a potential state gasline to avoid a seismic fault on other routes and a long-awaited swap of Southeast timberland between the Alaska Mental Health Trust Land Office and the Forest Service among other swaps for fire and water management in western states.

In the end, she was unsuccessful.

“Everything was sacrificed; so we have to start all over,” Murkowski conceded.

Elwood Brehmer can be reached at

More in News

Johni Blankenship signs her name after being sworn in as Soldotna City Clerk at a city council meeting on Wednesday, Nov. 30, 2022, in Soldotna, Alaska. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
Blankenship sworn in as Soldotna city clerk

Blankenship comes to the City of Soldotna from the Kenai Peninsula Borough

Demonstrators hold signs supporting Justin Ruffridge and Jesse Bjorkman for state office on Election Day, Nov. 8, 2022, in Kenai, Alaska. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
Nov. 8 election results certified

The outcomes of local races for state office remain unchanged

The Kenai Peninsula Borough administration building is photographed on Tuesday, March 17, 2020, in Soldotna, Alaska. (Photo by Victoria Petersen/Peninsula Clarion)
4 candidates vie for borough mayoral seat

The special election is slated for Feb. 14

Spruce trees are dusted with snow on Dec. 22, 2020, in the Kenai National Wildlife Refuge near Soldotna, Alaska. Some areas of the refuge are open to harvest of holiday trees for non-commercial uses beginning Thanksgiving. (Photo by Jeff Helminiak/Peninsula Clarion)
Snowmachine use permitted in Kenai National Wildlife Refuge beginning Dec. 1

Areas now available include those “traditionally open to snowmachine use”

Stephanie Queen. (Courtesy photo)
Queen to step down as Soldotna city manager

The resignation comes as Kenai finalizes negotiations with potential city manager Terry Eubank

Houses are seen in Seward, Alaska on Thursday, April 15, 2022. (Camille Botello/Peninsula Clarion)
Seward delays action on short-term rental regs

The limits are meant to ameliorate the city’s housing shortage

Kenai Central High School Culinary Students roll out dough for Christmas cookies as part of bake sale preparation on Tuesday, Nov. 29, 2022, at Kenai Central High School in Kenai, Alaska. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
Guest chefs ready to help

High school culinary students will do holiday baking for you

COVID-19. (Image courtesy CDC)
COVID-19: Hospitalizations fall statewide, rise locally

The state reported no new resident deaths from COVID-19 this week

Senator-elect Jesse Bjorkman, center, participates in a candidate forum Oct. 17, 2022, at the Soldotna Public Library. Bjorkman was elected in November to represent Alaska Senate District D on the Kenai Peninsula. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
Bjorkman joins Senate majority caucus

He is one of 17 members of the bipartisan group

Most Read