When Herring gull nestlings peck at the red dot on their parent’s bill, the parents regurgitate food. Is this an instinctive or learned behavior? (Photo credit by Todd Eskelin/Kenai National Wildlife Refuge)

When Herring gull nestlings peck at the red dot on their parent’s bill, the parents regurgitate food. Is this an instinctive or learned behavior? (Photo credit by Todd Eskelin/Kenai National Wildlife Refuge)

Refuge notebook: Why seagulls have a red dot on their bill


There are lots of “seagulls” flying around the Kenai Peninsula. At the mouth of the Kenai River alone, more than 30,000 Herring and Glaucous-winged gulls have taken up residence!

Have you ever stopped to really look at one? Have you noticed the red dot near the tip of the lower bill? Have you ever wondered why it is there?

If you answer yes to these questions, then you’ve got the hallmarks of a good naturalist. If you choose to research it, you’re on the path to being a scientist. If you take it so far as to conduct experiments, you might even win a Nobel Prize.

That’s precisely what happened to Nikolaas (Niko) Tinbergen. This Dutch ornithologist, a professor for many years at Oxford University, was co-awarded the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine in 1973 partly for figuring out what that red dot does.

Gull nestlings peck at the red dot to get their parents to regurgitate food to them. But this relationship is much more complex than that.

During the summer of 1946, right after World War II ended, Dr. Tinbergen and his students used gull dummies (cutouts and plaster effigies) to investigate which stimuli gull chicks responded to the most. By varying the color, contrast, head shape, bill shape, and the position and “lowness” of the bill, Tinbergen was able to demonstrate that this innate behavior of pecking was elicited by the red color of the dot contrasted against the yellow bill.

Tinbergen used this information to see if he could improve on nature. He created a “supernormal” stimulus by painting three white rings at the end of a long red rod. This abstract dummy received 26 percent more pecks than a three-dimensional, realistic plaster model of a gull’s head and bill.

“Big deal,” you might say disparagingly. Tinbergen shared this Nobel Prize with Karl von Frisch and Konrad Lorenz, who figured out how bees communicate by “dancing” and how goslings imprint on their goose parents, respectively.

All three biologists showed how some behaviors are innate or genetically programmed (as opposed to learned), triggered by specific key stimuli. Collectively, these three founded the modern field of ethology, or the study of animal behavior.

The press release for this Nobel Prize addresses the significance of these scientists and their work to the rest of humanity: “Man is [also] equipped with a number of fixed action patterns, elicited by specific key stimuli. This holds true for the smile of the infant and for the behavior of a mother to her newborn child.

“Psychosocial situations leading to conflicts, for example as a result of disturbances of the social organization of an animal society, may lead both to abnormal behavior and to somatic diseases such as hypertension and myocardial infarction. Research within these fields has led to important results, for example psychiatry and psychosomatic medicine, especially as regards possible means of adapting environment to the biological equipment of man with the aim of preventing maladaptation and disease.”

In his Nobel Lecture, Dr. Tinbergen addressed the unorthodox decision of awarding this prize to three men who had previously been regarded as “mere animal watchers.” Tinbergen stated that their revival of the “watching and wondering” approach to studying behavior could indeed contribute to the relief of human suffering.

I encourage you to read The Herring Gull’s World (1960), a book written by Dr. Tinbergen in such an engaging way that even the nonscientist can appreciate the wonder of gull behaviors. And take notice the next time you see a gull (or a goose or a bee) in your wanderings on the Kenai Peninsula — there’s certainly more there than meets the casual eye.

Dr. John Morton is the supervisory biologist at Kenai National Wildlife Refuge. Find more Refuge Notebook articles (1999-present) at https://www.fws.gov/Refuge/Kenai/community/Refuge_notebook.html.

More in Sports

Reece Tousignant, 15, of Green Bay, Wisconsin, poses with a pink salmon he caught on Monday, Aug. 3, 2020, at the Nick Dudiak Fishing Lagoon in Homer, Alsaka. (Photo by Michael Armstrong/Homer News)
Reeling ‘Em In: Nick offers tips for catching those cohos

I’m still receiving complaints that the smug silvers are continuing to drive… Continue reading

Refuge Notebook: Migrations of the Kenai Lowland caribou

Being a seasonal biology technician has its perks. Every summer is a… Continue reading

The author is seen here in July pleasantly enjoying a mountaintop in Denali National Park, with no training in mind. (Photo courtesy of Gillian Braver)
Tangled Up in Blue: Pandemic Priorities

I had a lot of goals at the start of this year.… Continue reading

Kenai Watershed Forum holds golf event

The Kenai Watershed Forum held its first golf outing Saturday at Kenai… Continue reading

Runners take off at the start of the Salmon Run Series in Soldotna, Alaska, on July 8, 2020. (Photo by Jeff Helminiak/Peninsula Clarion)
Salmon Run Series enters final week

The Salmon Run Series, which was moved to a virtual race series… Continue reading

Fishermen try to catch silver and pink salmon on Tuesday, July 21, 2020, at the mouth of Resurrection Creek in Hope, Alaska. (Photo by Michael Armstrong/Homer News)
Reeling ‘Em In: Silvers are still not strong in Fishing Hole

While Turk and I were watching the water evaporate at The Fishing… Continue reading

Refuge Notebook: What happened when the ocean warmed

The 2014 to 2016 marine heatwave, or “the blob,” in the Gulf… Continue reading

Alaska 20.
Alaska 20 sees season end

Alaska 20 saw its season end Sunday with a 4-3 loss to… Continue reading

Alaska 20.
Alaska 20 drops first 2 games at state

Alaska 20, the No. 7 seed, got off to a rough start… Continue reading

Most Read