What others say: Stricter penalties for Iditarod dog deaths

  • By Ketchikan Daily News editorial
  • Monday, March 12, 2018 10:46am
  • Opinion

Nothing like an Iditarod dog.

It’s an athlete with the desire to train, compete, perform at peak and accept its reward.

And it likes to run, and, if given the chance, will run all the way from Anchorage (or Willow) to Nome.

The Iditarod Trail Sled Dog Race started in 1973 under the guidance of Joe Redington Sr., who 25 years later ran the race at the age of 80. He’s since passed, but the race continues.

Not without incident.

It wouldn’t be worth competing if not for the challenge of it. The mushers compete as much against the climate as they do each other. They wreck sleds, lose dogs, encounter wildlife, and endure injuries and illness, all the while taking care of their teams of dogs.

This year 67 teams are competing in the Iditarod that started over the weekend. If all teams have at least 16 dogs, that’s 1,072 dogs on the run and 4,288 paws making a path to Nome.

This year the race has drawn increased criticism because of allegations of inhumane treatment of the dogs, in part because eight dogs have died during the race in the past five years. Those deaths, while few compared to the number of dogs who ran in the race’s 46-year history, are gut wrenching for mushers, the race itself, fans and sponsors.

Mushers and others connected with the Iditarod are talking about disqualifying teams of which one of the dogs dies. They’re also thinking about increased rest periods along the trail and fewer than the 16 dogs allowed per team to reduce carelessness (the winner must cross the finish line with at least five dogs and can leave others at checkpoints along the way).

Iditarod dogs are some of the most well cared for dogs; they’re treated like two-legged Olympic Games athletes in most cases. But, if rules can be adopted to eliminate dogs’ deaths, it would be well for not only the dogs but the Iditarod’s reputation and Alaska tradition of racing sled dogs.

Of the ideas proposed, one resonates. As with teams in the Olympics, it is the whole team that wins or loses. So it should be in the Iditarod. Let mushers drop dogs off with handlers along the trail; those dogs are still part of the victory.

But if a dog dies, then the team should be disqualified — at least for the current race. With a rule like that, if the dogs aren’t sufficiently pampered to date, they would be in Iditarods to come.

— Ketchikan Daily News,

March 7

More in Opinion

Larry Persily. (Juneau Empire file photo)
Opinion: Trying to deny voters a choice is getting to be a bad habit

Alaskans this fall will vote for the third time whether they prefer… Continue reading

The Juneau offices of the Alaska Permanent Fund Corp. are seen Monday, June 6, 2022. (James Brooks/Alaska Beacon)
Stewardship for generations

The Alaska Permanent Fund is celebrating a 50-year milestone.

Jim Jansen and Joe Schiernhorn are co-chairs of the Keep Alaska Competitive Coalition. Photo courtesy of Keep Alaska Competitive
Opinion: Alaska’s winning formula

Alaska is experiencing an energy renaissance, thanks to a stable fiscal framework… Continue reading

Pam Groves of the University of Alaska Fairbanks looks at bones of ancient creatures she has gathered over the years from northern rivers. The remains here include musk oxen, steppe bison and mammoth. Photo courtesy Ned Rozell
What killed the world’s giants?

Most of the large animals that have walked the surface of Earth… Continue reading

A vintage Underwood typewriter sits on a table on Tuesday, Feb. 22, 2022, at the Homer News in Homer, Alaska. (Photo by Michael Armstrong/Homer News)
Letters to the editor

Grateful for community generosity I am writing to express my heartfelt thanks… Continue reading

Larry Persily. (Juneau Empire file photo)
Opinion: Reelection should not be the measure of success

The Alaska Legislature will reconvene in Juneau in less than two weeks,… Continue reading

A 9-year-old female wolf with a satellite collar limps alongside the highway near Denali National Park in February 2019. Photo courtesy Ned Rozell
The Riley Creek pack’s sole survivor

As I was driving down the highway one spring day eight years… Continue reading

Sen. Jesse Bjorkman, R-Nikiski, speaks during a joint luncheon of the Kenai and Soldotna Chambers of Commerce in Kenai, Alaska, on Wednesday, June 4, 2025. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
Opinion: Alaskans deserve a real voice in decisions about public land

Like many Alaskans, I was caught off guard when meetings were announced… Continue reading

UAF seismologist Carl Tape, age 9, stands outside on his family’s Fairbanks deck at minus 50 degrees F on Jan. 23, 1989. “Carl was ahead of his time,” said Rick Thoman. “Now people pose in front of the UAF sign.” Photo courtesy Walt Tape
Fuzzy memories of a real Alaska cold snap

More than 35 years have ticked away since I turned my pickup… Continue reading

Larry Persily. (Juneau Empire file photo)
Opinion: Low oil prices a ‘bah humbug’ for state treasury

It’s the season of warm wishes, goodwill, families and friends. It’s a… Continue reading

Seismologist Carl Tape stands at the site of Dome City in summer 2025. Dome City ghosted out many years ago, but not before miners unearthed many fossils, some of which they donated to the University of Alaska. Photo courtesy Ned Rozell
A whale of a mammoth tale

Matthew Wooller couldn’t believe his ears after a California researcher rang his… Continue reading

A vintage Underwood typewriter sits on a table on Tuesday, Feb. 22, 2022, at the Homer News in Homer, Alaska. (Photo by Michael Armstrong/Homer News)
Letters to the editor

Soldotna needs better funding for all student sports An issue that has… Continue reading