What others say: NCAA goes overboard with punishment

  • Sunday, November 9, 2014 6:05pm
  • Opinion

Fans of Alaska Nanooks athletics got the equivalent of a body-check into the boards by the National Collegiate Athletic Association on Wednesday. The governing body for college sports handed the UAF athletics department a host of severe sanctions, including the loss of scholarships, a $30,000 fine, bans on postseason play this year for hockey, swimming and men’s and women’s basketball, as well as the vacating of all basketball and hockey wins in which ineligible athletes played between 2007-2008 and 2011-2012.

Remember the Nanooks wins against the University of Alaska Anchorage Seawolves in the Governor’s Cup in 2010, 2011 and 2012 that started the streak now five years long? Do your best to forget them, because — officially, at least — they never took place. Remember the hockey team’s first-ever NCAA tournament berth in 2010? That’s gone, too.

According to the NCAA and UAF officials, the sanctions stem from widespread issues in academic advising in which student athletes weren’t informed about NCAA academic requirements and were improperly certified to compete. Advisers were reportedly untrained on differences between UAF academic requirements and those for NCAA athletes. Also, an NCAA release states, UAF didn’t take appropriate action to correct the problem despite internal warnings that its certification system might be deficient.

Clearly, UAF and its staff made serious mistakes both in training academic advisers for athletes and in not acting immediately to fix potential issues when flags were raised. The university, however, did self-report the violations, enacted self-imposed sanctions prior to the NCAA’s and says it has taken appropriate action to reform the advising process to prevent future issues of the same nature. It makes sense the school should face strong sanctions for its missteps.

What doesn’t make sense, however, is for the weight of those sanctions to be so out of proportion to the offenses committed. The sanctions leveled against UAF — vacating records for a multi-year period and the loss of a handful of scholarships, among other things — is strikingly reminiscent of those that hit the University of Minnesota’s basketball team over an academic cheating scandal that took place over five years in the late 1990s. In that instance, a counseling manager for the team had completed more than 400 homework assignments for team members to ensure their eligibility, and instructors were coerced into changing deadlines and grades for team members. The news broke one day before the start of the NCAA basketball tournament in 1999. The university didn’t self-report, and the offenses committed by their staff and athletes were both willful and egregious.

At UAF, the problems were self-reported, self-sanctioning already had taken place and reforms had been made to ensure future compliance. The NCAA ignored these good-faith attempts to rectify the situation and slapped the university’s programs with the metaphorical equivalent of a game disqualification where a two-minute minor penalty would have been appropriate.

The damage inflicted by the disqualification of hockey, basketball and swimming squads from the postseason this year won’t be borne by the advisers who erred in improperly certifying athletes for competition, the UAF staff members who were supposed to train them on NCAA practices, or the college’s then-athletics director — himself a former compliance officer — who oversaw the programs at the time. That damage will be done to student athletes at UAF who had no part in the affair, and who are bearing the punishment for the missteps of others.

UAF’s athletics violations were serious, and the vacating of wins in which ineligible students took part makes sense. The $30,000 fine to UAF makes sense. The mandatory changes to advising to ensure future compliance make sense. The school’s probation through 2017 makes sense.

What doesn’t make sense are the outsized additional penalties impacting current student athletes who had nothing to do with past issues. Put simply, the punishment doesn’t fit the offense.

— Fairbanks Daily News-Miner,

Nov. 6

More in Opinion

Baisden family dog, Tug, is photographed in this undated photo. (Photo courtesy Rhonda Baisden)
Opinion: Ode to a good boy

The reality of saying goodbye hit us like a freight train

Alex Koplin. (courtesy photo)
Opinion: Why we’re not ranking Vance on the ballot

We will rank the other two candidates

Kenai Courthouse is photographed on Feb. 26, 2019, in Kenai, Alaska. (Clarion file)
Opinion: Seeking justice for our son

These state troopers need to be held accountable for their actions, and never let this happen again

This November 2022 file photos shows Alaska Division of Elections Director Gail Fenumiai explaining the ranked choice tabulation for the 2022 U.S. House race. Democratic incumbent Mary Peltola prevailed over Republican former Gov. Sarah Palin by a final tally of 54.9% to 45.1% after lower-finishing candidates Republican Nick Begich III amd Libertarian Chris Bye were eliminated during the first two rounds of instant choice runoffs. (Mark Sabbatini/Juneau Empire file)
Opinion: Ranked choice voting and open primaries diminish political party control. That’s great for Alaska.

The fact that both private political organizations are opposed to open primaries and RCV should be a red flag for us all

Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire file photo
U.S. Sen. Lisa Murkowski talks to supporters during a campaign event at Louie’s Douglas Inn on Oct. 12, 2022.
Opinion: Murkowski must get off the ‘none of the above’ fence

She needs to follow Cheney’s lead and endorse Harris

Voting booths are set up at the Soldotna Regional Sports Complex on Tuesday, Oct. 4, 2022, in Soldotna, Alaska. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
A few votes can make all the difference

Because we are expecting a low voter turnout, your vote carries more weight

Sen. Jesse Bjorkman, R-Nikiski, speaks during a debate with Rep. Ben Carpenter organized by the District 8 Alaska Republican Party at the Soldotna Regional Sports Complex in Soldotna, Alaska, on Monday, Aug. 12, 2024. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
Opinion: Legislation encourages professional development for teachers

This bill provides incentives to teachers to seek the most rigorous and effective professional development they can.

Alex Koplin. Photo courtesy of Alex Koplin.
Point of View: The 2020 election was safe and secure

How can so many voters be so misinformed?

The Kenai Safeway is seen on Wednesday, July 20, 2022. (Camille Botello/Peninsula Clarion)
Opinion: AG’s silence on Kroger-Albertsons merger is failing Alaskans

We are concerned for all Alaskan consumers and for Alaska’s food security.

AKPIRG logo. Photo courtesy of AKPIRG
Opinion: With the right regulations, the SAVE Act can unlock energy prosperity in Alaska

Since 2010, only homeowners have been able to invest in and earn monthly bill savings from rooftop solar

The Safeway supermarket in Juneau, seen here Oct. 4, 2023, is among those in Alaska scheduled to be sold if its parent company, Albertsons Companies Inc., merges with Kroger Co., the parent company of Fred Meyer. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire file photo)
Opinion: Alaska’s attorney general flunks math test

One supermarket owner is less competitive than two, and more competition is good for shoppers

Jenny Carroll (Courtesy)
Opinion: Homer Harbor plays critical role in community, economy

This gateway to Cook Inlet fuels everything from recreation and food security to commercial enterprises