What others say: Commissioner justified in defense of predator management

  • Tuesday, November 1, 2016 4:17pm
  • Opinion

In an ongoing battle about game management in Alaska, Department of Fish and Game Commissioner Sam Cotten made the right move in standing by the state’s existing system of predator control. Although the philosophical argument about how best to manage game in the state likely will go on for decades and changes may well be made in that time, the case for major changes to state management is not compelling at this juncture.

Alaskans who are invested in game management are not all of similar mind on whether the state’s current intensive management plan is the best way to maintain wildlife stocks and preserve diversity. Many of those opposed to current management practices wrote as much in a letter seeking the end to some aspects of wolf control on state lands and the establishment of an independent council that would review the practices of intensive management and their efficacy.

Chief among the suggestions the letter made that Commissioner Cotten declined to implement was the establishment of a 5-mile zone around federal lands where game management rules are different. Given the differences in management schemes on federal and state lands, there have been management conflicts at the borders between units. But an expansion of federal management authority five miles from the existing border of federal lands would greatly curtail the state’s ability to manage game on its own lands. As Commissioner Cotten pointed out in his response earlier this month, federal lands already make up more than 60 percent of Alaska’s land area. Pushing out those federal borders 5 miles in all directions for the purposes of game management would be a massive cession of authority to federal practices.

And while the state should continue to look at its management practices and their effects to ensure Alaska is doing its job providing for healthy wildlife populations, the notion that a body reviewing intensive management shouldn’t contain state biologists is problematic. Scientists from the Department of Fish and Game are some of the best-informed authorities on Alaska game issues; to suggest they couldn’t take part in a reasoned discussion of game management practices is similar to suggesting that current teachers shouldn’t be allowed to take part in a review of Alaska’s education system.

Commissioner Cotten was also right to be doubtful of wolf sterilization and relocation as a compromise between current techniques and an end to intensive management. Utilized during Gov. Tony Knowles’ administration, the practice was expensive and accomplished the same ultimate end as shooting the wolves would have. Moving wolves or sterilizing them may soothe our conscience by avoiding the direct killing of an apex predator, but if the end result is the same, all we’ve done is spend more money to kill a wolf. We shouldn’t pretend we’re being kinder by adopting different methods.

Intensive management of predators to maintain stable game populations isn’t always pretty, but it has been effective and has provided for a sustainable harvest of the large game for which Alaska is known. Commissioner Cotten is justified in standing by it.

— Fairbanks Daily News-Miner, Oct. 31

More in Opinion

A resident casts their vote in the regular municipal election Tuesday, Oct. 6, 2020 at the Kenai Peninsula Fairgrounds in Ninilchik, Alaska. (Photo by Megan Pacer/Homer News)
Voices of the Peninsula: All votes matter

In the beginning, only property-holding white men could vote.

Cristen San Roman. (Photo provided)
Point of View: Is management of Cook Inlet catered to special interest groups?

If these fish are so at risk, why is BOEM able to move forward with lease sale 258?

Homer Foundation
Point of View: Grateful for the hidden ‘good’

Gratitude: Noun The state of being grateful; thankfulness. The state or quality… Continue reading

Homer High School Principal Douglas Waclawski. (Photo provided)
Point of View: What is Homer High School about?

What I consider Homer High’s strength is that we are a place for learning.

UAA Chancellor Sean Parnell. (courtesy photo)
Alaska Voices: Invent your future at UAA

At UAA we’re providing the tools to help students of all ages and skills chart a new course forward.

A registered nurse prepares a COVID-19 vaccine at the pop-up clinic on the Spit on May 27. (Photo by Sarah Knapp/Homer News)
Alaska Voices: Vaccination is the still best protection from COVID-19

The Alaska State Medical Association encourages you to protect yourselves and your community from preventable illness by getting recommended vaccines.

(Ben Hohenstatt / Juneau Empire File)
The sad diminishment of Rep. Don Young

Young seems afraid to demand his party leader defend the dignity of the institution he loves.

A “Vote Here” sign is seen at the City of Kenai building on Monday, Sept. 21, 2020, in Kenai, Alaska. (Clarion file)
Alaska Voices: Restore our strong campaign donation limits

Without campaign spending limits, the ideal of one person, one vote is no longer really true.

The Final Redistricting Map approved for the Anchorage and Matanuska-Susitna area is seen on Nov. 9, 2021. (Map via akredistrict.org)
Alaska Voices: The Alaska Redistricting Board’s last-minute gerrymandering failed Alaska

Our Constitution outlines rules for a redistricting process designed to uphold public trust.

This photo shows the trans-Alaska pipeline and pump station north of Fairbanks. (AP Photo/Al Grillo)
Alaska Voices: The permanent fund has been taking care of Alaskans for 45 years

It’s the largest sovereign wealth fund in the nation, the pride of Alaska and this month we celebrate its 45th anniversary.

Dr. Tom Hennessy, MD, MPH (Courtesy)
Voices of the Peninsula: Don’t take medical advice from politicians, athletes or social media

Evidence leads to consensus among medical doctors: Vaccines are the best way to prevent infection.

The Entrance to the University of Alaska Southeast. (Michael Penn / Juneau Empire File)
Opinion: The University of Alaska is the state’s most important resource

Together, let’s break the record for donor participation.