Voices of Alaska: A ‘fix’ in search of a flaw

  • By Geoffrey Wildridge
  • Saturday, February 14, 2015 3:57pm
  • Opinion

Sen. Pete Kelly’s ongoing campaign to amend Alaska’s constitution to change the way we select and retain judges poses a grave threat to fair and impartial courts in our state. While couched as a mission to add a stronger public voice to the selection and retention process by diminishing the role of lawyers, his efforts would instead allow partisan politics to take hold of the one branch of government that is designed to remain as free from politics as possible. Doubling the number of politically appointed members on the Alaska Judicial Council and requiring legislative approval of lawyer members will undermine the fundamental promise of equal justice that Alaskans have a right to expect.

First, our constitution’s framers gave lawyers a prominent role in our merit-based judicial selection system for good reason. By law, judges must be lawyers, and are of necessity drawn from the legal community. It is common sense that lawyers can provide invaluable input on the professional competence of their peers seeking judgeships. Along with interviews, writing samples, public comments and other information, the council surveys lawyers on a candidate’s legal ability, temperament, integrity, diligence, and sense of fairness to ensure that judicial selection decisions are made with full awareness of a candidate’s potential to perform the great demands of the job. Lawyer members of the council represent the importance of merit and are key to ensuring the success of a merit-based system. Contrary to Kelly’s claims, the system has worked well for over half a century to bring Alaska one of the finest judiciaries in the world.

Second, the framers viewed any requirement for legislative confirmation of the lawyer members of the council as ill-advised because it would create another avenue for the influence of politics on the judicial branch. In the words of George McLaughlin, Chair of the Judiciary Committee at Alaska’s Constitutional Convention, “(i)f you require a confirmation of your attorney members you can promptly see what will happen … No longer is the question based solely on the qualification of the candidate for the bench … If political correctness enters into the determination of the selection of those professional members who are to be placed on the judicial council, the whole system goes out the window. All you have is one other political method of selection of your judges.”

Third, the suggestion that the public interest was undermined when the Chief Justice voted in agreement with lawyer members instead of public members in the five recent cases where the two groups were evenly divided ignores the record in each case. The duty of the council is to nominate to the governor a minimum of two of the most highly qualified candidates. In each of the circumstances where candidates received 3-3 ties, more than adequate numbers of other candidates received enough votes to be nominated. In two cases, there were four nominees that came out ahead of the 3-3 vote-getters; in two cases, there were three nominees. In one case, there were two nominees who each received five council votes out of six — both obviously viewed by the council as significantly more qualified than the 3-3 candidate. Suggesting that the Chief Justice should have exercised tie-breaking votes to add candidates on the margin to already sufficient pools of nominees that both lawyer and public members viewed as more highly qualified ignores the council’s responsibility to nominate only — in the words of one constitutional convention delegate — “the best available timber.”

Fourth, Sen. Kelly’s implication that the Chief Justice should refrain from breaking ties in the nominating process for vacancies on the Alaska Supreme Court ignores a responsibility that has been vested with the office since statehood, and which has served our state well. When a vacancy exists on our highest court, it is more imperative than ever that nominees meet the highest qualifications of the profession. When candidates receive three out of six votes in pools where others receive four, five, and even unanimous votes, it is difficult to argue that they are among the most qualified. Declining to forward their nominations is completely justifiable if we are to trust the overall integrity of our merit-selection process.

Alaska faces many critical problems at this time that demand our full attention. Alaska’s judicial selection system is not one of them. Sen. Kelly’s proposal is a fix in search of a flaw, and should fail.

Geoffry B. Wildridge is an attorney from Fairbanks and president of the Alaska Bar Association. The opinions expressed here are his own.

More in Opinion

The Alaska Capitol on Monday, Jan. 16, 2023, in Juneau, Alaska. (AP Photo/Becky Bohrer)
Alaska Voices: Legislature deserves credit

A special session shouldn’t have been necessary, but at least it was only one day instead of 30 days.

Alaska State Troopers logo.
Alaska Voices: Please be safe, courteous, and legal as you fish in Alaska this summer

As you head out to hit the water this year, here are a few tips to help you have a safe and citation free season

An observer makes an entry in the Fish Map App on Prince of Wales Island. (Photo by Lee House/courtesy Salmon State)
Alaska Voices: Document Alaska rivers with new fish map app

The app provides a way for everyday Alaskans to document rivers home to wild salmon, whitefish, eulachon and other ocean-going fish — and earn money doing it

(Peter Segall / Juneau Empire File)
Opinion: Sustainability report is a greenwashing effort

Report leaves out “the not-so-pretty.”

Pictured is an adult Chinook salmon swimming in Ship Creek, Anchorage. (Photo: U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service)
Voices of the Peninsula: Proactive measures key to king salmon recovery

I have been sport fishing king salmon along the eastern shores of Cook Inlet and in the Kenai River since 1977

U.S. Sen. Lisa Murkowski (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
Honoring the fallen on Memorial Day

As we honor the men and women who fell in service to our nation, we must keep their memories alive through their stories

Shana Loshbaugh (Courtesy photo)
History conference seeking input from peninsula people

The Alaska Historical Society will hold its annual conference on the central peninsula this fall

Coach Dan Gensel (left) prepares to get his ear pierced to celebrate Soldotna High School’s first team-sport state championship on Friday, Febr. 12, 1993 in Soldotna, Alaska. Gensel, who led the Soldotna High School girls basketball team to victory, had promised his team earlier in the season that he would get his ear pierced if they won the state title. (Rusty Swan/Peninsula Clarion)
Remembering my friend, Dan Gensel

It’s a friendship that’s both fixed in time and eternal

(Clarise Larson / Juneau Empire File)
Opinion: The false gods in America’s gun culture

HB 61 is a solution in search of a problem.

KPBSD Superintendent Clayton Holland
Reflecting on a year of growth and resilience

A message from the superintendent

Jim Cockrell, commissioner of the Department of Public Safety. (Courtesy photo/Office of Gov. Mike Dunleavy)
Honoring the 69 peace officers who have died serving Alaskans

Alaska Peace Officer Memorial Day honors the brave men and women who have given their lives in the line of duty

Rep. Maxine Dibert (Image via Alaska State Legislature)
Opinion: The economic case for a significant investment in education

As our oil production and related revenue have declined, our investments in education have remained flat