Kate Troll (Courtesy Photo / Kate Troll)

Kate Troll (Courtesy Photo / Kate Troll)

Opinion: Making tourism lemonade out of pandemic lemons

Can we make the most of a bad situation?

  • Saturday, March 20, 2021 12:48am
  • Opinion

By Kate Troll

It’s not often I agree with columnist Win Gruening. Not only do I concur with his assessment of the opportunity to increase independent visitors to Southeast, but I want to take it a step further. I believe Juneau can become the adventure mecca for small boat cruising and independent travelers. We can put a new mark on the growing (pre-pandemic) trend of so-called “geo-tourism.” Geo-tourists are visitors who are inclined to “seek culture and unique experiences when they travel,” according to the Bureau of Land Management.

As Gruening points out, it’s doubtful that any large cruise ship will be sailing to Juneau this summer, even if there is a congressional fix to allow large cruise ships to bypass a Canadian stop. The lack of large ships this summer provides an opportunity to switch focus and explore ways to maximize and document the economic impact of small boat visitors. Why would we want to do this? Because shoreside tourism-related businesses are hurting and small cruise vessel passengers spend far more money in port than the average cruise ship passenger.

Small cruise vessel passengers travel by air at least one way and in most cases both ways, requiring overnight stays in local hotels. These visitors have additional opportunity to dine in restaurants and frequent galleries and gift shops. According to a 2016 State Department of Commerce study, “Trends and Opportunities in Alaska’s Small Cruise Vessel Market,” approximately 20-25% of these passengers spend additional time in Alaska on a land tour.

To try to get a sense of the comparative spending between a small cruise vessel passenger and large ship passenger, I did not find any one definitive analysis. However, the 2016 state report cited above, did reference the accounting estimates provided by a small cruise operator. Looking at guest spending in shops, guest shoreside activities, lodging, dining and car rentals, one small boat operator estimated that each of his 700 guests spent $528 while docked in Juneau in 2015. By comparison, a 2016 report prepared for Travel Juneau by the McDowell Group, “Juneau Visitor Profile an Economic Impact Study,” found that the average large cruise ship passenger spent $162 while in Juneau. Accounting for the different reporting years and study approach, I would say it’s safe to say that a small cruise vessel passenger will likely spend three to four times as much as each large cruise ship passenger. This is a difference worth building on.

The same can be said for the independent traveler. The 2016 McDowell Study showed that independent travelers coming to Juneau only spend on average of $800 per trip.

Knowing that because of COVID-19 the number of independent travelers and small vessel sailings will be fewer than normal, the question Juneau needs to focus on is how can we maximize the impact of these visitors? With no competition from the large vessels are there more shoreside opportunities, such as whale watching, now available to these visitors? Can the visitor industry create more package opportunities, helicopter tours, etc., before and/or after the small vessel sailing? Can local artists and craft persons be given an onboard opportunity to show off their talent and wares? Can independent travelers access tours that previously had to be booked on the cruise ship? What can we learn from the summer of 2021 to better promote Juneau as North America’s No. 1 port for small vessel cruises?

It’s in exploring these types of questions where Juneau can make some tourism lemonade from the lemons that the pandemic has dealt to our visitor industry. It is in this regard that I suggest the Juneau Economic Development Council or Travel Juneau host a virtual geo-tourism forum wherein the operators of these small cruise vessels (in 2015 there were nine) could explore packages and promotions with Juneau’s many shoresidetour operators and business.

Kate Troll, former Juneau Assembly member, used to own a bed and breakfast and served as a naturalist for two years for Gastineau Guiding. Recently, she and her husband served as local host for four UnCruise sailings.Columns, My Turns and Letters to the Editor represent the view of the author, not the view of the Juneau Empire. Have something to say? Here’s how to submit a My Turn or letter.

More in Opinion

A role of "I Voted" stickers sit sanitizer. (Ben Hohenstatt / Juneau Empire File)
Opinion: There’s a problem election reform efforts are ignoring

Campaigns should be shorter. But they aren’t.

Nina Faust
Point of View: Celebrate Citizen Science Month with Crane Watch

April is Citizen Science Month, an opportunity for people to get involved… Continue reading

Opinion: How satellites may lead to broadband service for rural Alaska

Low Earth orbiting satellites may soon help Alaska to achieve a task force goal.

(Peter Segall / Juneau Empire File)
Opinion: An idea to limit length of legislative floor sessions

Here’s the plan to help move along the baseball games, I mean legislative work, at a faster pace.

Alex Koplin is a founding member of Kenai Peninsula Votes. (courtesy photo)
Voices of the Peninsula: Meet in the middle on voting reform

Wouldn’t it be great to have a voting bill that makes voting easier, more secure and one that all parties could possibly agree on?

Robert Archibald is president of the Prince William Sound Regional Citizens’ Advisory Council board of director and represents the city of Homer, where he has lived since 1984. (courtesy)
Alaska Voices: Walking the talk on responsible energy development

If you can recall the images of oiled otters and sea birds, of oil spreading from the Exxon Valdez, then you know what is at stake.

Ski tracks can be seen in the snow at Tsalteshi Trails near Soldotna, Alaska, on March 20, 2018. (Photo by Jeff Helminiak/Peninsula Clarion)
Voices of the Peninsula: Lessons learned on the downhill

If you are skiing and find conditions requiring creative nonstandard techniques to not end up in a snowbank, it’s probably time to revise your TTD list for the day.

Unless something changes at the federal level, Juneau’s waterfront may be devoid of cruise ships for another summer. (Michael S. Lockett / Juneau Empire)
Opinion: Why are there still no cruise ships?

Can You spell P-V-S-A-E-x-e-m-p-t-i-o-n?

Opinion: QAnon is the most successful April Fools’ joke I’ve ever seen

Like going down the rabbit hole into a dark, sinister version of “Alice in Wonderland,” once you’re in, that’s your reality.

Most Read