The Tongass National Forest sign seen en route to the Mendenhall Glacier Visitor Center on Wednesday, Aug. 28, 2019. (Michael Penn / Juneau Empire File)

The Tongass National Forest sign seen en route to the Mendenhall Glacier Visitor Center on Wednesday, Aug. 28, 2019. (Michael Penn / Juneau Empire File)

Opinion: It’s time to compromise on the Roadless Rule

The Roadless Rule has become a fight over which wild exaggeration of the facts will prevail.

  • Saturday, June 19, 2021 9:56pm
  • Opinion

By Rich Moniak

In October, the Trump administration issued a decision to fully exempt the Tongass National Forest from the Roadless Rule. Last week, the Biden Administration announced it’s considering whether to restore all or part of it. That prompted Sen. Lisa Murkowski to say it’s time “to end this yo-yo effect” which upends the lives of Southeast Alaskans “every time we have a new President.”

It’s an apt analogy. We’ve already gone from full implementation to full exception twice.

This would be an epic battle if the Roadless Rule restricted “tree harvest in more than half of the Tongass — about 9.4 million acres,” as reported by Alaska Public Media. But it’s really an argument over 1.8% of what the statement erroneously implies.

In Murkowski’s view, reimposing the Roadless Rule “will cost jobs, diminish income, keep energy prices high, and cripple the ability of the communities in the region to develop a sustainable, year-round economy.”

But what was remarkable about the Trump administration’s decision to exempt the Tongass is they didn’t increase the annual projected timber sale quantity of 46 million board feet. That objective was established by the 2016 Land and Resource Management Plan. The Forest Service signed off on it while the full Roadless Rule was in place.

The Trump administration also didn’t change the agency’s goal of transitioning to harvesting primarily young-growth forest.

What the exemption would provide is more old-growth acreage to choose from for future timber sales. According to the Environmental Impact Statement, that “could, in turn, improve the Forest Service’s ability to offer economic sales that meet the needs of industry.” And “communities influenced by the timber industry may experience minor beneficial effects resulting from flexibility for timber harvest.”

“Could” and “may” aren’t words associated with any kind of guarantee. And a “minor” addition to the 62 logging and sawmill jobs associated with Tongass timber harvest in 2018 falls far short of “rebuilding an entire industry, putting Alaskans back to work, and diversifying Alaska’s economy,” as Gov. Mike Dunleavy claimed the Trump administration’s decision would do.

Don’t go looking for job growth in the mining sector either. Because the EIS stated that exempting the Tongass from Roadless Rule wasn’t “expected to affect existing or future locatable mineral exploration or mining activities on the Forest.”

After the Biden administration changed course, Dunleavy tweeted he was “Disappointed in the latest suppression of AK economic opportunity” and divisively added “the federal government wishes to see Alaskans suffer at the lack of jobs and prosperity.”

The other side thinks Biden’s decision will save jobs. Sounding the familiar refrain of environmental advocacy groups, Austin Williams, the Alaska Legal and Policy Director for Trout Unlimited, called it “short-sighted” to exempt the Tongass from the Roadless Rule. “It’s long past time to end clear-cut logging of old-growth forest,” he argued, because it “damages important critical fish and wildlife habitat, costs taxpayers many millions of dollars, undercuts tourism and fishing jobs, and hampers our ability to fight climate change.”

But he began his press release claiming the Roadless Rule exemption made “more than nine million acres of backcountry lands in the nation’s largest national forest vulnerable to industrial clear-cut logging of old-growth forest.”

That’s propaganda, not the “science-backed policy muscle” Trout Unlimited says it brings to the cause on “behalf of trout and salmon fisheries, healthy waters and vibrant communities.”

The facts are the Tongass only contains 5 million acres of productive old-growth forests. The vast majority can’t be logged. They’re located in Admiralty Island and Misty Fjords National Monuments, 17 other wildernesses areas, and a dozen LUD II areas “managed in a roadless state to retain their wildland character.” Hundreds of miles of rivers and streams vital to the region’s wild salmon wind their way through these protected lands.

And as identified in the EIS, fully exempting the Tongass from Roadless Rule would only add 168,000 acres old growth timber to the 227,000 acres that are already available for future harvest.

I’m not dismissing the environmental risks associated with logging old growth in any part of the forest. But the Roadless Rule has become a fight over which wild exaggeration of the facts will prevail. Neither side should win. Which means it’s well past time they commit themselves to accepting a compromise.

Rich Moniak is a Juneau resident and retired civil engineer with more than 25 years of experience working in the public sector.

More in Opinion

Opinion: It’s time for bold action to protect our fisheries

Our fisheries feed the world and sustain our unique cultures and communities.

The logo for the Kenai Peninsula Borough School District is displayed inside the George A. Navarre Borough Admin Building on Thursday, July 22, 2021 in Soldotna, Alaska. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
Voices of the Peninsula: Hard to fill positions?

Paying poverty wages to support staff, secretaries and custodians is unacceptable yet routine behavior by our district

A copy of the State of Alaska Official Ballot for the June 11, 2022, Special Primary Election is photographed on May 2, 2022. (Peninsula Clarion staff)
Choosing a candidate – Who will best represent us in D.C.?

Voters are encouraged to do homework before casting a vote

Tourists watch as one of two cubs belonging to an 18-year-old sow black bear crosses the path between groups of tourists visiting the Mendenhall Glacier Visitor Center on Wednesday, July 18, 2018. (Michael Penn / Juneau Empire File)
Opinion: Tourists have pushed us to critical mass in parts of Juneau

I don’t go to the glacier in the summer now to hike or watch bears.

Sens. Shelley Hughes, R-Palmer, left, and Robert Myers, R-North Pole, read through one of 41 amendments submitted to the state’s omnibus budget bill being debate on the floor of the Alaska State Senate on Monday, May 9, 2022. (Peter Segall / Juneau Empire)
Opinion: The Alaska Senate’s foolish gamble

“All these conservative people just spent all our money”

Mobilizing for Action through Planning and Partnerships. (logo provided)
Point of View: A few ideas for Mental Health Awareness Month

What are some things you can practice this month and subsequently apply to your life?

Alex Koplin is a founding member of Kenai Peninsula Votes. (courtesy photo)
Voices of the Peninsula: 1 candidate dined, 47 to go

By Alex Koplin Last month, I wrote a satirical piece for the… Continue reading

Smoke from the Swan Lake Fire impairs visibility on the Sterling Highway on Aug. 20, 2019. (Photo by Victoria Petersen/Peninsula Clarion)
Opinion: Alaskans should prepare for wildfire season

Several past large fire seasons followed snowy winters or unusually rainy springs

Most Read