Opinion: In defense of free speech for all

Selective defense of free speech shreds vital connection to Equal Protection Clause.

  • By Rich Moniak
  • Monday, October 24, 2022 11:01pm
  • Opinion

By Rich Moniak

Last week, the Alaska Supreme Court heard the appeal of a case in which Gov. Mike Dunleavy purported to be defending the free speech rights of state employees. Much earlier, in two separate lawsuits filed in federal court, Dunleavy was found to have violated the free speech rights of three state employees.

The difference is these cases should serve as an instructive warning. The defense of free speech for my team but not for others is shredding its vital connection to the Constitution’s Equal Protection Clause.

In an Administrative Order issued in August 2019, Dunleavy directed new procedures be developed for state employees who opt-in to belong the public employee unions. They’d be required to sign a statement acknowledging they did so “freely and without any coercion whatsoever,” that they were waiving “their First Amendment right not to pay union dues and fees,” and that they were “freely associating” themselves with the “union’s speech activities.”

The case stems from the 2018 U.S. Supreme Court ruling in Janus v. AFSCME. It struck down state laws allowing public employee unions to collect “agency fees” from non-union members.

Dunleavy’s order was based on a legal opinion written at his request by Kevin Clarkson, the attorney general at the time. Quoting from a prior 9th Circuit Court ruling, Clarkson wrote that waiving one’s constitutional rights is only voluntary if “it was the product of a free and deliberate choice rather than coercion or improper inducement.”

It’s important here to note that public employee unions overwhelmingly support Democratic candidates and contribute little or nothing to the Republican Party. If it was the other way around, it’s unlikely that Dunleavy would have been at all concerned about making sure employees understood their constitutional rights regarding union dues and fees.

After state employee unions sued to block implementation of Dunleavy’s order, Anchorage Superior Court Gregory Miller ordered a temporary halt to its implementation. Last February, he ruled that the Dunleavy “breached the collective bargaining agreement” and “the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing” between the unions and the state. He also stated Dunleavy violated the constitutional separation of powers, the Public Employees Relation Act, and the Administrative Procedures Act.

How far Dunleavy will go to defend the rights of free speech and association for members of his team? He appealed even though the state’s own attorney acknowledges his position has been rejected by courts across the country.

Two psychiatrists and Juneau attorney Libby Bakalar got the opposite treatment from Dunleavy. They lost their jobs for not sharing his political views.

In a lawsuit filed by the psychiatrists at the Alaska Psychiatric Institute, U.S. District Judge John Sedwick ruled that the Dunleavy fired them for refusing “to endorse or pledge allegiance” to his political agenda.

Bakalar was an assistant attorney general in the Department of Law. Privately, she frequently expressed negative opinions about President Donald Trump in a self-published blog. According to an investigator hired by the state, her writing “can be interpreted to evince a liberal or progressive worldview.”

Sedwick determined Dunleavy lacked “adequate justification for treating [Bakalar] differently from other members of the general public.” And the firing violated her “free speech and associational rights under the federal and state constitutions.”

Dunleavy isn’t the only Alaska Republican taking a tribal approach to our First Amendment rights. Sen. Lora Reinbold, R-Eagle River, and Rep. Kevin McCabe, R-Big Lake, have been sued by people who they blocked from posting criticisms of them on their Facebook pages. The plaintiffs are relying on a unanimous appeals court ruling that then-President Donald Trump violated the First Amendment rights of Twitter users he blocked for being critical of him.

Intolerance of differing political views is certainly not confined to the political right. More than a few supposedly progressive institutions, particularly private and public universities, are plagued by an authoritarian desire to enforce their ever-changing lexicon of political correctness.

“The advancement and diffusion of knowledge is the only guardian of true liberty” James Madison argued two centuries ago. But a society structured around dueling echo chambers encourages neither the growth nor the spread of new ideas. Instead, it empowers an inbred cast of characters willing to defend liberty for only their like-minded followers.

Rich Moniak is a Juneau resident and retired civil engineer with more than 25 years of experience working in the public sector.

More in Opinion

Gov. Mike Dunleavy speaks in support of an agreement between the Alaska Department of Transportation and Public Facilities and Goldbelt Inc. to pursue engineering and design services to determine whether it’s feasible to build a new ferry terminal facility in Juneau at Cascade Point. (Clarise Larson / Juneau Empire File)
State, labor and utilities are aligned on modernizing the Railbelt grid

Today, Alaska has a once-in-a-generation opportunity to capture federal infrastructure dollars and… Continue reading

No to 67%

Recently, the Alaska State Officers Compensation Commission voted to raise the pay… Continue reading

This image available under the Creative Commons license shows the outline of the state of Alaska filled with the pattern of the state flag.
Opinion: Old models of development are not sustainable for Alaska

Sustainability means investing in keeping Alaska as healthy as possible.

Gov. Mike Dunleavy unveils proposals to offer public school teachers annual retention bonuses and enact policies restricting discussion of sex and gender in education during a news conference in Anchorage. (Screenshot)
Opinion: As a father and a grandfather, I believe the governor’s proposed laws are anti-family

Now, the discrimination sword is pointing to our gay and transgender friends and families.

Kenai Peninsula Education Association President Nathan Erfurth works in his office on Thursday, Oct. 28, 2021, in Soldotna, Alaska. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
Voices of the Peninsula: Now is the time to invest in Kenai Peninsula students

Parents, educators and community members addressed the potential budget cuts with a clear message.

Gov. Mike Dunleavy holds a press conference at the Capitol on Tuesday, April 9, 2019. (Juneau Empire file photo)
Opinion: An accurate portrayal of parental rights isn’t controversial

Affirming and defining parental rights is a matter of respect for the relationship between parent and child

Opinion: When the state values bigotry over the lives of queer kids

It has been a long, difficult week for queer and trans Alaskans like me.

Unsplash / Louis Velazquez
Opinion: Fish, family and freedom… from Big Oil

“Ultimate investment in the status quo” is not what I voted for.

Dr. Sarah Spencer. (Photo by Maureen Todd and courtesy of Dr. Sarah Spencer)
Voices of the Peninsula: Let’s bring opioid addiction treatment to the Alaskans who need it most

This incredibly effective and safe medication has the potential to dramatically increase access to treatment

An orphaned moose calf reared by the author is seen in 1970. (Stephen F. Stringham/courtesy photo)
Voices of the Peninsula: Maximizing moose productivity on the Kenai Peninsula

Maximum isn’t necessarily optimum, as cattle ranchers learned long ago.

(Ben Hohenstatt / Juneau Empire File)
Opinion: The time has come to stop Eastman’s willful and wanton damage

God in the Bible makes it clear that we are to care for the vulnerable among us.

Caribou graze on the greening tundra of the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge in northeast Alaska in June, 2001. (Michael Penn / Juneau Empire File)
Opinion: AIDEA’s $20 million-and-growing investment looks like a bad bet

Not producing in ANWR could probably generate a lot of money for Alaska.