Kenai gillnet plan denied; subsistence board rejects request to remove manager

  • Tuesday, July 28, 2015 10:23pm
  • News

The Kenai River subsistence gillnet won’t see the water this season, with the Federal Subsistence Board standing behind the federal in-season manager who has roused the ire of the Ninilchik Traditional Council by rejecting the group’s operational plan.

At a Tuesday meeting in Anchorage, the board upheld Kenai National Wildlife Refuge in-season manager Jeff Anderson’s decision to deny the operational plan that was a requirement for the Ninilchik Traditional Council to put its subsistence gillnet in the water, and kept him as the manager of the fishery despite the council’s request to remove him.

In a tie vote, a request failed to rescind Anderson’s emergency order that closed subsistence chinook harvest in the federal waters of the Kenai River.

Ninilchik Tribal elder and Council President Greg Encelewski spared no venom describing how the council feels about Anderson’s management of the Kenai River gillnet.

“It’s absolutely ludicrous,” said Encelewski. “It’s shameful and we’re disgusted.”

The Ninilchik Traditional Council had submitted two requests on July 17 and July 21 asking the federal board to rescind the orders of U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service closing chinook subsistence fishing, remove Cook Inlet area subsistence fishing from the federal in-season manager’s authority, and rewrite the language in the original proposal that requires the approval of operational plans by the in-season manager.

The board voted on the first two and requested to review the language revision, a regulatory affair, later.

Anderson had reviewed and approved an operational plan for the Kasilof River sockeye gillnet on July 13, but did not approve the operational plan submitted for the gillnet on the Kenai River.

The board made the controversial vote Jan. 21 to add a subsistence gillnet for the Ninilchik Traditional Council along federal segments of the Kenai and Kasilof rivers in pursuit of sockeye salmon.

State and federal biologists recommended against the measure on conservation concerns for the chinook salmon and trout that will inevitably be caught in the non-selective gear type.

Both gillnets required that Anderson approve an operational plan before use.

The Kenai measure narrowly passed with a 5-3 vote; board members from the Bureau of Land Management, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, and U.S. Forest Service opposed the motion on conservation grounds.

Anderson, describing his reluctance to approve the Kenai plan, voiced the same conservation concerns.

Anderson’s approval of the Kasilof net drew questions from board members who wondered why a similar plan couldn’t be approved for the Kenai gillnet. Why not try it, some asked, and reserve the right to cancel it at the slightest trigger.

“Wouldn’t you be willing to run a temporary one, like you did on the Kasilof?” asked National Parks Service board representative Bert Frost. “Is there a tolerable level (of incidental catch)?”

“The difference between tolerable and legal isn’t mine to make,” said Anderson. “Am I negligent in my position as manager to allow the harvest of non-legal species with a high likelihood of mortality?”

Ninilchik Traditional Council Executive Director Ivan Encelewski maintains that USFWS, through Anderson, is defying the federal board’s allowance for a gillnet by denying the operational plan.

Conservation concerns, he said, are beside the point; the federal board made the ruling and its up to Anderson to help implement it, not hamstring it over the same issues as before.

“There’s this thing called rule of law,” said Encelewski to the board by teleconference. “The Federal Subsistence Board made the law. The USFWS is on record vetoing and usurping that authority. They’re saying they’re never going to issue a permit or an operational plan.”

Encelewski firmly denies any conservation necessity for king salmon on the Kenai River.

He cited the relative health of this season’s late run kings, recently opened to bait fishing and dipnet retention in state waters and projected to meet minimum escapement, as proof, as well the low level of non-legal species caught on the Kasilof gillnet up to this point.

The board, however, felt that it has no alternative than defer to the authority of the federal manager.

“I’m not in a position right now to rescind somebody’s authority,” said the board’s rural representative, Hydaburg Mayor Tony Christiansen. “I wish we were in a better position to help Ninilchik get some fish.”

On the subject of Anderson’s authority, the rest of the board agreed. The motion to rescind his authority of Cook Inlet subsistence fisheries was rejected unanimously.

A motion to rescind the federal closure of chinook subsistence fishing failed on a 4-4 vote.

In the end, the board voted 7-1 in favor of a motion to “direct the USFWS to work on an operational plan on the Kenai River.” The action reset the Kenai gillnet to its previous state: possible, but not yet approved.

Contact DJ Summers at or follow him on Twitter @djsummersmma.

More in News

Signs are placed on Lowell Point Road ahead of the road opening in Seward, Alaska, May 27, 2022, following the May 7 Bear Mountain landslide. (Photo and caption courtesy Kenai Peninsula Borough)
Lowell Point Road reopens after landslide

Locals have relied on water taxi service since the May 7 slide

Heather Renner and Tasha Reynolds run and fat bike to the finish line on the Kenai Beach during the 2019 Mouth to Mouth Wild Run & Ride. (Photo courtesy Kaitlin Vadla)
Mouth to Mouth bike race and run returns Monday

The race starts at the mouth of the Kasilof River and ends at the mouth of Kenai River

Demonstrators rally in support of Kenai Peninsula Borough School District teachers and staff outside of the George A. Navarre Admin Building on Thursday, May 26, 2022 in Soldotna, Alaska. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
‘Overworked and underpaid’

Rally calls for support for KPBSD staff, teachers

Mount Redoubt volcano can be seen across Cook Inlet from the shores of South Kenai Beach, in Kenai, Alaska, on April 10, 2022. (Photo by Erin Thompson/Peninsula Clarion)
Cook Inlet basin energy future lies beyond fossil fuels, conference speakers say

The region that was once famous for oil is teeming with renewables like wind, solar, geothermal and tidal energy

Tony Izzo, CEO of Matansuka Electric Association, stands with other utility executives on May 25 to describe a $200 million project to upgrade transmission lines along Alaska’s Railbelt. The announcement was made at the Alaska Sustainable Energy Conference in Anchorage. Curtis Thayer, executive director of the Alaska Energy Authority, is at the far left; Gov. Mike Dunleavy is at the far right. (Photo by Yereth Rosen/Alaska Beacon)
Utilities in Alaska’s Railbelt announce $200M transmission upgrade project

The upgrade will move more energy from the Bradley Lake Hydroelectric Plant on the Kenai Peninsula

Silver salmon swim in Sucker Creek on Sept. 18, 2020. (Photo by Matt Bowser/Kenai National Wildlife Refuge)
Project to study effect of climate change on salmon streams

The organization will partner with the United States Geological Survey

Wood is piled near the entrance to Centennial Park on Thursday, May 26, 2022, in Soldotna, Alaska. The campground was closed for most of May while the city worked with contractors to remove trees infested with spruce bark beetles from the property. Southcentral Alaska’s current spruce beetle outbreak has already affected 1.6 million acres of land, including 21,000 acres managed by the Kenai Peninsula Borough. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
Soldotna beetle-kill efforts boosted by $150K grant

The city has focused recent mitigation efforts on city campgrounds

A spruce bark beetle is seen on the underside of a piece of bark taken from logs stacked near Central Peninsula Landfill on Thursday, July 1, 2021, near Soldotna, Alaska. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
Emergency harvest of beetle-killed spruce trees approved

The move comes amid an infestation that has spread across Southcentral Alaska

This May 4, 2022, photo shows oceanographers Andrew McDonnell, left, and Claudine Hauri, middle, along with engineer Joran Kemme after an underwater glider was pulled aboard the University of Alaska Fairbanks research vessel Nanuq from the Gulf of Alaska. The glider was fitted with special sensors to study ocean acidification. (AP Photo/Mark Thiessen)
An ocean first: Underwater drone tracks CO2 in Alaska gulf

The autonomous vehicle was deployed in the Gulf of Alaska

Most Read