Lin Davis, of Juneau, Alaska, shown wearing an orange rain coat, holds signs supporting gay marriage during a news conference Friday, Oct. 10, 2014, outside the federal courthouse in Anchorage, Alaska. A federal judge on Friday heard arguments from five gay couples seeking to overturn the state's ban on gay marriage. (AP Photo/Mark Thiessen)

Lin Davis, of Juneau, Alaska, shown wearing an orange rain coat, holds signs supporting gay marriage during a news conference Friday, Oct. 10, 2014, outside the federal courthouse in Anchorage, Alaska. A federal judge on Friday heard arguments from five gay couples seeking to overturn the state's ban on gay marriage. (AP Photo/Mark Thiessen)

Judge considers fate of Alaska gay marriage ban

  • By Mark Thiessen
  • Saturday, October 11, 2014 8:56pm
  • News

ANCHORAGE, Alaska — A federal judge in Alaska promised a quick decision after hearing arguments Friday to overturn the first-in-the-nation ban on gay marriages.

Five gay couples sued the state to strike down the constitutional amendment approved by voters in 1998 that defined marriage as being between one man and one woman. They say it violates their U.S. constitutional guarantee of due process and equal protection.

Arguments for the plaintiffs were bolstered Monday when the U.S. Supreme Court refused to intervene in the issue, making gay marriage legal in a number of states.

The 9th Circuit Court of Appeals, to which Alaska belongs, the following day struck down similar bans in Idaho and Nevada. Each side in the Alaska case was given 30 minutes to present its case. The lead attorney for the plaintiffs, Allison Mendel, said she anticipated using only a little bit of that time and would save the remainder for rebuttal.

“Are you anticipating the landscape is going to change while we’re talking?” joked U.S. District Court Judge Timothy Burgess.

“I wouldn’t be surprised,” she responded.

Mendel said the 9th Circuit’s decision in the Nevada case set the precedent on equal protection within the circuit. The Nevada decision, she said, “is controlling on this court in every respect.”

She added of the state’s ban on gay marriage: “I think you can reach no other conclusion this is impermissible discrimination under the equal protection clause.”

Assistant Alaska Attorney General Bill Milks argued the ban was put in place by voters and the Legislature, and the state has every intention of defending the ban.

“The state of Alaska’s position is that this is a law that was democratically passed by voters and the Legislature,” he said. “We don’t think there is a fundamental right to same-sex marriage.”

But under direct questioning from Burgess, Milks acknowledged that it appeared the Nevada decision rules this case. All but acknowledging the state would not win the case, Milks twice urged Burgess to issue a stay if the decision is, indeed, for the plaintiffs. He cited uncertainty and legal confusion in rulings from other states, including gay couples who were allowed to marry in Utah before the decision was ultimately put on hold. The Supreme Court’s refusal to step in on Monday allowed gay marriages to begin once again in Utah.

Milks said the “importance of having a measured, orderly process” supported a stay.

The state had pinned its hope on Idaho’s appeal of the 9th Circuit decision.

But Mendel informed the court that the U.S. Supreme Court lifted its stay on gay marriages in Idaho while the Alaska case was being heard, drawing a round of applause in the courtroom. So many people wanted to watch the proceedings that another courtroom with a live video feed was set up for those who couldn’t get seats at the federal courthouse in Anchorage. The hearing was also simulcast live to federal courthouses in Juneau and Fairbanks.

“We love Alaska, and we’re not leaving. It’s only fair that our marriage is recognized,” said Susan Tow, who is a plaintiff along with her partner Christina LaBorde.

Other plaintiffs Matthew Hamby and Christopher Shelden, who were married six years ago, also spoke during a news conference after the hearing.

“We’re really looking forward to going to a bunch of friends’ same-sex weddings here in our home state in short order,” Hamby said.

Shelden said being able to marry was something he could never conceive of while growing up. The last few years have “been a wonderful ride for all of us,” he said before kissing Hamby.

More in News

Raymond Bradbury preserves his salmon while dipnetting in the mouth of the Kenai River on Saturday, July 10, 2021. (Camille Botello / Peninsula Clarion)
Kenai River dipnetting closed; Kasilof to close Sunday

The Kasilof River dipnet fishery is reportedly slow, but fish are being caught

Silver salmon hang in the Seward Boat Harbor during the 2018 Seward Silver Salmon Derby. (Photo courtesy of Seward Chamber of Commerce)
Seward Silver Salmon derby runs Aug. 13-21

Last year’s derby featured 1,800 contestants competing across eight days

Rayna Reynolds tends to her cow at the 4-H Agriculture Expo in Soldotna, Alaska on Aug. 5, 2022. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
Animals take the stage at 4-H expo

Contestants were judged on the quality of the animal or showmanship of the handler

Emily Matthews and Andy Kowalczyk pose outside the Center for Alaskan Coastal Studies headquarters on Friday, July 29, 2022, in Homer, Alaska. (Photo by Charlie Menke/Homer News)
AmeriCorps volunteers aid Center for Alaskan Coastal Studies

The 10-month commitment pushed them outside of comfort zones

People gather in Ninilchik, Alaska, on Friday, Aug. 5, 2022, for Salmonfest, an annual event that raises awareness about salmon-related causes. (Camille Botello/Peninsula Clarion)
All about the salmon

Fish, love and music return to Ninilchik

Alaska State Veterinarian Dr. Bob Gerlach gives a presentation on Avian Influenza Virus at the 4-H Agriculture Expo in Soldotna, Alaska, on Aug. 5, 2022. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
State looks to outreach, education amid bird flu outbreak

Highly Pathogenic Avian Influenza is spreading in Alaska

Fencing surrounds the 4th Avenue Theatre in Anchorage, Alaska, on Wednesday, Aug. 3, 2022. Demolition will begin in August 2022 on the once-opulent downtown Anchorage movie theater designed by the architect of Hollywood’s famed Pantages Theatre. The 4th Avenue Theatre with nearly 1,000 seats opened in 1947, and it withstood the second most powerful earthquake ever recorded. (AP Photo/Mark Thiessen)
Efforts fail to save historic Anchorage theater from demolition

Anchorage entrepreneur Austin “Cap” Lathrop opened the 4th Avenue Theatre, with nearly 1,000 seats, on May 31, 1947

Mimi Israelah, center, cheers for Donald Trump inside the Alaska Airlines Center in Anchorage, Alaska, during a rally Saturday July 9, 2022. Two Anchorage police officers violated department policy during a traffic stop last month when Israelah, in town for a rally by former President Donald Trump showed a “white privilege card” instead of a driver’s license and was not ticketed. (Bill Roth/Anchorage Daily News via AP, File)
Alaska officers violated policy in ‘white privilege’ stop

The top of the novelty card reads: “White Privilege Card Trumps Everything.”

Ashlyn O’Hara / Peninsula Clarion file 
Alaska LNG Project Manager Brad Chastain presents information about the project during a luncheon at the Kenai Chamber Commerce and Visitor Center on July 6.
Local leaders voice support for LNG project

Local municipalities are making their support for the Alaska LNG Project known

Most Read