A message opposing annexation is visible on an electronic sign at Lucky Raven Tobacco, located inside one of the proposed areas for annexation, on Thursday, Sept. 5, 2019, near Soldotna, Alaska. (Photo by Victoria Petersen/Peninsula Clarion)

A message opposing annexation is visible on an electronic sign at Lucky Raven Tobacco, located inside one of the proposed areas for annexation, on Thursday, Sept. 5, 2019, near Soldotna, Alaska. (Photo by Victoria Petersen/Peninsula Clarion)

Boundary Commission sends Soldotna annexation decision to voters

Fewer than 40 people could potentially make a decision on the petition.

Alaska’s Local Boundary Decision voted Thursday to amend the City of Soldotna’s annexation petition from legislative review to local option, meaning that residents of Soldotna and the proposed territory for annexation will now have the final say on whether the annexation goes through.

The LBC’s decisional meeting lasted just over three hours on Thursday and ended with a 3-2 vote in favor of amending the petition, and a 3-2 vote to approve the petition as amended.

Commissioners Lance Roberts, Kenneth Gallahorn and Clayton Trotter voted in favor of amending the petition and in favor of approving the petition as amended. Roberts was the commissioner who initially introduced the amendment at the first decisional meeting on Aug. 5.

Commissioners Larry Wood and John Harrington voted against the amendment and against the amended petition.

Jedidiah Smith, staff member for the Local Boundary Commission, told the Clarion after the meeting that this is the first time the Local Boundary Commission has voted to change an annexation petition from legislative review to local option. Legislative review means that the State Legislature reviews and votes on any annexation proposals during regular session approved and submitted by the LBC. Local option means that the decision is put onto a ballot for residents of the petitioning municipality — in this case, the City of Soldotna — and the residents of the area that would be annexed.

Smith did point to an inverse situation in the LBC’s history, where the commission converted a petition by the City of Dillingham from local option to legislative review after a local Superior Court judge determined that there were not enough registered voters in the areas of Nushagak Bay to warrant a vote by local option.

The City of Soldotna as well as Wood and Harrington made similar arguments against converting this petition to local option. In a letter to the LBC submitted after Roberts introduced the motion to amend the petition, City Manager Stephanie Queen argued that there are an estimated 140 registered voters in the areas proposed for annexation, and several of the “study areas” included in the annexation are unpopulated. Queen was not immediately available for comment following Thursday’s meeting.

Wood said during Thursday’s meeting that, assuming a 20% turnout for this election, fewer than 40 people could potentially make a decision that Wood argued should be made on the state level, as with previous annexation decisions.

Wood and Harrington also stated that the LBC has never converted a petition in this way and warned against the precedent it would set for future annexation decisions.

“It’s not balancing to let 140 voters make the decision on behalf of thousands of Soldotna residents,” Wood said. “The legislative review process is meant to prevent small, self-interested groups from stopping decisions that would benefit the state as a whole.”

Roberts and Gallahorn argued that the ability for the LBC to convert a petition to local option is enshrined in the constitution, and that there was a first time for everything.

“It’s a tool we can use,” Gallahorn said. “‘Because it’s never been done’ is not a good enough excuse to vote against (the local option). And in my personal opinion, respecting the will of the people by putting it to a vote is a huge benefit to the state.”

Smith is drafting the final written decision based on Thursday’s vote, which the LBC will vote to approve on Nov. 25. Harrington is writing the dissenting opinion. Following the meeting on Nov. 25, the City of Soldotna will have 18 days to file a motion for the LBC to reconsider the petition, Smith said. The City of Soldotna will also be responsible for holding two elections for the petition: One for Soldotna residents and one for residents of the area proposed for annexation. A majority of voters in both elections must approve the petition in order for it to pass.

Reach reporter Brian Mazurek at bmazurek@peninsulaclarion.com.

More in News

EPA logo
Alaska Native group to receive EPA funds for clean water projects

The agency is handing out $4.3 million to participating tribal organizations nationwide.

COVID-19. (Image courtesy CDC)
State reports 6 new COVID deaths

The deaths, which included a Kenai woman in her 40s, pushed the total to 840 since the pandemic began.

Ryanna Thurman (right) speaks to a library employee at the Soldotna Public Library on Thursday, March 25 in Soldotna, Alaska. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
Soldotna library seeks OK for grant fund purchases

The funds are made available under the federal American Rescue Plan Act

Alaska State Troopers logo.
Kenai man killed in vehicle rollover

The man was travelling northbound on the Sterling Highway on Tuesday.

Cheryl Morse and Tom Kleeman prepare Thanksgiving lunch at the Kenai Peninsula Food Bank on Wednesday, Nov. 24, 2021. (Camille Botello/Peninsula Clarion)
Food bank opens doors for Thanksgiving lunch

“We don’t know what to expect, so we’re trying to still be cautious on our limited seating.”

Carter Kyle (left), Lincoln Kyle (center) and Brandon Kyle (right) hand off Thanksgiving meals at a drive through event hosted by the Salvation Army on Thursday, Nov. 25, 2021 in Kenai, Alaska. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
Thanksgiving on the go

Salvation Army hands out meals in drive-thru event

Bench creator, Brad Hughes, pours the molding material over the clay while Rob Wiard and Matt brush the liquid rubber over each character on the bench to ensure it is covered evenly. (Photo by Sarah Knapp/Homer News)
Molds for the Loved Lost Bench are underway

Construction for the memorial bench continues as the rubber molds to shape the concrete are made.

Alaska Rep. David Eastman sits at his desk on the Alaska House floor in Juneau, Alaska, on March 5, 2020. Dozens of West Point graduates have demanded state Rep. Eastman resign from office over his ties to a right wing extremist group, saying his affiliation has betrayed the values of the U.S. Military Academy he attended. (AP Photo/Becky Bohrer, File)
70 West Point grads call on Alaska lawmaker to resign

Fellow West Point graduates called on Eastman to resign after his membership in the Oath Keepers became public.

Most Read