Bill would authorize individuals to get fish enhancement permits

Individual Alaskans, private companies and nonprofits could jump into the world of incubating and releasing salmon under a bill being discussed in the Legislature.

House Bill 107, sponsored by Rep. Dave Talerico (R-Fairbanks) and Rep. Mike Chenault (R-Nikiski) would create a system allowing qualified individuals to apply for a fisheries enhancement permit through the Alaska Department of Fish and Game. Under the permit, people could take wild salmon eggs deposited in a stream, incubate them and release the hatched fry into the same water from which they were taken for the primary purpose of increasing fish populations.

The proposed permit structure is very similar to existing permits, but it opens up the process to individuals who wouldn’t be using them strictly for education or scientific purposes, Talerico said during a House Resources Committee hearing Wednesday.

“This bill would clean things up by outlining those permit requirements in statute, and for the purposes of rehabilitation,” he said. “… This creates the ability for us to do this as a collaborative effort with the private sector and nonprofits out there, completely under the department’s direction, but having participation from the others out there to actually do this.”

Talerico’s district, which encircles Fairbanks to the north and includes Cantwell, Arctic Village and Tok, includes a number of communities that have traditionally subsistence fished for king salmon along the Tanana and Yukon rivers. In the last decade, fishing has been restricted multiple times because of low king salmon returns on the Yukon.

The goal would be to get private organizations’ money into fish restoration efforts, said Elijah Verhagen, one of Talerico’s staff members, during the committee meeting.

“With the science and education permits, such entities would have to apply and get one of these permits and do it under the premise of science or education, whereas this bill is allowing them to get a permit because they need more fish,” he said. “… The hope of this bill is we want the private sector to collaborate under the oversight of Fish and Game to use their private dollars to boost the fish population.”

Talerico tried to get a similar bill, HB 220, through the Legislature last year, but it received heavy opposition because of concerns about impacts to wild stocks and the potential for invasive species. Opponents labeled it “bucket biology,” referring to the practice of introducing fish to a lake without any consideration of the impact of invasive species on an ecosystem. Improper species introduction has led to the widespread presence of invasive northern pike in the Matanuska-Susitna Valley, which prey on salmonids.

Fish and Game had a hand in crafting HB 107, and it is a rigorous application process, Verhagen said. Applicants would have to provide documentation of a need, historical data, current conditions, goals and assessment plans, and would have to report data to Fish and Game, he said. It would still ultimately be up to Fish and Game to decide whether to issue a permit, and each would have to be signed by the commissioner.

“I’ve been working on this all session and I have a pretty good idea of how do this, I think, now, and yet I still would probably be rejected if I turned in an application,” Verhagen said.

Several groups voiced support for the bill, including Tanana Chiefs Conference, a coalition of Alaska Native tribal leaders. The group supported the previous bill that Talerico sponsored and already has a number of fisheries projects around the Interior drainages. HB 107 would provide a permit structure for Tanana Chiefs Conference to do their work without having to apply for multiple permits, said Will Mayo, executive director of tribal government and client services for Tanana Chiefs Conference.

“The existing permits would not work,” he said. “We could not use them for the purpose we wanted.”

Other groups raised concerns about wild stocks. Nancy Hillstrand of Pioneer Alaska Fisheries in Kodiak said she opposed the bill, saying that if fish were not making it up the Yukon in Canada, it was the result of management issues downstream. The North Pacific Fishery Management Council has worked to reduce king salmon bycatch in the commercial fishery, and more projects to improve fish passage would help as well, she said. Increasing hatchery contributions could do damage to wild stocks over time, she said.

“It’s very important that (legislators) read some of these scientific papers that show that we do do damage to our wild fish,” she said.

Rep. Justin Parish (D-Juneau) said he was concerned about preserving the genetic diversity present in wild stocks. Hatchery fish could have an advantage over wild stocks in terms of survival, so introducing more incubated fish into an existing wild stock could limit genetic diversity, he said.

Parish also raised concerns about the sustainability of using hatchery practices to supplement wild runs that are being damaged by larger causes like warming oceans, increased predation or commercial fishing bycatch.

“It also seems a little bit like if your house is on fire, it’s like a really cool glass of ice water,” Parish said. “It’s really great in the short term, but if you don’t deal with the fact that your house is on fire, it’s not a long-term solution.”

Fish and Game has a genetic diversity baseline policy for hatchery-supplemented stocks. Talerico acknowledged that maintaining genetic diversity is a legitimate concern.

The committee held the bill at its Wednesday meeting, and another hearing scheduled for Friday was cancelled.

Reach Elizabeth Earl at elizabeth.earl@peninsulaclarion.com.

More in News

Alaska House Speaker Louise Stutes, center, along with leaders of the House majority coalition, Rep. Bryce Edgmon, left and Rep. Kelly Merrickspeaks, right, speak to reporters on the final day of a special legislative session in Juneau, Alaska Friday, June 18, 2021. The special legislative session limped toward a bitter end Friday, with Alaska Gov. Mike Dunleavy and House majority leaders sharply disagreeing over the adequacy of the budget passed by lawmakers earlier this week. (AP Photo/Becky Bohrer)
Special session limps toward its end, another looms

Gov. Mike Dunleavy and House majority leaders sharply disagreed on the adequacy of the budget passed by lawmakers.

Brent Hibbert (left) presents Tim Dillon with a commending resolution on Tuesday in Soldotna. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
KPEDD honored with assembly resolution

The resolution praised, among other things, KPEDD’s work in helping distribute federal COVID-19 relief funds.

The Kenai Public Dock is seen on Friday, June 18, 2021 in Kenai, Alaska. (Ashlyn O'Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
Kenai dock repairs substantially complete

The dock, which was built in 1986, sustained damage from multiple earthquakes, including in November of 2018.

Screenshot 
A recently released map by the National Telecommunications and Information Administration shows the vast areas of low data speeds and access by broadband users across Alaska and the rest of the U.S.
White House laying groundwork for improved internet infrastructure

In Alaska, providers are looking at their own improvments to access.

Kate Cox, 12, testifies before the Kenai City Council on Wednesday, June 16, 2021 in Kenai, Alaska. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
Council, public voice support for Triumvirate land donation

The land is located near Daubenspeck Park by the Kenai Walmart.

Part of the hose line laid around the perimeter of the 102-acre Loon Lake Fire to help firefighters extinguish any hot spots is seen on Thursday, June 17, 2021 on the Kenai Peninsula, Alaska. (Bryan Quimby/Gannett Glacier Fire Crew)
Loon Lake Fire reaches 100% containment

The 102-acre fire was first reported on the evening of June 12 and is said to have been caused by lightning.

A-10 Thunderbolt II aircraft assigned to the 25th Fighter Squadron taxi during exercise Red Flag-Alaska 21-02 at Eielson Air Force Base on June 14. 
Tech. Sgt. Peter Thompson / U.S. Air Force
Air Force kicks off major multinational exercise in Alaska

More than 100 aircraft from three countries will be involved.

Ron Gillham, who represents District 30 in the Alaska House of Representatives, is seen here in this undated photo. (Courtesy Ron Gillham)
Gillham files intent to run in 2022 primary

Gillham did not indicate the office he plans to run for.

Most Read