Assembly revives invocation policy

The Kenai Peninsula Borough Assembly revived its controversial invocation policy during a reconsideration vote at its Tuesday meeting.

The assembly passed an amendment at its Nov. 22 meeting deleting the entire policy it had passed in October, which set guidelines for who would be allowed to provide the prayer given before the regular assembly meetings. However, at the end of the meeting, assembly member Blaine Gilman filed for reconsideration, which brought the topic up again for discussion at the Tuesday meeting.

With assembly member Willy Dunne absent, the other eight members of the assembly split the vote on the amendment deleting the policy that was up for reconsideration. When the vote is tied, a motion fails, so the amendment deleting the policy failed, reverting the policy back to the one the assembly passed in October.

That policy lays out a set of criteria for anyone wishing to give an invocation. The person must be part of a religious group that meets regularly for the primary purpose of sharing a religious perspective or be a chaplain that serves fire departments, law enforcement agencies, hospitals or other similar organizations. The assembly president designates someone to give an invocation.

The policy is also one the Alaska chapter of the American Civil Liberties Union threatened to sue the borough over. The organization advocates for civil liberties, frequently through litigation, and sent a letter to the borough on Oct. 20 asking it to drop the invocation policy because it prevents people not part of a religious group or whose groups do not pass the criteria from participating.

Gilman, one of the original sponsors of the policy that passed in October, defended it as open to all religious groups, including atheistic and humanist groups. The goal was to prevent political groups from giving invocations, he said. Having a policy in writing will help keep it open if an assembly president who is less open to all religions should ever be elected, he said.

“A president could be up there who wasn’t so inclusive,” he said. “That’s not good policy for the assembly. Things need to be in writing. And we shouldn’t be afraid to have our policy in writing.”

Assembly President Kelly Cooper, a cosponsor on the amendment passed Nov. 22 that would have changed the language to include groups that meet to share “an interest or belief that is very important to the attendees,” urged assembly members to support the amendment that deleted the entire policy. The policy that the assembly enacted in October excluded individuals and groups that don’t fit the definition, she said.

“This policy would even exclude Jesus Christ from being able to give us an invocation,” Cooper said. “I can’t reconcile how this exclusive policy serves the assembly or our residents.”

Because Dunne, who has been a vocal opponent of the policy, was absent and assembly member Paul Fischer attended by phone, assembly member Gary Knopp tried to postpone the vote to the Jan. 3 meeting. However, the policy’s supporters refused, voting against the motion to postpone.

The assembly was tied 4-4 in their re-vote on the amendment that deletes the policy, with Cooper, Knopp, Fischer and assembly member Brandii Holmdahl of Seward voting to keep the amendment. Knopp tried to ask for reconsideration at the end of the meeting, but assembly policy prevents an issue that has just been reconsidered from being immediately reconsidered again, regardless of the outcome.

More two dozen people filled the seats at the assembly chambers to get the chance to weigh in on the issue, which has been ongoing for months. Commenters called in from Homer, all six of whom opposed reconsidering the policy. The people who spoke in person at the assembly chambers had differing views on the issue, with some opposing any kind of invocation, others opposing the policy, some supporting the policy and still others speaking generally in favor of the presence of God in public meetings.

Borough Mayor Mike Navarre said during his comments at the end of the meeting that he planned to bring forward a budget appropriation at the next meeting to transfer funds to the legal department because of legal challenges to the policy. It would not increase the budget, and if there are no challenges to the policy, the funding will lapse at the end of the fiscal year, he said.

“It’s not because I want to spend money on this issue,” he said. “It’s because as mayor and administrator of this borough, I have a responsibility and a duty to uphold, whether I agree with them or not, the ordinances and policies of the assembly. It’s not because I want to spend money on it, it’s because I believe we will see some challenges on it.”

Reach Elizabeth Earl at

More in News

The sign in front of the Homer Electric Association building in Kenai, Alaska, as seen on April 1, 2020. (Peninsula Clarion file)
HEA rates to increase Jan. 1

The cooperative’s last rate increase took effect in April 2020

AP Photo/Erin Hooley
An eight-week-old sea otter rescued from Seldovia, Alaska, peaks out of his enclosure at Shedd Aquarium Wednesday, Dec. 6 in Chicago. The otter was found alone and malnourished and was taken to the Alaska SeaLife Center in Seward which contacted Shedd, and the Chicago aquarium was able to take the otter in. He will remain quarantined for a few months while he learns to groom and eat solid foods before being introduced to Shedd’s five other sea otters.
Seldovia sea otter pup has a new home at Chicago’s Shedd Aquarium

The northern sea otter was found alone and malnourished and taken to the Alaska SeaLife Center in Seward

Students from Nikiski Middle/High School and Kenai Middle School join Jesse Bjorkman, Ken Felchle and volunteers from the Kenai Peninsula Chapter of Safari Club International on an educational moose hunt in Nikiski, Alaska, on Saturday, Dec. 2, 2023. (Photo provided by Jesse Bjorkman)
Lessons in big game hunting

Students learn to ethically and responsibly harvest a moose and process its meat for food

Cook Inletkeeper Energy Policy Analyst Ben Boettger presents information about retrofitting homes to be more energy efficient at the Cook Inletkeeper Community Action Studio on Tuesday, Dec. 5, 2023, in Soldotna, Alaska. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
Inletkeeper turns focus to energy for next community climate solution

The meeting marked the official kickoff of Cook Inletkeeper’s fourth installment in its local solution series

Alaska State Troopers logo.
Woman arrested after allegedly shooting neighbor’s house

The woman had been trying to break up a dog fight, troopers said

A pie chart shows Kenai Peninsula Borough School District expenditures by object for the current fiscal year. (Chart via KPBSD)
Explanation of how KPBSD organizes funds caps ‘Budget 101’ series

Finance Director Elizabeth Hayes delivered the presentation to school board members during a Monday work session

Rep. Justin Ruffridge, R-Soldotna, answers questions from constituents during a legislative update at the Kenai Chamber of Commerce and Visitor Center on Wednesday, Dec. 6, 2023, in Kenai, Alaska. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
Ruffridge predicts school funding, energy security will be top issues in Juneau next session

Ruffridge has represented District 7, which includes Kenai and Soldotna, in the Alaska House of Representatives since October 2022

Members of the Kenai Peninsula Borough School District Board of Education meet on Monday, Dec. 4, 2023, in Soldotna, Alaska. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
New school board group will study 4-day school week

The group will meet regularly until next July, when committee members will present their findings to the full board

Members of the Kenai/Soldotna Fish and Game Advisory Committee raise hands to vote in favor of a proposal during a meeting at Cook Inlet Aquaculture Association in Kenai, Alaska, on Monday, Nov. 20, 2023. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
Advisory committee supports protections for lake trout and king salmon

Advisory committee recommendations will be weighed by the State Board of Fisheries alongside public testimony as they deliberate on each proposal

Most Read