This image released by DreamWorks Animation shows Sherman, voiced by Max Charles, from left, Penny, voiced by Ariel Winter, and Mr. Peabody, voiced by Ty Burell, in a scene from "Mr Peabody & Sherman." (AP Photo/ DreamWorks Animation)

This image released by DreamWorks Animation shows Sherman, voiced by Max Charles, from left, Penny, voiced by Ariel Winter, and Mr. Peabody, voiced by Ty Burell, in a scene from "Mr Peabody & Sherman." (AP Photo/ DreamWorks Animation)

Reviews of Mr. Peabody and Sherman/ Out of the Furnace

Mr. Peabody and Sherman

1hr 30min

Rated PG



Out of the Furnace

116 minutes

Rated : R

This week I saw two very different films and, while they were of approximately the same level of quality, they are for vastly different audiences. It should go without saying that parents will want to take their kids to the one with the cartoon dog voiced by “Modern Family’s” Phil Dunphy as opposed to the one where Christian Bale and Woody Harrelson play mumbling misanthropes in the backwoods of the Rust Belt.

I remember watching “Mr. Peabody & Sherman” as a kid on “Rocky and Bullwinkle” reruns, although I don’t think it was called that. In fact, the duo has been around so long that my parents could also have watched them as children, taking delight in their screwball trips through time via the WABAC machine. I remembered that Mr. Peabody was super-smart, that he was in charge, and that he was a dog. Sherman, as I recall, was a bit of dork and sounded a lot like Rocky the Squirrel. What I don’t remember was any kind of familial relationship between the two, although the 2014 big-budget 3-D animated adventure sure does. Apparently Mr. Peabody, the world’s most accomplished being, was lonely and decided to adopt a baby. After gaining specific permission from the courts to do so, Peabody takes legal parental custody of Sherman, raising him as his own, with a little help from historic figures of the distant past. While the five minute cartoon segments focused mainly on the adventure followed by a not-so-clever pun, this current incarnation is all about the family stuff, which is frankly, slightly off-putting. Peabody, upon dropping Sherman off at school for the first time, is nervous, understandably, it turns out because his precious boy winds up biting a bully who was taunting him in the lunch room. As a solution, Peabody invites the bully and her parents (the bully in question is a pretty blond girl named Penny – anyone want to take odds on whether Sherman is going to have his first crush?) home to supper to work it all out. Predictably, Sherman and Penny wind up in the WABAC machine and all heck breaks loose.

At first, I was fairly annoyed at the number of dumb, ever-so-gently crude jokes there were in the film. The material is certainly not offensive, just lowest common denominator stuff. Gradually, however, the story picks up steam and by the end things get both fun and pretty sweet. The movie moves at a break-neck pace, perhaps to satisfy a generation children being brought up on “Phineas and Ferb,” but there are some genuinely enjoyable moments. Ty Burrell, as Peabody, is nicely witty and urbane, although he can’t do much beyond an impersonation of the original Peabody from the ‘50s. Stephen Colbert is a welcome addition as Penny’s father, as is Patrick Warburton as a dimwitted Agamemnon from the Battle of Troy. Unfortunately, as many of the jokes fall flat as land, and many of the plot twists, including one involving Child Protective Services, seem needlessly flamboyant. By the time the credits rolled, I had bought in, but it took a while to get there. The movie is a fine little diversion, but really sets itself up for failure when it touts both “How to Train Your Dragon,” and “The Lion King,” among the pedigree of its creators. There is nothing classic about “Mr. Peabody,” and not even a trip back in the WABAC can change that. Grade: B-

“Out of the Furnace,” though slightly better as a whole, also suffers somewhat in comparison to its predecessor. Touted as the next major project from “Crazy Heart” director Scott Cooper, this tale of small town tragedy and justice can’t come close to living up to the beauty and heart of that previous film. That doesn’t make it bad, but it’s just not great either. Christian Bale and Casey Affleck are two brothers in the rural Northeast – the older, Russell, working quietly at the steel mill while younger brother Rodney flounders at home while in between tours to Iraq. Russell has a handle on life, taking care of his ailing father and keeping his brother out of trouble, all the while growing closer to family and fatherhood with his beautiful girlfriend Lena, played by Zoe Saldana. But, when a tragic accident puts him out of commission for an extended time, life spins out of control. Lena leaves and takes up with a local law enforcement officer played by Forrest Whitaker, and Rodney, under the reluctant tutelage of small-time crime boss John Petty, takes a gig bare knuckle fighting for the dangerous Harlan DeGroat, played by Woody Harrelson. As you can imagine, things go from bad to worse.

Most of the pieces of “Furnace” are top notch. The acting, though certainly minimalist, is well done, especially by Harrelson and Affleck. Christian Bale, in trying to play “real” barely says anything at all, but it works. It was also nice to see Willem Dafoe in a completely non-disturbing role, for once, as Petty. The problem is that the movie fails to really grab the audience. Everything is so muted, from the performances to the music, that even when the stakes are rising, the tension level seems to stay the same. In the end, you’re left with the feeling that you’ve just watched two hours of backwoods lowlifes butting up against each other and nothing ever really comes of it. It’s not that nothing happens – plenty does, but the stakes feel low and there is little consequence to it all. The performances are impressive in a non-impressive way. Unfortunately, the movie only seems impressive until you realize it isn’t.

Grade: B-

“Mr. Peabody & Sherman” is rated PG for mild crude humor and cartoon action. “Out of the Furnace” is rated R for language and strong violence.


Chris Jenness is a freelance graphic designer, artist and movie buff who lives in Nikiski.

More in Life

Will Morrow (courtesy)
Springing ahead

I’m not ready to spring ahead

Murder suspect William Dempsey is pictured shortly after he was captured on the outskirts of Seward in early September 1919. (Photo courtesy of the University of Alaska Fairbanks archives)
A Nexus of Lives and Lies: The William Dempsey story — Part 8

Dempsey spent more than a decade attempting to persuade a judge to recommend him for executive clemency

Promotional image via the Performing Arts Society
Saturday concert puts jazz, attitude on stage

Lohmeyer is a former local music teacher

The author holds a copy of Greta Thunberg’s, “No One Is Too Small to Make a Difference,” inside the Peninsula Clarion building on Wednesday, March 22, 2023, in Kenai, Alaska. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
Off the Shelf: Thunberg speeches pack a punch

“No One Is Too Small to Make A Difference” is a compilation of 16 essays given by the climate activist

White chocolate cranberry cake is served with fresh cranberries. (Photo by Tressa Dale/Peninsula Clarion)
Hard-to-ruin cranberry cake

This white chocolate cranberry cake is easy to make and hard to ruin — perfect for my students aged 3, 6, 7 and 7.

Virginia Walters (Courtesy photo)
Life in the Pedestrian Lane: It’s March

March is the trickster month, probably why we see so much raven activity these days

After Pres. Woodrow Wilson commuted his death sentence to life in prison, William Dempsey (inmate #3572) was delivered from Alaska to the federal penitentiary on McNeil Island, Wash. These were his intake photos. (Photo courtesy of the University of Alaska Fairbanks archives)
A Nexus of Lives and Lies: The William Dempsey story — Part 7

The opening line of Dempsey’s first letter to Bunnell — dated March 19, 1926 — got right to the point

Bella Ramsey as Ellie and Pedro Pascal as Joel in “The Last of Us.” (Photo courtesy HBO)
On the Screen: ‘The Last of Us’ perfectly adapts a masterpiece

HBO unquestionably knew they had a hit on their hands

Chocolate cake is topped with white chocolate cream cheese frosting. (Photo by Tressa Dale/Peninsula Clarion)
A cake topped with love (and white chocolate cream cheese)

He loved the frosting so much he said he never wants anything else on his cake

In 1914, Pres. Woodrow Wilson appointed Charles Bunnell to be the judge of the Federal District Court for the Third and Fourth divisions of the Alaska Territory. (Photo courtesy of the University of Alaska Fairbanks archives)
A Nexus of Lives and Lies: The William Dempsey story — Part 6

Prosecution lawyers were fortunate to have a fallback plan: witnesses to the crime.

The author displays her daily vitamin, three yellowish clear bubbles of Vitamin D, and 20 mg of Paxil. (Photo by Meredith Harber/Minister’s Message)
Minister’s Message: Accepting all parts of your story of growth

I started taking Paxil almost six years ago, after a lifelong struggle with anxiety and depression

Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion 
A copy of Marie Aubert’s “Grown Ups” sits on a desk in The Peninsula Clarion building on Wednesday in Kenai.
Off the Shelf: Good for her

Marie Aubert’s “Grown Ups” caught my attention with a flashy cover and a review from Independent Ireland on the cover