Jeremy Renner, left, and Gil Birmingham in a scene from “Wind River.” (Fred Hayes/The Weinstein Company via AP)

Jeremy Renner, left, and Gil Birmingham in a scene from “Wind River.” (Fred Hayes/The Weinstein Company via AP)

Reeling it in: Authentic feel to ‘Wind River’

“Wind River”

The Weinstein Company

1 hour, 47 minutes

Jeremy Renner has never been an actor that elicits a huge emotional response. I like him, I guess. I’ve liked most of his movies, at least the ones I’ve seen. He plays Hawkeye in “The Avengers” and, while I like his character in those films a lot, you’re not hearing people clamoring for a “Hawkeye” solo flick. He’s the kind of inoffensive performer that you spend very little time thinking about outside of whatever character he’s playing.

That said, it’s hard for me to think of a movie he’s been in that I didn’t like. Wait — yes, “The Bourne Redundancy.” Was that what it was called? Who cares? The weird spin-off Bourne. That one wasn’t good. But mostly, Renner’s OK in my book.

This week, with his new wilderness murder mystery “Wind River,” Renner’s stock just went up.

The story concerns the investigation into the murder of a young woman on the Arapaho Reservation in Wyoming. Renner’s character, Cory Lambert, is a Predator Control officer for Wyoming Fish and Wildlife. His job is to hunt down coyotes, wolves or mountain lions that harass local livestock. It is with grim irony, then, that while trailing his prey, he comes upon the body of girl, dead from exhaustion and over-exertion in the frigid mountainous landscape. Barefoot, badly beaten, and six miles from the nearest outpost of civilization, foul play seems obvious.

The local law enforcement, a depressingly understaffed Tribal Police force, calls for assistance from the FBI, who arrives in the person of Jane Banner, played by Elizabeth Olsen. Banner, in typical movie fashion, is relatively new to the job, and ill-prepared for the weather and terrain she’ll face. In addition, she’s alone. Unable to call for back-up due to the fact that the medical examiner won’t declare the death a homicide (she died from the run, not her injuries), it’s up to Banner and Lambert to work the case to its logical conclusion.

In many ways, “Wind River” is a very straightforward, typical genre film. Murder mystery, fish out of water, unlikely partnership, surprise villain. You’ve seen this movie. If I remember right, Val Kilmer made a very similar movie about 20 years ago called “Thunderheart.”

What makes this film special, however, is a combination of the script and the performances. The word that kept coming back to me was “authentic.” The film feels real. The actors, in their various roles, are all entirely believable. That takes a subtle script and a confident director.

You can tell writer/director Taylor Sheridan is the real deal because all the performances, from the largest to the smallest all have that sense of being true. Not true as in documentary style veritas, maybe — this is still a slick Hollywood film — but true to the area and to the story it’s telling.

It’s also very economical. Nothing feels extraneous or wasted. Though this is Sheridan’s first major directing job, you can see the same kind of authenticity in his scripts for “Hell or High Water,” and “Sicario” — two excellent films in their own right.

Though I like Elizabeth Olsen fine (also an Avenger, I might add) I was particularly taken with Renner in this film. Finally he feels like he’s broken free of his particular brand of pleasing blandness and turned in a really powerful, emotional performance. Never bombastic, Lambert is a quiet, thoughtful guy, but with a determinedly friendly air about him, disguising a deep, deep hurt.

Actually, Renner’s performance really reminded me of a good friend of mine — a guy who always takes my kids fishing and calls all the boys “bud.” Whether it was that particular familiarity, or the fact that this film will seem especially relevant to Alaskans, “Wind River” feels like home in some ways. Not all of those ways are good, but so much of the movie was reminiscent of the kind of lives people often live in this state, I couldn’t help but make the comparison.

I did have a few problems with the film. For one, the resolution of the mystery is somewhat dissatisfying, if only from a logic standpoint. So much of this film feels so true, and the actions of the villain didn’t really have that same feeling.

Also, the film finishes with a coda about the fact that Native American women go missing at an alarming rate and that it is criminally under reported. A valid and worthy point, but not really one that has anything to do with the movie, where the crime seems very specific and has more implications into just general violence against women, than it does with Native women in particular.

That said, I really enjoyed this movie. It’s rough in parts — no doubt about it — but if you can stand it, it’s definitely worth the ride. Grade: A

“Wind River” is rated R for language and graphic violence including sexual assault.

Chris Jenness is an art teacher, freelance graphic designer, artist and movie buff who lives in Nikiski.

More in Life

White men and women in Kenai tended to congregate with people like themselves. This typical outing, in Kasilof, includes (far left, back row) Hans P. Nielsen, superintendent of the Agricultural Experiment Station. (Photo from the Alaska Digital Archives)
Exerting control in Old Kenai — Part 3

This is the third installment in a series about two killings that occurred in Kenai on April 8, 1918.

Pratt Museum officials pose for a photograph while practicing social distancing on the museum lawn on Friday, May 15, 2020, in Homer, Alaska. From left to right are Jennifer Gibbins, executive director; Savanna Bradley, curator, and Marilyn Sigman, naturalist in residence. (Photo by Michael Armstrong/Homer News)
Homer Arts groups look to post-pandemic future

Signs of hope include more in-person workshops, writers residencies.

Photo from “Once Upon the Kenai” 
William N. Dawson chats with Captain Rose, of the S.S. Tyonic, in front of Dawson’s Kenai store in 1915.
Exerting Control in Old Kenai — Part 2

The second installment in a series about two killings that occurred in Kenai on April 8, 1918.

Tom Kizzia, author of “The Wake of the Unseen Object,” in a photo taken Aug. 10, 2012, near Homer, Alaska. (Photo by Don Pitcher; courtesy of Tom Kizzia)
Local author’s ‘Wake of the Unseen Object’ back in print after 30 years

Literary travel book had roots in newspaper series about rural Alaska.

Victoria Petersen / Peninsula Clarion
Chicken noodle soup is a bowl of comfort during challenging times.
Kalifornsky Kitchen: Chicken soup for the stressed

Maybe you’ve been feeling stressed, and are just looking for something comfortable and nourishing.

Nick Varney
Unhinged Alaska: So, now what 2021 ?

The new year has started out in an interesting way, mainly because many of us are still dealing with some hang-around issues from the previous 365 days.

A few days after surviving an Aug. 2, 1967, crash in this single-engine Maule Rocket, Dane Parks poses near the front end of the wreckage. (Photo courtesy
Dr. Gaede drops in, Part 3

This is Part Three of a three-part story of an airplane crash more than a half-century ago.

Minister’s Message: Have faith; we are in good hands

Whether or not this new year will continue the wild adventure of the year most recently ended or not, we are going to make it.

My favorite breakfast bagel sandwich from my favorite neighborhood coffee shack, on Jan. 5, 2020, in Anchorage, Alaska. (Photo by Victoria Petersen/Peninsula Clarion)
Looking for a few good bagels

Simple ingredients to make your own breakfast sandwich

In the early 1890s, one of the few men willing to stand up against the bullying and brutality of Alex Ryan was the Russian Orthodox priest, Father Alexander Yaroshevich. (Photo from the Alaska Digital Archives)
Exerting control in Old Kenai — Part 1

This is a complex tale of a changing Kenai and of four men — not just the two dead ones — and their perhaps inevitable fatal collision.

The finished product should have a light, flaky crust and moist fillings, as seen here on Christmas Day, Dec. 25, 2020 in Crystal Falls, Michigan. Finished off with a Michigan made beer, it’s hard to find a better second lunch/early dinner on Christmas Day. (Photo by Megan Pacer/Homer News)
Kalifornsky Kitchen: Pasties two ways

Peninsula Clarion columnist Victoria Petersen and Homer News reporter Megan Pacer team up to make the traditional hand pie.