An Outdoor View: Trouble with gill-netters

For years, I railed against subsistence fishing in the Kenai. I dreaded that it would mean gill nets in the river. I feared that it would be a federally enforced source of bitter divisiveness among local residents.

When I heard about the recent decision of the Federal Subsistence Board to allow subsistence gill nets in the Kenai and Kasilof rivers, I felt sick. I noted that the motion to allow gill netting had passed on a 4-3 vote by the federal board, signaling that the issue already was contentious, even before anyone put a gill net in the river. It seemed that my worst fears had come true.

However, after thinking about it for a while, I’ve had second thoughts. Given the fact that there remains no limit on the number of fishing guides on the Kenai and Kasilof rivers, and that the Kenai River Sportfishing Association seems hell-bent to maximize the number of tourists that can be squeezed onto these rivers, one 60-foot-long gill net for the community of Ninilchik seems relatively harmless. Not that I approve of it, but at least the people who fish with that gillnet will be catching salmon for food, not catching and releasing them simply for fun and profit.

Yet another gill net-related event was Governor Walker’s appointment of Roland Maw to the Alaska Board of Fisheries. What next? Appointing Rod Arno, executive director of the Alaska Outdoor Council, to the Board of Game?

There’s a good reason why Maw would be the first Cook Inlet commercial fisherman to serve on the fish board since 1980. He shouldn’t be on the board for the same reason that Brent Johnson shouldn’t have been on the board. Johnson, a longtime East-side set-netter and set-netter advocate, was appointed by Governor Sarah Palin in 2009. However, most legislators saw that Johnson would not only be a lightning rod for conflict, but in large part would be ineffective due to his ties to commercial fishing in Cook Inlet, so they didn’t confirm his appointment.

Maw is a longtime, outspoken commercial-fishing advocate, and executive director of United Cook Inlet Drift Association (UCIDA). Even more damning, UCIDA — with Maw aboard — has in recent years twice filed lawsuits in federal court that would return Cook Inlet salmon management to the federal government. This alone means that Maw has a contentious relationship with the board before he even takes a seat. With him on the board, every allocative proposal — and nearly all proposals are allocative — would trigger heated debate.

Maw’s association with drift-gill net fishing puts him at odds with all other user groups, even the East-side setnetters, who often are shut down while the “drifters” are allowed to fish. If seated, Maw can be expected to try to reverse some of what other user groups have gained in salmon allocation decisions made by the board in the past two decades.

No matter how or where you fish in Alaska, the seven-member Alaska Board of Fisheries is important to you. This is the board that makes all the state regulations for fisheries. In recent years, it has been balanced, with fair representation of all user groups. Maw, being a stronger advocate of commercial fishing than the other board members, will upset that balance. This board’s business is too important to jeopardize by appointing someone to it who is certain to be a negative influence.

Governor Walker, as well as the Legislators who will have to confirm Maw’s appointment, need to be told that it would be a big mistake to have Maw on the Board of Fisheries. The best scenario would be for the Legislature to vote against Maw’s confirmation before he has a chance to sit in a board meeting.

Les Palmer can be reached at les.palmer@rocketmail.com.

More in Life

This Al Hershberger photo of his good friend Hedley Parsons was taken in Germany in 1945, after World War II had ended. Parsons and Hershberger came to Alaska together a few years later, and in 2010, when Parsons was interviewed for this story, he may have been the last person living who had actually attended George Dudley’s messy funeral
This parting was not sweet sorrow — Part 2

The funeral was scheduled for 2 p.m. on May 5, and spring break-up was in full, sloppy bloom at the Kenai Cemetery

Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion
A copy of “People, Paths, and Places: The Frontier History of Moose Pass, Alaska” stands in sunlight in Soldotna on Friday.
Off the Shelf: Community history project a colorful portrait of hometown

The book features the work of students at Moose Pass School and integrates further stories pulled from a community newspaper

The Anchorage Bowl Chamber Orchestra performs. (Photo courtesy Anchorage Bowl Chamber Orchestra)
Anchorage orchestra group to visit Kenai Peninsula for 10th annual tour

Anchorage Bowl Chamber Orchestra will play four shows from May 30 to June 2

File
Minister’s Message: Boasting only in Christ and the Cross

The Reverend Billy Graham advised every president since Truman during his lifetime

Corn cheese is served alongside grilled beef, kimchi and lettuce. (Photo by Tressa Dale/Peninsula Clarion)
Planning barbecue with all the bells and whistles

Expect kimchi, lots of side dishes, piles of rice, marinated meat for the flame and cold fruit for dessert

Noa (voiced by Owen Teague) in 20th Century Studios’ “Kingdom of the Planet of the Apes.” (Photo courtesy of 20th Century Studios)
On the Screen: New ‘Planet of the Apes’ expands, brings new ideas to franchise universe

“Kingdom of the Planet of the Apes” tells a story that feels more rooted in fantasy than the post-apocalypse vibe of its predecessors

A mural depicting imagery and iconography of Kenai brightens the entryway of the Walmart in Kenai, Alaska, on Wednesday, May 15, 2024. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
‘Visible art raises people’s spirits’

Local artist’s mural introduced as part of Walmart renovations

Former North Kenai resident George Coe Dudley, seen here during the winter of 1950-51, was a hard-drinking man. His messy funeral in 1967 in Kenai echoed his lifestyle. (Photo courtesy of Al Hershberger)
This parting was not sweet sorrow — Part 1

“Dudley was an easy-going, laid-back sort of guy, always laughing and joking, as well as hard drinking.”

The Ladies of the Pacific lead a hula demonstration as part of Aloha Vibes at the Soldotna Regional Sports Complex on Saturday. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
Diamond Dance’s ‘Aloha Vibes’ brings together music, movement and celebration

The project’s all-company showcase was only one of several attractions filling the space as part of the group’s annual event

Most Read