An Outdoor View: Fishing the forum

When fishing opportunities are few, I sometimes enjoy fishing in the various forums on the Internet.

You never know what you might find in a fishing forum. Like any good water, these things are in a constant state of flux. And like any good fishing hole, you never know who you might find there.

Earlier this week, I fished the Alaska Outdoors Supersite, a Website for everyone who does most anything outdoors in Alaska. In the Alaska Fisheries Management Forum, a thread titled “Catch and Release – Blood Sports” caught my eye. What grabbed my attention was that the first post contained a link to my Clarion column of Feb. 28, 2014, one of several I’ve written about catch-and-release fishing. I like seeing what people think about my columns. I was hooked.

My column apparently touched a few nerves. In a post that fairly seethed with emotion and hyperbole, I was accused of using emotion and hyperbole. A couple of commenters thought my views on catch-and-release fishing were like something written by the president of PETA. Another suggested that I should hang my head in shame. I was called stupid, a hypocrite and — my favorite — “the enemy of all sportsmen.”

When I write, I’m usually trying to get readers to think about something. Judging from the first few comments in this thread, I succeeded in getting some of them to think about melting some tar and finding some feathers to use on Les Palmer.

One sentence in my column seemed to evoke the most vitriol. In my closing, I wrote, “I can’t help but wonder. If people get some kind of perverted enjoyment from seeing animals being abused, and suffering and dying, what else do they do for entertainment?” A couple of the commenters, apparently assuming that I was pointing The Accusatory Finger of Judgement at them, wanted me to apologize.

OK, here’s an apology: I apologize for wondering. Forgive me, please. However, wondering about things is a lifelong habit with me, so don’t be surprised if I do it again. For example, right now I’m wondering why some of the critics of that sentence were so defensive.

I’ve always known catch-and-release is controversial, and this thread pretty much covers the reasons why. The comments run on for 11 pages, a good indication of the interest readers have in the subject. The most recent posts are only a few days old, so the thread has had a two-year run. For a fishing forum, that’s a long run.

Not all the comments are negative. After reading through them, I was pleasantly surprised to find that most of those who commented agree that catching and releasing Kenai River king salmon shouldn’t be allowed when adequate spawning escapement is in doubt, as it has been in recent years.

Not that I don’t appreciate negative comments about what I write. Whether a comment is a candy heart or a poison dart, I learn something from it. Sometimes I find out that I didn’t make a point as well as I could’ve or should’ve. When I get no comments at all, I’m left to wonder.

The way I see it, if something I write can start people thinking about subjects that need a good airing, and get them started discussing those subjects, I’ve done my job. In this particular Internet fishing forum, for this particular subject, my work is done.

Visit the Alaska Outdoors Supersite at

■ ■ ■

Les Palmer can be reached at

More in Life

Michael S. Lockett / Juneau Empire
Local Tlingit beader Jill Kaasteen Meserve is making waves as her work becomes more widely known, both in Juneau and the Lower 48.
Old styles in new ways: Beader talks art and octopus bags

She’s been selected for both a local collection and a major Indigenous art market

A copy of “The Fragile Earth” rests on a typewriter on Wednesday, May 18, 2022 in Kenai, Alaska. (Ashlyn O’Hara/Peninsula Clarion)
Off the Shelf: Seeking transformation in the face of catastrophe

Potent words on climate change resonate across decades

Gochujang dressing spices up tofu, lettuce, veggies and sprouts. (Photo by Tressa Dale/Peninsula Clarion)
On the strawberry patch: Healthy life starts with healthy food

Gochujang salad dressing turns veggies and tofu into an exciting meal

Virginia Walters (Courtesy photo)
Life in the Pedestrian Lane: Spring Fever

“OK, Boomer” is supposed to be the current put down by the “woke generation”

A headstone for J.E. Hill is photographhed in Anchorage, Alaska. (
Night falls on the Daylight Kid — Part 2

“Bob,” he said, “that crazy fool is shooting at us.”

Minister’s Message: Has spring sprung in your life?

Christ also offers us an eternal springtime of love, hope and life

Eggs Benedict are served with hollandaise on a bed of arugula and prosciutto. (Photo by Tressa Dale/Peninsula Clarion)
On the strawberry patch: Honoring motherhood, in joy and in sorrow

Many who have suffered this loss believe they must bear it in silence for the sake of propriety

Page from Seward daily gateway. (Alaska State Library, Archives and Museum, Juneau, A.K.)
Night falls on the Daylight Kid — Part 1

Night Falls on the Daylight Kid—Part One By Clark Fair

Meredith Harber (courtesy)
Minister’s Message: Spread love in these challenging times

I don’t know about you all, but the world feels pretty rough these days

Most Read