An Outdoor View: Big fish, big fight

Author’s note: For various reasons, most big halibut are caught by anglers fishing from charter boats. This story is about a very large halibut that was hooked by a local angler fishing from his 20-foot skiff. The Clarion previously published it in “On the Kenai,” in 2002. It’s one of my favorite big-fish stories. — LP

On April 18, 1997, Brandon O’Neill, his father, Ray, and his friend, Joe Johnson, were trolling for king salmon near Homer, off Bluff Point, in Ray’s 20-foot skiff. They had caught two 15-pound kings. Then, just after noon, a fish took one of the baits. Brandon grabbed the rod, and the fight was on.

They didn’t know what it was, but it felt heavy. They were fishing with light salmon gear, 20-pound line. Twice, the fish ran, taking probably 200 yards of line each time, Ray said. They followed it. Forty-five minutes after hooking the fish, Brandon was able to bring it up.

“When I first saw it, about five feet down, I thought it was a big skate,” Ray said. “Then, I realized it was a big halibut.”

A thrashing halibut can wreak havoc in a small boat. When one weighs 100 pounds, or so — and this one definitely did — Alaskan anglers usually shoot it with a .410 shotgun or a large-caliber pistol. The only gun Ray had aboard was a .22 pistol. Holding the inadequate pistol six inches from the fish’s head, Ray shot twice. The fish dove to the bottom.

Brandon pumped and reeled. Thirty minutes later, the fish again surfaced. Ray shot again, several times.

“After about the sixth shot, it went down again,” he said.

On this dive, Brandon’s rod broke. Undeterred, they tied his line to another outfit and cut the broken one loose.

Again, Brandon pulled the fish up. Again, Ray shot. The fish was stunned, just hanging there with its mouth open. Joe took a chance. With rope in hand, he thrust his arm through the yawning mouth and out the gills, just in time. The fish started thrashing.

Ray had gaffed the fish. Now, the gaff hook broke. Fortunately, Joe’s rope held. While the fish beat the water to a froth, Ray got a rope around its tail.

“Right then, Brandon’s hook fell out,” Ray said. “On that little salmon hook, it had been just barely hooked.”

The battle had lasted two and a half hours. Back in Homer, most of the charter outfits were still closed for the winter. The only scale around had a 300-pound limit. The fish pegged the scale.

Ray said the biggest halibut he had ever caught was a 150-pounder, caught on heavy halibut gear. Brandon had never caught one before, except maybe a small “chicken,” he said.

Les Palmer can be reached at les.palmer@rocketmail.com.

More in Life

The Ridgeway Rounders perform during Frozen RiverFest on Saturday, Feb. 20, 2023, at Soldotna Creek Park in Soldotna, Alaska. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
10th Frozen RiverFest set for Saturday

The event will feature 19 breweries.

The Middle School Battle of the Books Team from Homer Connections, who won the district competition in February, stand for a photo. (Provided by Districtwide Librarian Julie Gottfried)
District Battle of the Books teams ready for state competition

Battle of the Books is an annual celebration of reading and teamwork.

File
Minister’s Message: Living in the community of faith

Many of us tend to stay within our own denomination for purposes of what we consider to be purity of doctrine.

Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion
Artwork by Susan Nabholz, Charlotte Coots and Chelline Larsen is displayed as part of “Fiber” at the Kenai Art Center on Wednesday.
Focus on fiber

Kenai Art Center show transforms threads to art

The Palm Springs Limelight-News used this photo in 1946 to announce the start of the Alaska Photographic Expedition, guided by Keith McCullagh (left) for his expedition partner and photographer, Harry Reed.
Mostly separate lives: The union and disunion of Nellie and Keith — Part 5

After a bankruptcy, a divorce and an 18-year absence from Alaska, Louis Keith McCullagh headed north on vacation.

These cupcakes are dense, more like brownies than traditional cupcakes, and are chock full of chocolate. (Photo by Tressa Dale/Peninsula Clarion)
‘Chocolate, chocolate, chocolate’ with some sprinkles

These cupcakes are dense, more like brownies than traditional cupcakes, and are chock full of chocolate.

Sophie Thatcher is Iris in “Companion.” (Promotional photo courtesy Warner Bros. Pictures)
On the Screen: ‘Companion’ provides an entertaining critique of digital romance

There are interesting ideas here about what human connection looks like in a world where people are increasingly siloed away into digital spaces.

Mark Jurek directs the Soldotna High School band at a rehersal on Oct. 11, 2022 at Soldotna High School in Soldotna Alaska. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
SoHi jazz band and swing choir fundraiser concert set for Feb. 11

The show will feature SoHi’s jazz band, swing choir, “several vocal soloists” and a variety of cheesecakes.

Virginia Walters (Courtesy photo)
Life in the Pedestrian Lane: January’s done

This has been the strangest January I can remember, and to hear others, apparently it’s pretty unprecedented.

Most Read