Editorial
Web posted Sunday, March 18, 2007

Fish farming plan should be sunk


The Bush administration’s push to allow fish farming for the first time in federal waters does not bode well for Alaska.

The plan would mean ocean farming of shellfish, salmon and saltwater species could occur in federal waters from three to 200 miles offshore.

In announcing the plan last week, Commerce Secretary Carlos Gutierrez said aquaculture is a $70 billion business that acco 0s as competition from farmed fish ballooned.

Fishermen have eked back a portion of their livelihood through marketing campaigns, trying to convince consumers what Alaskans knew all along — wild fish is better. It’s healthier and better for the environment.

But the federal government apparently isn’t interested in supporting the health of its populace or its maritime environment.

Why else would it be pushing a plan that would harm existing industry and pose drastic threats to wild fish stocks?

Money.

As Gutierrez said, importing fish from overseas creates “a trade deficit of about $9 billion in fish.”

That’s significant, to be sure, but so are the potential harms of this proposal.

Fish farming involves wastewater discharge, pesticides and other chemicals that can harm ecosystems.

Then there’s the genetic threat posed to wild stocks if farmed fish get loose, as they invariably do, and the competition that would ensue if farmed fish took up residence in wild fish territory.

The federal government’s plan gives states the option to disallow fish farming up to 12 miles offshore of their coasts. But that restriction does little in the way of protection. A problem with a fish farm offshore of Oregon could negatively impact Alaska, and a poorly operated farm 12 miles off the coast of Alaska undoubtably would.

That’s the thing. Water moves. So do fish. It’s unreasonable to assume pollution or a containment break 12 miles offshore would stay 12 miles offshore.

The Bush administration includes fail-safes in its plan to protect against these occurrences. Fish farming businesses would be required to post bonds or other financial guarantees that they will remove the farms when they are done operating. And operators could be fined for violations, up to $250,000 a day per violation, and criminal penalties of up to five years in prison and $500,000 in fines.

That still isn’t enough protection. Once a disaster happens, all the fines in the world won’t reverse the damage done.

That’s why more study needs to be done to assess exactly how big a risk this proposal poses.

Sen. Lisa Murkowski, R-Alaska, has called for Congress to resist fish farming until a study can be conducted on how it will affect Alaska’s wild fish stocks.

That study hasn’t happened. Yet the Bush administration is pushing ahead without it.

Hopefully Congress realizes the threats posed by fish farming outweigh the monetary benefits that may come from it and deep-sixes this proposal, as it deserves.

Marketplace
View Today's Ads
Place an Ad


Local News
Updated April 15, 2008
News
Airport seeks way to increase earnings
New location for Serenity House found on K-Beach
It's not too late
Borough budget on tap
Photo feature: Clinging to winter

Community News
Around the Peninsula

Letters to the Editor
Reader recalls Heston encounter
Racers give thanks for support

Schools
Getting 'Smart'er
Retiring professor of English receives accolade
Writer chooses excellence over 'just getting by'
Around the District

Obituaries
James M. 'Jim' Murdock

Strange News
Updated 6:10 PM ET
Pachyderms outdo people in cross-species chow bout
New Zealand airline issues nude safety video
NYPD rookie makes arrest moments after graduation
Illinois cabbie uses deodorant to disarm attacker
Calif. students get X-rated version of class DVD
Police: Conn. teens mishear sex screams, beat man
Va. woman rides to landfill in trash bin
Man says bear mugged him for his Italian sandwich
More News

Comments or questions about the web site? Check the FAQ or...
Contact Peninsula Clarion New Media Director Vincent Nusunginya.
To send a letter to the editor, Peninsula Clarion letter submission page.

Peninsula Clarion, PO Box 3009, Kenai, AK 99611. Phone 907/283-7551
Copyright © Peninsula Clarion, a Division of Morris Communications. Privacy and terms of use.


This text is replaced by the Top Ads display.